- Estimated sales we wish to achieve in the UK market
- Based on above information, it is not difficult to find the relationship between a newspaper and on-line news. Users of the Internet for reading and researching are becoming a common trend. Moreover, the AFR’s circulation has decreased in comparison to the year 2001, however the web hits has increase. Therefore, in order to keep our goals in line with the trends we must provide on-time news over the Internet (through NewsStand). We will do this by specifically targeting the UK market.
- The estimated sales we wish to achieve in the UK market depends upon the people who decide to buy, it is quite difficult to judge. The optimal view for the UK population is around 62% people who use the Internet, therefore, for the sales and pricing strategy we must encourage the first time reader. We estimate our price per copy in two different sections, which are Monday to Friday edition and Monday to Saturday edition. For the Monday to Friday edition, average sells $2.5 and number of copies sold by 350,000. The total revenue would get $890,369.36. For the Monday to Saturday edition, average sells might be lower, around $2.3, and number of copies sold by 150,000. The total revenue would get $355,887.19. This offers great growth potential in the future.
3.2.2 Market Forecast
- Brief history of Fairfax Business
- Fairfax Business Media magazines has moved forward steadily over the year. Fairfax has launched its first publication in Mandarin. It has also continued to progress its development of its offshore magazine businesses in the UK and Asia.
(reference:)
- Cyber- success: online growth- the Fairfax trading room represents an important milestone in online services for the company. Since its introduction in 1997, the site has attracted more than 22,000 subscribers. In average, is 233,000 hits per day (The business of Fairfax, p.67)
- The 2002 financial reports indicated that the consolidated profit attributable to the consolidated entity for the financial year was $53,660,000 (2001: $128,069,000). (reference:)
- The publications, which the Fairfax group covers, are newspapers and magazines. Some examples are The Sydney Morning Herald, Herald Classifieds, The Sun- Herald, The Age, The Australian Financial Review and Fairfax Community Newspapers. Therefore to gain a better understand of the market share of AFR in Fairfax Business, it might be a good idea to go through the readership of each. (reference: )
- Comparing the newspapers within the Fairfax business group: The table below shows that the readership of the AFR has increased for Monday to Friday. The table of readership shows that the AFR M-F has increased 3.6% in March 03 as compared with last year.
- Over this last 12 months The Australian Financial Review has demonstrated a high degree of commitment to its audience and has become Australia's fastest growing newspaper with readership up 11.6% M-F and 12.5% for the Weekend edition, and circulation is up 3.8% M-F and 9.4% on the weekend. Adapting to change, it has developed new sections for both readers and advertisers. Expanding reach and adding depth of coverage, the AFR has focused on explaining and examining the increasingly complex issues that arise from global business activity. (reference: )
-
The Circulation and readership of AFR in Australian market (as December 2002) (reference: )
- The December 2002 Audit Bureau of Circulation results list circulation for The
Australian Financial Review Monday to Friday edition as 89,779 and the Weekend Financial Review circulation as 86,256
- Readership: brief overview
- From the above information, it can be seen that Fairfax is in a good position to extend to overseas markets. Therefore, the best tool might be through the publisher of NewsStand Inc.
- NewsStand Inc. is a digital/electronic partner for premier publishers of newspapers, magazines and printed media. Publications delivered by NewsStand are in demand by paying customers in more than 100 countries. Headquartered in Austin, Texas and it is privately held. (Newsstand Inc.: about company)
- In regards to the Fairfax financial report 2002, profits and circulation has decreased, while the Internet hints has increased. Thus, this offers great opportunities for AFR to become a publisher on NewsStand Inc. The Market share we wish to achieve is 30% by the first year, then increase to 50% over the next two years. The way we will measure market share is to compare it to subscriptions to “The Australian” (the only other newspaper which is also related to Australian news currently on NewsStand). We hope and believe it to be possible to become the market leaders in Australian business news in the UK and Globally.
