• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month


Extracts from this document...


Examine the contention that how managers manage their people resources/assets will be shaped by either a 'conventional personnel' or a 'human resource management' approach. What differences exist between these two approaches, and where does this lead to in the management of 'people in organisations'? Draw upon service industry examples and literature to add weight to your analysis, discussion and conclusions. The management of people in organisations can take many shapes and forms and has evolved rapidly over time. This is due to the changing role of the manager within organisations.. There are two methods of people management which have existed and still do exist within organisations today which will be examined in this essay. These methods are Personnel Management (PM) and Human Resource Management (HRM). This essay will discuss the history of the two methods, the key features and the implications of the methods, by implementing them in key areas of a managers responsibilities and then applying them to an industry - which in this case will be the service sector. Before we discuss the two methods of management, it is best to first discuss why we manage human resources. This is best described by Maund (2001): "...the role of Human Resources is to assist in the long term viability of a business or a non-profit making enterprise...While it is recognised that other resources are essential to the efficacy of an organisations business, for example finance and production, it is the human resources that remain virtually limitless in their capacity to make an impact - both positive and negative - on an organisation (Maund 2001. p.17)". Agazadeh (2003) shows in this quote "Successful HR Managers and departments have a significant strategic impact on their organisations (Agazadeh. 2003. p.201) that he also believes that good human resource management is at the core of a successful organisation. Managing people well, especially within the service sector, means happier employees which in turn means happier customers who will return in the future ensuring the long term success of an organisation. ...read more.


The employees worked harder because they knew they were being treated differently and were not being seen as workers but as individuals.. This became knows as the 'someone upstairs cares' principal (accel-team 2007). Another two differing approaches to management by HRM and PM is the way in which they deal with business goals. According to Cole (2002) PM focuses on how a business goal will affect employees before it is challenged, but HRM has a total commitment to business goals. Previously, restrictive Trade Unions meant business goals had to come second to keeping employees happy. Of course this all changed. The 1990's became known as the 'decade of the consumer' which meant that employees concerns now came second to customer needs. These attitudes light up another significant difference in the two methods, how they deal with change. PM will support change but unlike HRM it will not encourage it. Change is becoming increasing important for today's businesses. Rosenfeld and Wilson (1999) note customer's demand changes constantly and a business needs to adapt quickly if it is going to stay competitive. As mentioned previously by Boella (2001), the service sector is an ever growing industry which contributes hugely to the UK's economy every year. With over 10 million employees in the sector and the majority of them coming face to face with customers as part of their job, it is essential that they convey the best image possible of the organisation. As mentioned before, Mound (2001) describes the strongest resource an organisation has is its human resources and when managed well can have the largest impact on an organisations success. One company's who takes great pride in their image by looking after their employees, is John Lewis. John Lewis is major UK department store with 23 shops across the country. An article entitled 'The ethical route to service quality at John Lewis Partnership' by Dandy (1996) ...read more.


