• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Economists and accountants have diametrically opposite views of cost-volume profit (CVP) behaviour but only accountant's have a CVP model that is appropriate for assisting management with decision making

Extracts from this document...


[TYPE THE COMPANY NAME] BEA2003- Management Accounting Economists and accountants have diametrically opposite views of cost-volume profit (CVP) behaviour but only accountant's have a CVP model that is appropriate for assisting management with decision making Ryan Bebbington Word Count 1796 Economists and accountants have diametrically opposite views of cost-volume profit (CVP) behaviour but only accountant's have a CVP model that is appropriate for assisting management with decision making Cost volume profit analysis looks into the relationship between a firms fixed and variable costs and total revenues across a varying level of production. The model will give a predicted level of profit at a given level of production. There are many ways that CVP analysis can be useful for decision making, it is important to distinguish between the different applications of the Economists and Accountants interpretations, as well as other factors involved in decision making. CVP analysis is used in management decisions when forecasting production levels. To use this model effectively, Management will look at different scenarios of output, prices and costs, and see where the model predicts the firm's revenues will cover its total costs. This point is known as the breakeven point. Management can investigate the effects of price increases, changing costs from fixed to variable such as salaries to commission based pay. Managers can also investigate the outcomes from decisions such as making components in house or buying in, retaining or replacing equipment and marketing decisions. ...read more.


The Accountant's interpretation of the fixed cost curve is different to the Economist's view because it meets the Y axis at a higher point, which indicates that the Accountants believe that firms are committed to a higher minimum level of fixed costs. This is because although a firm may reduce its fixed costs to a lower level, as in the Economist's interpretation, the firm can only do this by redundancies and shutting down plants. As the Accountants model only represents a relevant range, the fixed costs cannot be reduced to this level in the short run, when this interpretation is extended outside of the relevant range, a stepped fixed cost and total function will be seen, as in figure 3. The other difference is that the revenue function is linear. This is because in the short run, firms cannot change the price of their products easily; it may also be because of firms competing on non-price, rather than price competition. As Accountants make no attempt to extend the revenue function outside of the relevant range, there is no need to model the firm's decrease in product price to increase demand. The Accountant's interpretation of the Cost Volume Profit model is more appropriate for Management decisions, as management decisions are not concerned with long term information. This is because the Board of Directors will be making the firms long term decisions. ...read more.


If management are not aware of the assumptions made in the data, then they will be unable to draw relevant conclusions from the information. The assumptions i are that all other variables remain constant; there is a constant sales mix, total costs and revenues are linear functions of output, profits are calculated using variable costing, the analysis only applies to the relevant range, costs can be divided into fixed and variable elements, it only applies to the short term, and fixed costs do not change. In conclusion, the Accountant's interpretation of the CVP analysis, as shown by the underlying assumptions, will allow managers to develop a more relevant understanding of the information, so that it can be used more effectively in decision making. If managers tried to use the economists CVP graph, the cost of gathering and interpreting the data would be high, as well as making the information more difficult to understand and less reliable. In the real world, the Accountant's model may be considered too simplistic, as it relies on many assumptions and conditions, which are often not met. This is why it important to understand that the Accountant's CVP model may not be applicable. For the CVP analysis to be effective, managers must be aware of the limitations of the model, otherwise they will be unprepared for any deviations from the outputs of the model. i Drury C. 2004. Management and Cost accounting 6th edition P263-286 ?? ?? ?? ?? Candidate Number: 018255 Management Accounting BEA2003 Ryan Bebbington ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Accounting section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Accounting essays

  1. The Importance of Communication in Accounting. Todays accountant, especially within the managerial accounting realm, ...

    Well thought out questions also help insure and clarify perceptions on the part of all parties involved. Questions also show another that one is listening and helps with the listening process itself. (Walters, 2001) When auditors do their job correctly, management will receive accurate information in regarding risk identification and

  2. Discuss and critically evaluate the role of management accountants in providing relevant information to ...

    By doing so, organization have broad focus on how will and accurate the information help managers in different levels example sales managers, production managers, human resources managers, etc. to do a better job and determinate what substitute products to consider in decision making.

  1. An Analysis Of harmonization issues of accounting standards

    0.456 0.213 0.055 0.007 0.003 The numbers shown in the table 4-9 above indicates, that in 2003 and 2004 the p-value was more than 0.1, which indicates that there are no significant differences are existing between the net assets based on CAS and IFRS; but there are differences which are

  2. Contemporary issues in management accounting - Target costing,Life cycle costing andQuality ...

    It will be thoroughly applicable in cases where the operating costs may be much more than the initial procurement or acquisition costs. After taking all the above into account we may as well arrive at what is known as benefit to cost ratio, implying the ratio of benefits(in monetized terms)

  1. Working Capital Management

    In general, the nature of the product, hold on the market, quality of management and monopoly power would by and large determine the profit earned by a firm. A priori, it can be generalised that a firm dealing in a high quality product, having a good marketing arrangement and enjoying

  2. Compare the impact of the activity-based costing model and the traditional based costing model ...

    However, the profit margin percentage is low for the S3 lens, where the company has a strong capability, but high on the newest, CL5 lens. So management starts to believe that there are perhaps problems with their costing system. Maybe the S3 lens is overcosted and CL5 lens is undercosted.

  1. ABC Costing Vs Traditional costing

    ABM is a dynamic method for continuous improvement and firms can have a built in competitive cost advantage so it can continuously add value to both its stakeholders and customers. Major (2007) states that changes within the last couple of decades have led to a new competitive business environment.

  2. Financial statement analysis

    in debt stemming from the diana ferrari acquisition which, in turn, produced a domino effect of an increase in receivables, inventories, interest-bearing liabilities and net assets. Return on Financial Leverage As a result of the use of leverage to support capital structure, shareholders of both firms have witnessed some major peaks and valleys in terms of financial gains.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work