3.2.2.1 Market characteristic, Developments & Trends
In looking at these topics we must look at a number of factors such as:
- Five forces analysis. The barriers to entry are very low for many newspapers and
Magazines entering the UK market. Customer buying power is stuck at the loyalty stage. The graph of five forces looks at the profit potential market. (see Appendix 2)
-
The barriers to entry. These barriers reduce competition and enhance profit potential
for protected competitors. However for our project the barriers for AFR to enter into the UK market are quite low. The reasons are,
- Distribution channel: because of electronic distribution, therefore, on-time delivery, cost reductions are achieved due to less paper, printing and postage and selling digital versions of back issues. (NewsStand Inc.: about product/ service). Also the AFR will not actually be sold physically in the UK as such it will be sold over the Internet, thus most laws governing the print media and restrictions may not apply.
- NewsStand Inc. provides clear terms to follow for the use of publishers and readers. For example, NewsStand Inc. provides clear examples of how they wish to run their business, some security rules, price and content and monitor controls. Thus these are what will restrict us not so much the UK laws.
- As it stands currently, “The Australian” is the only other global paper (that is on NewsStand) that can prevent us from becoming market leaders in Australian business news.
- The economic and political environment (in both countries) currently is in a good condition to launch this project. However things can and do change quite dramatically, so some caution and monitoring should be considered here.
- We should keep a strong look out for other potential companies entering into the market.
- It is fairly easy to exit the market. Fairfax simply has to tell NewsStand of its intentions to leave and for NewsStand to take them off their web page (some contractual advice may have to be taken into account).
- If AFR wants to leave the market, this decision may affect the brand name of the Fairfax business group and might decrease the number of loyalty customers.
- This can be competitive due to the fact that there are already a lot newspapers and magazines from various countries currently on NewsStand Inc. However, there is only one newspaper which is currently providing news on Australia (The Australian). Therefore, for the competitive advantage and market attractiveness for the AFR we must not only carefully monitor our progress but also The Australians. Thus, the AFR now is faced with how to penetrate the market and become a leader in the UK market. (see Appendix 3,4)
- Based on the competitive advantage and market attractiveness, the portfolio analysis and strategic market plans (see Appendix 5), show that the AFR is in the offensive and growth stage in order to gain a competitive advantage.
- As the terms and conditions are very similar between different newspapers on NewsStand Inc., the buyer can easy switch between different newspapers. However, the competitive advantage that the AFR has is that it provides a high quality of Australian content in the business market. It is very useful for people who are doing business with Australian firms or who have investments in Australia. Therefore, it is in a very strong competitive advantage to attract loyal customers. Moreover, in order to improve the newspaper’s contents. AFR did some innovative changes such as,
- Information. This section is dedicated to reporting global and local information, technology developments covering fields such as Internet commerce, telecommunications, networking, software and a host of supporting industry issues. The special pullout section each Tuesday is the most recent development of this section, ensuring additional editorial, colour availability’s and positions for advertisers to stand out from the crowded IT market.
- Weekend Edition. Since its inception in 1997, the Weekend Edition Australian Financial Review has established itself as a must-read for people of discerning taste, while its unique reader profile affords unequalled reach into the elusive top-end of the Australian business market. In September 2001 the Weekend Edition was redesigned based on feedback from our readers and advertisers. Relevant business news is delivered through sections such as EGN, Business, and Perspective. At the heart of the paper is Smart Money, offering advice on how to make money and how to keep it. The new Observer & After Hours sections are all about lifestyle, from global events and controversy to travel, sport and wine. As Australia's only weekend business and financial newspaper Fairfax is able to reach business readers while they are in a relaxed frame of mind.
- The pricing strategy: The customer cannot negotiate the price; the price is fixed. Therefore, this is in the supplier- AFR’s favour.
- Customers buying decision behavior (see Appendix 6) might belong in the “Variety- Seeking buying behavior”. Customers may have low involvement but see significant perceived brand differences. Customers often do a lot of brand switching on NewsStand Inc. as there is a lot to choose from. However, we hope to build brand loyalty for the customer of the AFR as it will be the only newspaper which provides unmatched Australia financial news. Thus making it more attractive to customers who have investment in Australian business, who are considering investment in Australian business or who are ex pat Australian’s in the UK.
