• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Leadership Nature or Nurture? Discuss with reference to theories whilst critically evaluating available evidence.

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐Is Leadership Nature or Nurture? Discuss with reference to theories whilst critically evaluating available evidence. Abstract The nature vs. nurture debate is a long standing issue not only in relation to leadership, but in general terms as well. Researchers have failed to reach a consensus on whether leadership is an inborn phenomenon or whether it can be learnt. This essay will focus on leadership role occupancy rather than the effectiveness of already appointed leadership. Role occupancy is whether people occupy positions of leadership in organisations. Different theories relating to role occupancy are discussed, detailing evidence supporting these theories. While the theories take centre stage, different aspects of leadership are also discussed. Keywords: Leadership emergence; role occupancy; traits; context Introduction Leadership is a central component to organisational performance, however the definition remains illusive. Effective and ineffective leadership means different things to different people. Hogan et al. (1994) described leadership as the act of persuading other people in the pursuit of a common goal, a goal that is important for the welfare of the individual and the group as a whole. There lies a multitude of research on the subject of leadership. ...read more.


This was found because the students assigned as prison guards acted with cruelty towards those cast as prisoners claiming that they were merely playing the role they were supposed to. Although the above is an extreme case, the underlying principals remain unchanged; the students acted as their roles dictated. This can be applied to leadership in the way that anyone put into a leadership position will assume this role regardless of any individual characteristics. Generalising from this study is difficult as it has come under great criticism, because not all the guards acted similarly, others were fair and did not behave inhumanely. Integrated Approach Both these theories look at leadership as an effect of a single perspective, overlooking the combined effect. A more plausible approach is to look at leadership as an interaction of both nature and nurture. In relation to the study that found personality as a good predictor, Johnson et al. (1998) noted that personality itself is dependent on genetic and environmental factors and so the extent to which each is responsible for leadership is not clear. Zhang et al. (2009) found a noteworthy result on their study on a sample of 89 pairs of identical and 54 pairs of fraternal twins. ...read more.


A rather undermined application in organisations refers to the implicit leadership theory; this is that of follower training. Schyns and Meindl (2005) advocate that revealing to followers the errors of their perceptions of leaders, if any, can allow them to have more realistic expectations and therefore are more capable of selecting a competent leader. Conclusion Although it is clear that leaders possess certain qualities that make them stand out, the evidence suggests that it is not because they were destined for such positions. Instead, authors should look at leadership as a complex structure, dependent on many aspects that are not at the control of the individual. The context of the task, the task itself and the perception of the follower are some of the conditions that may influence leadership role occupancy. Past research has been too simplistic and focused on identifying a single variable, hence the debate of whether leadership is nature or nurture. This essay has shown that a more rewarding avenue to pursue is that of nature and nurture intertwined, although some authors may be so set in their ways that they reject anything alien to their own ideas. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. No one best style of leadership

    Clarke and Pratt identify four stages of leadership. The theorists suggest that most are suited to a particular stage of the development of the business, and that it is not always possible for managers to effectively change between each role.

  2. Management and leadership within health visiting team in Edmonton locality.

    Additional factors influencing team effectiveness are: * Organisational context that support working. * Effective team leadership. The team working guide (adapted from Markiewicz and West (1996 and 2001) provides tools that our team can adopt to assess how well it is working together and practical advice and guidance for team members which can help our team work together more effectively.

  1. HRM best practise case study. Research into HRM at a branch of Barclays ...

    11 of staff said they did work in teams and relating to that the next question asked dif they liked working in teams and the result was 8 said yes 3 said no. the manager stated that when management isn't present it is vital to work in teams in order

  2. What are the attributes of an effective leader? Discuss with reference to well ...

    People follow because they desire to. Level 3, production, is interested in results. People follow because of the leader's achievements in the organisation. Level 4, people development, is specified by reproduction in other words, people follow as a result of what the leader has accomplished for them.

  1. Transformational Leadership. Transformational leadership involves the provision of leader influence on subordinates, but ...

    Best known classification of leadership styles is of K. Levin. Levin describes three main styles of leadership: autocratic, democratic and liberal leadership styles. Meanwhile, R. Likert classifies leaders as either people-oriented or task-oriented. Nevertheless, empirical studies indicate that there is no unique relation between the characteristics of leadership style and its effectiveness (Storey, 2004).

  2. Leadership- Winston Churchill

    concluded after examining over 100 studies that there are five traits that tend to differentiate leaders from followers these being, intelligence, self confidence, dominance, level of energy and activity and task relevant knowledgeiv. I feel that Churchill fits into these five areas e.g.

  1. International Leadership & HRM The effective leadership model

    And through the in-depth discussion internationalization and localization of different characteristics, to make examples that should notice items and skills in leadership. 1. The Leadership Style There have discussing in academics, which is the best leadership; what kind of leadership style can bring remarkable performance for organizations.

  2. The link between national culture and leadership style. Can one expect discrepancies between the ...

    GLOBE Project In 2002 Robert House finished his research which is named GLOBE project. GLOBE is abbreviation for Global Leadership and Organizational Behaviour Effectiveness. This research focuses on leadership and culture and the interrelation between them. The GLOBE project took examples from 61 countries.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work