Interviewing - My experience with recruitment interviewing has shown me that it does not deserve its popularity. Discuss.

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

Business Enterprise Year 1 OFB Assignment (Term 1) "My experience with recruitment interviewing has shown me that it does not deserve its popularity." Interviewing is a technique used by almost all firms in the process of recruitment selection. This process of recruitment involves other elements depending on the type of position, number of candidates for the job, and the difficulty of the position. In this report I will be pointing out the advantages and disadvantages of interviewing as a process of recruitment as well as drawing on my own experiences of interviewing. For many years employers have seen the interview process as the most vital stage of recruitment selection. The industrial relation service carried out a survey showing that "80 per cent regarded the formal selection interview as the most important source of evidence in making the final decision." (Price, 1997) In past years experts have began to question the interview with the traditional interview given poor reviews (Cowling/Mailer, 1998). This enhances the view interviews do not deserve their popularity as a form of selection. The traditional method of interviewing has been dismissed by Cowling and Mailer they are quoted "information about candidates is often inconsistent and interviewers frequently rate the same candidate quite differently." (Cowling/Mailer, 1998). Another method of interviewing used by firms is the structured interview this is thought to be a much better method of interviewing but it does have disadvantages.

Middle

A clever applicant can persuade the interviewer that they are the right person for the job emphasizing strong points and covering up weak areas this may lead them to being successful when they maybe be inappropriate for the job (Price, 1997). The way an interview is set out is important too. Interviewing is a poor method of selection if the room layout is wrong and if there are not the right amount of interviewers. For example a large table between the interviewer and candidate can create a barrier and make the candidate feel intimidated. A large number of people on your interview board may also intimidate a candidate. They're maybe too many people on your board, which may ask irrelevant questions which lengthen the interview and increase the unease of the candidate (Bennett, 1994). An interview board may only consist of one person known as the singleton interview. This can make an interview unfair as you may make a better impression on other people and personal prejudice may resolve who gets the job (Price, 1997). The way an interview is marked can disrupt a candidate I noticed in my role play assessment that the candidate was wondering what I was writing and that shifted her attention from the interview which was not a good thing because she wasn't concentrating on the questions asked.

Conclusion

When questions are prepared you can see what answers different candidates gave to the same questions and see who came up with the best answers under pressure (Cowling/Mailer, 1998). With other many other methods of selection you can't put candidates in the same pressure situation and with unstructured questions you can't compare candidates as well. Using a panel or board although possibly intimidating for the candidate it lets leaders of all departments in a large firm see where there prospective employee fits in within there department. This gives all parties involved with the employee position to see him/her at one time and save time for people in the firm. Other factors supporting recruitment interviewing are its relatively inexpensive and its expected and accepted by virtually all candidates in fact they might think something is wrong with a firm that doesn't conduct interviews. With using interviews as a form of recruitment there are many things you have to think about to get the interview perfect for the selection process. This is why using the interview is not always the best way to recruit someone for example in a job involving manual labour. It probably doesn't deserve the popularity the interview has but it will always be around and the best way forward for it is to improve it and it would become a really good tool in the selection process.

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. Human Resource Management: Development, Activities, Planning and Recruitment

    - the Home Office's Immigration and Nationality Directorate - for a work permit. Only the Human Resources Division is authorised to make the application. The process can take up to three months and staff cannot under any circumstances be employed until permission is given.

  2. Recruitment and Selection

    Linking back to SWOT and PEST, through the use of technology and building on the company's strengths, such as on their brand name, more E-recruitment methods these days are being chosen. Such problems like unfair discrimination and costly posting of relevant job documentation can be avoided, as the candidate or

  1. Context of Employee Relations and Industrial Conflict

    was terminated in connection with the dispute or if the termination of his employment was one of the circumstances giving rise to the dispute. * A third definition in Jobseekers Act 1995, s.35 is the widest. For purposes of the Jobseekers Act a trade dispute is "any dispute between employers

  2. Human Resource Management - Recruitment and selection.

    The informal organisation is a powerful controlling force. The third stage of the Hawthorne studies was about 14 men in the Bank Wiring room. The researchers discovered that the group managed the level of output and that incentives offered by the company had little effect.

  1. The aim of the report was to analyse the recruitment and selection method of ...

    There are techniques such as critical-incident or workshop analysis, which could carry out reliable source for the job descriptions, but these are time consuming and need experience to apply them in the actual circumstances. * Person specifications The Personnel Department, with the approval of the Treasurer defines this kind of specification.

  2. Recruitment & Selection

    Usually, a skills gap analysis is carried out to check all of the staff's skills and then measures it against the skills required. This will enable the Met to see if the staff already in the organisation has what it takes to cut it in the job they are advertising.

  1. Entrepreneurship, my bachelor project is to analyze the situation of the ethnic female entrepreneurs ...

    Even though Marshall pointed out a list of entrepreneur's characteristics, however in neoclassical era, a definition of entrepreneurship was not explained. Khalil agreed that neoclassical theory did not provide explanation on entrepreneurship due to a misleading dichotomy that supports the theory between everyday action and entrepreneurial action.

  2. The Recruitment & Selection Process of The Canadian Armed Forces Vs. Scotiabank

    Any non-entry level position will always be filled internally. Military experience cannot be gained in any other field and therefore they must choose from an internal pool of members who meet the specific job requirements. Another reason for this is that the CF follows a Rank system, you need a

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.