- Product life cycle. The product life cycle maybe a way to understanding the product substitutes involved in the UK newspaper market. It might be said that the AFR is in the growth stage in the UK market. Due to new technology being introduced – the Internet, we are able to launch ourselves into UK market through it. The product substitutes involved in the growth stage are slight. However, once more Australian newspaper publishers become members of NewsStand Inc., the product substitutes will increase. There are two major reasons for AFR to become a publisher on NewsStand Inc.,
- People can read on- time news, and get the whole newspaper through it (not just a few sections as showed in afr.com) from anywhere in the world.
- NewsStand service: You can print out a digital copy of the paper which is delivered with NewsStand's technology solution, publishers in a traditionally formatted print media to readers via the Internet. The NewsStand Reader is just a part of NewsStand's patent-pending technology suite. It converts a publisher’s existing source files into an electronic version of their publication. Subscribers simply download their favorite publications, and enjoy them just like their printed form.
- AFR is a member of the Fairfax business group. Therefore, it has strong financial support and sufficient organization capacity. So, AFR will have a strong supply background form the Fairfax group.
- The other element associated with supplier power is the cost structure of industry. That is the cost to set up AFR on NewsStand and promote it to the UK market. The set up cost is very low, as Fairfax will only get charged a delivery cost. So the main cost will be on the promotion (internal). The benefit for our customers in purchasing the AFR from NewsStand Inc., is that they receive the total paper, not only sections of it, as it is on afr.com.
- Our Target Market comprises of three categories:
- Ex-patriots of Australia living in the UK
- UK people who are currently doing business in Australia or with Australians
- UK people who want to do business in Australia or with Australians.
3.3 Competitor analysis
3.3.1 “The Press and Journal”
– Scotland’s leading regional newspaper
The Press and Journal is Britain's oldest daily newspaper, the country's largest regional morning newspaper, and the world's third-oldest English-language newspaper - dating back to 1746.
Today, the Press and Journal's parent company is Aberdeen Journals which, in turn, is part of the Northcliffe Newspapers Group Ltd.
Size, market share, coverage
The Press and Journal now sells around 96,253 (PriceWaterhouseCoopers Jan - Jun 2002) copies a day, in 7 different editions, making it (as far as we can establish) the most editionised daily newspaper in the world.
This site is published on behalf of the Press and Journal and evening Express newspapers by a team from Northcliffe Electronic Publishing, which is the Internet and electronic publishing arm of Northcliffe Newspapers. It is part of the Daily Mail and General Trust, publishers of the Daily Mail, Mail on Sunday and London Evening Standard.
Northcliffe Newspapers publishes 18 regional morning and evening newspapers across the country as well as hundreds of other weekly newspapers and many non-newsprint titles, and the team that brings you this site also publishes sites for those newspapers as well.
The Northcliffe Electronic Publishing:
- Mission: “The way to the hearts and hearths of the British people is through their local communities.”
- Extensive coverage: 20 Dailies, 18 Weekly Paid, 42 Weekly Free
- Circulation: Approximately 10 million copies per week reach over 6 in 10 adults per week.
- Local advantages: Serving local interests for 250 yeas.
- Strong brads
- Closeness to community
- Trust
- Influence
3.3.2 “Financial Times”
– Daily newspaper
The Financial Times, one of the world's leading business newspapers, which is recognised internationally for its authority, integrity and accuracy and services a growing audience of internationally minded business people. It provides extensive news, comment and analysis, the newspaper is printed in 19 cities across the globe, and it has a daily circulation of over 480,000 and a readership of more than 1.6 million people worldwide.
One can be subscribed to it from all over the world (as it is on NewsStand). Subscribers can view and print an electronic version of the paper. These pages are made available from 11pm London time the evening before the publication.
