• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evidence shows that it is easier to talk about organisational change than to implement such change effectively. Discuss

Extracts from this document...


Evidence shows that it is easier to talk about organisational change than to implement such change effectively. Discuss. Introduction: Technology explosion and globalisation have dramatically accelerated the pace of change in modern organisations (Prastacos 2002). Organisational Change (OC) has become a compulsion in order to maintain competitive edge or be successful in modern businesses and a difficult process to implement in practice due to its complex nature (Hamel et al, 1996; Illinitich et el, 1996 Cited in Prastacos, 2002). There are a number of theorists who have made suggestions in literature and presented their model of implementing change in organisations with certainty of success. e.g. Beer and Nohria, 2002; Pascale and Athose, 1981; Scott- Morton, 1991; Bullock and Batten, 1985; Lewin, 1951; Lippitt et al, 1958; Frohman et al, 1976; Ackerman, 1982; Bruke, 1982, 1994; Beer et al, 1990; MaCalman & Paton, 1992; Walton, 1995; Kottler, 1995 (Cited in Prastacos et al, 2002; Lanning, 2001). However, only 30% of the efforts of implementing the change in organisations are effective (Strebel, 1996; Siegal, 1996). From the practical personal experience of managing the change in a small scale company in India and examples of failures of organisations like Fumac, Philips, Ford, Nissan and literature in the field, the author opinions that it is easier to talk about organisational change than implement it effectively. ...read more.


Dexter (1994) point out that the universal models of change management are inadequate to address each organisations needs according to its culture and particular situation. The management have to be extra careful in choosing the right strategy for implementing the change. It cannot afford the risk of blindly applying the standard change recipe and hope it will work (Owen, A, 1986). Turbulent times demand different approaches in varied circumstances (Dexter, 1994), so the management should be smart enough to choose a "contingency model" which will enable to change strategies to achieve "optimum fit" with the changing circumstances. Managers also need to be able to interact effectively with employees who posses different values and work orientation (Smith et al 1998). 2) Negligence of human factors: One of the main reasons for difficulty in implementing the OC is the negligence of human factors over the technical side of organisational change by the management (Siegal et al, 1996). All of the processes of OC directly or indirectly deal with or influence the employees. It implies that OC means personal change for employees (Bovey. 2001). OC requires participation of employees who have to change themselves so that organisational change can be a success (Evans, 1994). ...read more.


R., 2007). Communication has a key role to play in determining the level of resistance. A poorly managed change communication results in rumours and higher level of resistance from employees to change by exaggerating the negative aspects of change. Sometimes there is a high level of uncertainty during change about the individual implications and the outcome which affects the employee's readiness to change. When organisational change results in down sizing and employee lose their jobs; the job-insecurity of survivors will have a big negative effect on the employees' readiness to change (Elving, 2005) Conclusion: The extent of difficulties in effectively implementing the OC depends on the extent of resources' spent on planning the careful strategies for OC. However in general the nature of the process of change implementation is complex and difficult to put effectively in practice. The management have to consider all of the above mentioned complex aspects OC for a planning the strategy. It is easy to understand by analysing case studies, how and why a particular organisation failed in effectively implementing the change. Even though the number of theories produced is huge, the statistic of failure to effectively implement the change is as high as 70% (Strebel, 1996; Siegal, 1996).Thus it proves that it is easier to talk about organisational change than to implement such change effectively. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Management Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Management Studies essays

  1. Strategic Management - CARREFOUR CASE ANALYSIS

    * SYNERGY o There is a high level of synergy among Carrefour's product offerings. By operating a variety of formats for its retail operations, it achieves synergy in its procurement and distribution channels. A Carrefour convenience store benefits from the buying power generated through the operation of Carrefour's hypermarkets, and vice versa.

  2. How can change affect an organisation and what impact might it have on employees? ...

    Let the employees know what the reason for change is. A large portion of the success of the 'change' is dependant upon the employees understanding of the final goal 'the future of the organisation'. If they have a different idea of what the change is aiming for then perhaps it may not be successful.

  1. Leadership Theories - this review seeks to determine which theoretical perspectives, theories and schools ...

    is base on utilizing the competence model developed by another organization, but it has the disadvantage of not considering the culture and needs of the borrowing company (Ibid). The borrowed-and-tailored approach is an intermediate type of approach, since it combines using the competence model of another corporation, but modifying it to adapt to the organization's needs and culture.

  2. Managing Change in Organization

    > Due to company's good reputation about its products & services among the customers, it is always now focused towards excellent customer services strategies in order to attain highest level of customer satisfaction. Structure of Salman & Associates:- The structure of the company was organic in nature.

  1. Managing Change in Organisations. Examples from Beximco Pharma Ltd of Bangladesh. Develop systems ...

    *?A sense that skills and abilities of people are under-utilised or concerns about a lack of commitment from employees, *?The need to introduce changes in technology or working practices, *?Workers feeling over-controlled by supervision or by the process or jobs seen as being boring; *?Concerns about ineffective communications or poor performance indicators; *?Fractious relationships between managers and the managed.

  2. Innovation For Business Success. It is possible to be innovative in both large ...

    low cost countries on scale or cost, but it pursued, as its name says, a specialty or niche strategy in premium markets. These days the small runs of over 1000 different products the Company use to make to order have given rise to a highly efficient business that now produces

  1. A critical review of Biedenbach et al, 2008, The Challenge of Organizing Change in ...

    capability is special because it depends on intangible knowledge and skills which are not imitable by the organizations competitors. Craig (1996) agrees that capability is something an organization needs to develop in order to compete, and a dynamic capability is essential in hypercompetition.

  2. Enterprise rent-a-car total quality management

    of new recruits also has a significant impact on the customer satisfaction. As the Pareto analysis demonstrates the other primary sources of customer satisfaction are receiving the correct car group and specification of vehicle of which stem from employees insufficient on the job training.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work