Reference List Aghazadeh, SM. 2003. The Future of Human Resource Management. Work Study. Volume 52 Number 4 pp.201-207 Accel Team. 2007. Human Relations Contributions. Elton Mayo's Hawthorne Experiments [online] Available from:<http://www.accel-eam.com/motivation/hawthorne_03.html> [Accessed December 11 2007} Beardwell, I., Holden, L., Claydon, T. 2004. Human Resource Management: A Contemporary Approach. 4th ed. Harlow: Pearson Education Limited Bloisi, W. 2006. Management and Organisational Behaviour. 2nd European ed. Maidenhead: McGraw-Hill Education Boella, M. 2000. Human Resource Management In The Hospitality Industry. 7th ed. Cheltenham: Stanley Thornes. Clement, B. 2005. Protest forces Asda Christmas discount U-turn. . The Independent. October 24 Cole, G. 2003. Personnel and Human Resource Management. 4th ed. London: Continuum. Cornelius, N. 2001. HRM. A Managerial Perspective. 2nd ed. London: Thomson. Dandy, J. 1996. Celebrate and record: The ethical route to service quality at John Lewis Partnership. Managing Service Quality, Volume 6 Number 5 (4) August, pp.297-303. Dictionary.com. 2007. Definition.'Nurture' [online] Available from:<www.dictionary.reference.com/browse/nurture> {Accessed December 10 2007] The Guardian. 2007. John Lewis Employees get record �155m bonus [online] Available from: http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2007/mar/08/retail.money [Accessed December 11 2007] John Lewis Partnership. 2007. Employer of Distinction [online] Available from: < http://www.johnlewispartnership.co.uk/Display.aspx?&MasterId=bb9e575f-01e3-4228-8da5-7f782f182dd4&NavigationId=55> [Accessed December 10 2007] Kessler, I. 1991. Workplace Industrial Relations in Local Government. Employee Relations, Volume 13 Issue 2 Maun, L. 2001. An Introduction to Human Resource Management. Hampshire: PALGRAVE. Rosenfeld, H., Wilson, D. 1999. Managing Organisations. 2nd ed. Maidenhead: McGraw-Hill Sandelands, E. 1997. Starbucks - Investing in People as a Route to Profit and Growth. Industrial and Commercial Training, Volume 29 Number 4 1997 pp.137-138 Scotsman Newspaper. 2007. John Lewis announce record profits [online] Available from: < http://business.scotsman.com/retail.cfm?id=188716200> [Accessed December 11 2007] Storey, J. 1992. Developments In The Management of Human Resources. Oxford: Blackwell This Is Money. 2006. Companies and Markets. Starbucks Set for World Domination [online] Available from : http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/investing-and-markets/article.html?in_article_id=413376&in_page_id=3&ct= [Accessed December 10 2007] This is Money. 2006. News. Starbucks sales rocket to �244m [online] Available from: http://www.thisismoney.co.uk/news/article.html?in_article_id=411577&in_page_id=2 [Accessed December 10 2007] Welsh, R. 2007 Priorities of People Management October 17. [lecture] Edinburgh: Queen Margaret University. Welsh, R. 2007 The Service Sector. October 9. [lecture] Edinburgh. Queen Margaret ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. The Role Of Human Resource Management. Theories and Case Study of HRM ...

    programs so that they respond to the personal needs of employees, they help employees meet their personal needs, and wherever possible they offer assistance to help employees meet family and personal needs. However with reference to Nadler and Tushman model, there are four organisational components that impact on the four

  2. Critically discuss the Best Fit approach to strategic human resource management (HRM)

    Best fit policies are contingent. They are developed or modified to sustain a strong strategy. This means that an organisation's reward system and other practices will be matchless and should possibly change with major adjustments to organisational strategy so that organisation can benefit from its flexibility and adapt to constantly changing environment.

  1. To what extent is HRM different from conventional Personnel Management? Is it the same ...

    Leading According to Hellriegel,D.& Slocum,J.W.(1993:11), leading "involves communicating with and motivating others to perform the tasks necessary to achieve the organization's objectives. And leading is not done after planning and organizing end, it is crucial to those functions, too".

  2. This IHRM report is based on a large food retail company in UK, Malone ...

    Besides practising in the organisation, Malone Superbuy Ltd can send their employees for training to different places to better understand the job and create a different environment. 4.3.3 Mentoring Mentoring is whereby senior employee in Malone Superbuy Ltd guides the new employees as part of the training (Beardwell and Holden, 1997).


    Training for employees should also be considered (Williams 2002). Farr (1993) notes the need for the requirement of training to be given to employees to receive feedback in a non-defensive manner. Bretz, Milkovich and Read (1992) also suggest that a lack of training of appraisees may cause discrepancies between expected and actual performance of the process, and associated satisfaction.

  2. Employee turnover and key personnel retention; a review and analysis of Trident UK

    However the author is anonymous and there is no verification available on the information provided. Steve Truelove (1995) is one author whom associates employee motivation to their training and development needs; Truelove recognises that 'people vary in their needs and drives.'(Truelove 1995: 292)

  1. Cape Breton Wallcoverings - HRM analysis

    That is, employee?s ability to perform the task as described in the job description was to be developed. Training was also required in order to reduce the risk of injury on the job. As the machinery used was highly technical and the employees had no idea of how to operate

  2. Human Resource Management - HRM approaches, HR Planning, Job Evaluation, Reward Management system and ...

    The pay grade is associated with a pay range that is defined by a minimum and a maximum pay rate. Job evaluation plans have been in use for approximately 75 years in the public and private sectors. There are many variations to the design a job evaluation plan.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work