-
Product: There are three editions of the FT newspaper. Firstly for the UK, continental Europe, secondly for the US and lastly for international markets (with a new Asian edition due out in 2003). There is also the FT.com, the newspaper’s online partner.
-
Size, market share, coverage: The FT is the most international business newspaper in the world. It is printed in 20 cities, has a daily circulation of more than 470,000 and a readership of approximately 1.6 million people in 140 countries. Over the past five years, the average daily sales of the FT have increased by more than 30%.
-
Readers: The FT’s editorial perspective and international breadth attracts a unique audience of influential, affluent people in finance, business and politics that advertisers find particularly hard to reach. The typical FT reader earns over £100,000 and is involved in the international activities of their business. Un-typical readers include the President of the United States (the FT is the only non-US newspaper to be delivered to the White House every day) and the Chairman of the Federal Reserve Board Alan Greenspan (who has been known to turn up at White House briefings carrying only his copy of the FT).
- Five year financial record:
All figures are stated after Internet enterprises
+ Restated to reflect the rights issue of equity shares during 2000
* From continuing operations
# restated for the adoption of FRS 19
3.3.3 “The Australian”
- Australia’s national daily newspaper (reference: )
It was launched on July 15, 1964. The Saturday edition was renamed The Weekend Australian on July 2, 1977. In the year 2002, the weekday readership was 438,000 and weekend Australian readership was 917,000. In August 2001 it become one of NewsStand Inc publishers.
The Australian is available for download through NewsStand Inc. by about 17:00. Information about “The Australian” can provide insightful information for our competitor analysis (Source: Roy Morgan Readership Survey September 2002 ).
- Readers:
- Readers of The Australian are nearly 3 times more likely (than the population) to have an income over $60,000.
- 59% of The Australian's readers have a degree or diploma and 57% of The Weekend Australian readers
- 53% of readers of The Australian are in the AB socio-economic quintile
- 49% of readers of The Weekend Australian are in the AB socio-economic quintile
- 62% of The Australian readers are male
- 47% of The Weekend Australian readers are female
- Most readers are over the age of 35 years of age
- One in five (28%) readers of The Australia and 23% of readers of The Weekend Australian have an income over $60,000.
- 79% of readers of The Australian and The Weekend Australian have been on a holiday in the last 12 months.
- 57,000 readers of The Australian intend to buy a car in the next two years.
- 70% of readers of The Weekend Australian drank wine in the last 4 weeks.
(Source: Roy Morgan Readership Survey September 2002 )
- Numbers:
Weekday Circulation: 130,000
Weekday Readership: 438,000
Weekend Australian Circulation: 300,000
Weekend Australian Readership: 917,000
(Circulation Figures ABC September 2002
Readership Figures Roy Morgan Readership Survey September 2002 )
- The policies of “the Australian” on NewsStand:
- Printing Enabled
- Delivery: Monday to Saturday
-
Costs $1.20 per issue with a 2nd Download Fee of $0.25
3.4. Organisation’s assets and skills
John Fairfax Holdings Limited is Australia’s leading publishing group. The Australian Financial Review (AFR), The Sydney Morning Herald (SMH), The Age, BRW and The Sun-Herald are but some of its mastheads. Fairfax also publishes regional newspapers, customer and financial magazines. It also has a wholly owned Internet subsidiary which provides online, e-commerce and news interactivity.
“Fairfax has a market capitalisation of over $2.1 billion (November 2002). For the financial year ended June 30, 2002, Fairfax reported revenues of $1.19 billion and profit after tax and pre-significant items (previously classed as abnormals) of $90.2 million. Net profit after tax and significant items was $53.7 million. The Board announced a total dividend for the year of 11.5 cents per share, fully franked.” (Corporate profile, .
The Board of Directors consist of:
Dean Wills AO, Chairman
Frederick G. Hilmer AO, Chief Executive Officer
Mark Burrows
Sir Roderick Carnegie
David Gonski AO
Julia King
Roger Corbett
Ronald Walker AC CBE
Margaret Jackson
Executive Management Team consists of:
Fred Hilmer, Chief Executive Officer
Mark Bayliss, Chief Financial Officer
Nigel Dews, Managing Director, Commercial and Publisher, f2 Network
Brian Evans, Publisher and Editor-in-Chief, Fairfax Regional and Community Newspapers
Michael Gill, Publisher and Editor-in-Chief, Fairfax Business Media
Peter Graham, Director, Group Operations
Gail Hambly, Group General Counsel and Company Secretary
Greg Hywood, Publisher and Editor-in-Chief, The Age and Fairfax Magazines
Alan Revell, Publisher and Editor-in-Chief, Herald Publications
Mark Scott, Director, Organisation Development
Fairfax has dedicated itself to uphold its standard of excellence. This is set out it their corporate values, which follows:
In relation to Czinkota’s stage of Internationalisation, Fairfax would be up to product development in relation to putting the complete AFR onto . The stages are as follows:
Generating Ideas
- Fairfax has afr.com but it is not the complete paper (i.e. you can only obtain the complete paper in physical form).
- Fairfax also sells (a physical copy of) the SMH to the UK in 77 outlets. So there is already an established market.
- The idea of setting up on newsstand.com is a good one as readers in the UK can obtain the AFR complete electronically daily (we will be targeting the UK as there is already a tried channel of distribution).
Screening Ideas
- Need to discuss this with AFR and see what the thoughts are on it.
- Setting the AFR up over the net will hopefully lower costs in shipping or setting up small and costly print runs in the UK.
Business Evaluation
- Fairfax sees the need to compete in the electronic media. With the world changing constantly, media must present up to date information as it happens, so the internet is the likely avenue to achieve this.
- Australian business news is quite difficult to obtain overseas, so setting the AFR up on NewsStand for people to obtain this scarce information would be leading the market and it also creates a convenient and cost effective way of accessing it.
Product Development
- We must evaluate the cost of setting the AFR up on newsstand.com and see whether it will be cost effective.
Test Marketing
- Fairfax has consultants in the UK so we must consult them to do market research to see whether they believe it would be viable.
Product Introduction
-
If the test marketing were proven to be successful then the AFR would be launched on .
Fairfax has had previous experience with overseas ventures. It has a printing plant and offices in New Zealand. These seem to be going well.
It also has an established channel in the UK for the SMH. This was primarily set up for the Olympic and Commonwealth Games, in which the SMH was electronically sent to a printing plant in the UK and the SMH was then distributed to 77 outlets throughout the UK (although predominantly around London) in a physical form. The appearance of the paper is slightly different. It is a digital print and smaller in size than the Australian version but slightly larger than a tabloid paper. It contains almost the same quantity of stories.
Profit wise however, it is not doing well. As all papers rely upon advertising to raise profits (as to print the paper alone, you are going to be loosing money) one must increase advertising. However the problem with the UK SMH is that it is such a small print run, who would advertise in it? Who would be in charge of it? You would need to hire staff to look after it (another costly expense for such a small print run is not viable).
On top of this somewhat not successful print run in the UK, Fairfax also has links with Qantas. Fairfax supplies Qantas with in flight reading for their Trans-Atlantic runs. This not only provides high quality reading material for Qantas, but it also gives Fairfax a captive audience in which to promote themselves to.
Fairfax as a company is focused on marketing its product to obtain market share growth. It has a fine product and wants more people to be aware of it. So it has different marketing divisions for specific needs/departments. In this way it can specialise in all its avenues.
Much of the (market) research is done internally through Fairfax, while some is commissioned out to research agents such as Roy Morgan. Fairfax sees the importance of market research as a way of keeping ahead of the competition. There is much market research, which is done, and many databases are kept. Such as of current or potential clients, cash flows or payment plans.
Being in the media business, Fairfax has to keep up to date and in most cases be at the cutting edge of technology, because their livelihood relies on being ahead of the competition. Fairfax therefore has its own IT department which maintain, monitor and develop new ways (databases, systems etc) to help the staff do their jobs more effectively and efficiently.
Fairfax has its own printing plants in Chullora (NSW) and Tullamarine (VIC). They take pride in their plants and additional funding and development over the next few years will aid expected growth for Fairfax. Fairfax promotes itself as a growing company and this is evident through the fact that 1,200 of its 4,500 staff are involved In Group Operations. Fairfax describes Group Operations focus as “supporting the growth of Fairfax through a competitive advantage in the key operational areas of Time, Cost, Quality and Safety.” (Fairfax annual reports 2002).
Fairfax distribute their papers with commissioned drivers from their printing plants to newsagents, schools, hotels, companies and so forth. Much of the emphasis of distribution and channels are internal to Fairfax.
Fairfax’s key customers are newsagents and the actual readers of the newspapers. There is always a constant stream of communication between the newsagents and many departments in Fairfax, such as the circulation and education marketing departments as they both have a lot of dealings with newsagents. Fairfax also deals direct with the public. There is a customer service department set up (which has a free call 1800 number) to assist with all the needs that customers may have with all aspects of Fairfax.
Much of Fairfax is divided into divisions and it is the job of the divisional manager to make decisions in regards to pricing and communication (promotions), although, these divisional managers must report to people higher up on the corporate ladder. The divisional manager must also keep in mind their individual budget constraints in any new decisions they make.
Fairfax also has its own Human Resource’s department. Here such things as learning and development (training), leave entitlements, occupational health and safety, information kits, child care, grievance handling, equal employment opportunity, the Fairfax Foundation, employee assistance program, discounted goods and services, work related forms, flexible work options and transfer and relocation assistance are dealt with. Work related overseas travel or entertainment is done at a department level and taken out of the individual department budgets.
Fairfax does advertise within its papers. It is a cost-effective and self-promoting way to promote itself while filling up empty space.
Fairfax’s ethos or company profile is that “Fairfax is a competitive media company, with a strong performance ethic, serving its communities through high quality, independent journalism and dynamic venues for commerce and information”. Fred Hilmer (CEO) goes on to say “This statement, therefore, should be considered a work in progress and open to further debate and possible modification. Indeed, it is only through such discussion that the consensus on these values can grow and be adopted by each of us. This is the ultimate key to their relevance as a guide for how we carry out our professional responsibilities and conduct our business”.
Fairfax number of readers is well ahead of their competition. From a Roy Morgan Readership survey conducted for Fairfax in December 2002 it showed that SMH (M-F) has 402,000 readers, while The Daily Telegraph (M-F) has 237,000. The Saturday edition of the SMH has 579,000, while the Saturday Daily Telegraph has only 172,000. The Sun-Herald has 475,000, the Sunday Telegraph has 388,000. Although these figures are for NSW, the Victorian figures also show that Fairfax is well ahead of their direct competition. For national metro newspapers, Fairfax is also ahead. The AFR (M-F) had 69.2% of the readership while The Australian (M-F) has 53.6%. The Saturday AFR has 64% while the Weekend Australian has 48.458%.
Fairfax is also ahead in the Internet news. The combined efforts of the smh.com.au, theage.com.au, afr.com (which make up the f2 news network) total 2,646,027 users over a six-month period (to Dec 2002) and are constantly growing. While their direct competitors get far less hits, news.com.au (1,415,138), news.ninemsn.com.au (856,776), abc.net.au/news (385,000) and bbc.co.uk (422,000). Clearly f2 is ahead. Thus Fairfax is in a good position in Australia and is marketing themselves well.
From Fairfax cash flow statements it can be seen that their cash flows from operations has remained fairly stable from 2001 to 2002, while cash flows from investing has decreased from 2001 to 2002, due to Fairfax buying many plant equipment for the printing upgrades. While cash flows from financing activities have remained fairly stable. Cash Flow at the end of 2001 was 8,542,000 and at the end of 2002 it was 7,299,000.
From a recently released CEASA Report (Commercial Economic Advisory Service of Australia), we can see the best sources of advertising revenue in the main media’s. This shows that the best source of advertising is through the newspaper. The pie chart, which follows, shows the break down for classified advertising. Here Metropolitan/National dailies come second to classified directories. These two graphs support Fairfax’s strong position in the market, as most revenue for Fairfax comes from advertising.
4.0 SWOT ANALYSIS
4.1 Strengths and Weaknesses
Strengths
- Fairfax is in the business of disseminating information in a variety of forms including city, metropolitan and provincial newspapers, magazines, Internet services and CD-ROM medium.
- Occupies more than 25% of Sydney’s morning newspaper market.
- Sydney Morning Herald
- The Australian Financial Review
- The Sun Herald
- The Age
- The New Castle Herald
- Illawarra Mercury
- Business Weekly Review
- Personal Investment
- Caters to different geographic locations with different publications.
- Owns and runs services on more than 30 Internet sites.
- Major stake (60%) in one of the world’s largest independent directory publications, providing over 26 directories covering most of Australia.
- News gathering, administrative and ancillary function located in the heart of the city making itself strategically positioned to take advantage of commercial services of the city and easily getting the potential workforce from adjoining areas in CBD.
- More than 4,500 skilled people working in editorial/administrative section of Fairfax.
- The printing plant at Chullora situated on 10 Hectares and covers 38000 sq. meters. Plant is fully automated. Capacity to print 256 broad sheets with up-to 80 colour pages and 10 inserts. Total capacity to produce 80000 copies per hour.
- Readership base of more than 402,000 on weekdays and circulation of SMH (M-F) is 222,000. On Saturday, the readership is 579,000 and circulation 386,500 newspapers. The Sunday ed. Readership is 475,000 and circulation is 550,000 newspapers.
- Market research indicates that Sydney Morning Herald is considered to be well-written, informative, trust worthy, enjoyable and entertaining.
- An active market research department with a highly detailed picture of SMH’s readers, their reading habits and their interests, provides statistical data to help the marketing department in making strategic plans for growth.
- The H.R. department ensures good working conditions and other benefits to staff and employees.
- Large distribution network.
- John Fairfax is a holding company, holding fully or partly more than 36 other small companies and subsidiaries.
Weaknesses
- Still not a major supplier of Newspapers in Australia. Room for improving market share.
- Major holding in the company is of FXF Investment (16%) which is owned by Packer Group of companies, Fairfax’s traditional competitor in media market.
- Out of the two major players, News Ltd. and Fairfax Holdings, News Ltd. enjoys monopoly situation in most parts of Australia except NSW and Victoria.
- Limited by the Australian Trade Practices Act, which prohibits Fairfax Holdings from owning TV and broadcasting services at the same time as it owns newspapers.
- Bound by Australian media policies.
- Many of its own publications may be eating into the market share of its other owned publications and services.
- Till now it does not have any direct selling outlets.
4.2 Opportunities and Threats
Opportunities
- To improve its present market shares in Internet and print news.
- Even better presentations of its publications so as to improve readership and circulation.
- To expand and improve market share in other geographical locations in Australia, where News Ltd. or other companies have their strong hold.
- To try to enter the broadcasting business by acquiring TV and radio companies.
- To cater to the needs of Aussies who live in other countries. That is the Aussie traveler who wishes to be kept informed about an array of information of the things happening in Australia. Also the businesspeople around the world, who may find it useful to buy the Australian Financial Review or other news for their business etc.
- Improve reader’s awareness of the presence of Fairfax’s various publications by organising regular competitions / promotions etc.
- Can enter the field of publishing academic books, novels etc. to grow its sales and market presence.
- Can introduce special international newspapers in Australia, which cater exclusively to the needs of importers and exporters who may be interested in gathering social, economic and current news about some major industrial country, international students studying subjects related to other countries. (E.g. A newspaper or publication related to news from a geographical location of the world --- Middle East, European Union, U.S. sub-continent etc.)
Threats
- Other substitute products such as tabloids, magazines, books etc.
- Competition from existing newspaper publishers.
- The existing Australian newspaper (The Australian) on www.newsstand.com
- Web casters who provide live and regular news bulletins and updates through the Internet.
- Local newspapers published in UK.
- Non-sufficient reach of Internet in UK.
- Local and world news broadcast on TV.
4.3 Implications of SWOT Analysis
For many years, Fairfax has been known as one of the most renowned news and information providers in Australia. Fairfax’s experience in the news distribution will provide certain advantages when it comes to expanding its business to overseas markets. A product such as an Internet copy of Australian Financial Review (AFR) with high quality and advanced technology will make Fairfax more known in the field of news distribution. It will also benefit its existing customers who are always on the move (travelling) and will cater to the needs of new customers as well, who want to get access to accurate and high quality financial news about Australia for business purposes.
Fairfax’s marketing intelligence and reader’s research system will provide accurate everyday information about the marketing environment, which will be used by the Fairfax’s internet newspaper department to make decisions regarding the promotion of Fairfax’s other products also on NewsStand in the near future. Fairfax does not have any distribution issues with sending AFR Internet copies to its new customers in the UK. Since it will send it, as a soft copy (of the local Australian edition), to NewsStand and then NewsStand will distribute the newspaper to the customers - for a small fee charged from Fairfax on per copy basis. In addition, Fairfax will emphasise marketing this product from its own websites (http//:afr.com, etc.) to increase the reach of its products globally and this will increase Fairfax’s market share and profitability while strengthening Fairfax’s position as the market leader in Australia and help build market in UK. Moreover, since anybody can access NewsStand.com from all around the world, customers other than from the UK market will be an added bonus and a source of revenue for Fairfax.
Fairfax also has to compete with many local and international news and information providers that are well established in the market and achieving substantial market share, which may take a lot of time. The AFR, along with Sydney Morning Herald, is a well-reputed newspaper brand in Australia and its customers associate it with an image of accurate and high quality news providers. Convincing and attracting new customers in the overseas market towards buying the internet edition of its newspaper, may not take much effort since it plans to target businesses who want an access to quality financial news from Australia. It will still have to compete with other newspapers available on NewsStand.com and specially ‘The Australian’, another Australian newspaper available on NewsStand.com.
5.0 EVALUATION OF ALTERNATIVE MARKETING STRATEGIES
In contemplating the export of the AFR to the UK we considered a number of possibilities before deciding on exporting it via .
After discussions with the head of circulation at Fairfax, we soon discovered that they export the Sydney Morning Herald to the UK. It is sent electronically to a printing firm in London where a small digital print run is done and then it is distributed to 77 outlets (predominately around London). We considered attaching the AFR to this print run as we thought that there was an already established distribution channel, and customers who were interested in Australian news may also be interested in Australian business (an already established market).
We knew the product (AFR) is one of the leading business newspapers in Australia with a very specific target market, but were not sure how it would react in the UK, especially when it is a fairly specific product. From speaking to further people in Fairfax we soon discovered that the London SMH was loosing money. Which is reasonable, as newspapers rely upon advertising to make profits. The problem with the London SMH was, who do you get to advertise in it and who will look after the London advertisers. It would end up costing a lot of money for something you can view over the Internet (only in brief though). This is why we decided against sending an electronic copy to be printed in the UK.
The other idea we came up with was to send a physical copy of the AFR newspaper. However it could not be sent daily in time and it would cost too much to send a copy. Also finding people to distribute and sell old newspapers would be a difficult task. It just was not profitable.
We then thought about sending a monthly business magazine in a physical copy from Australia to the UK. We would have targeted business districts and also international hotels where business people are spending time on business trips. However logistically this would be too expensive, as set up cost for freight alone would have been to high for a small run, making this idea not profitable.
We discussed our ideas further with the business media people at Fairfax and came up with the idea of setting the AFR up on and promoting this site to the UK. The main advantage of this is that not only are the people in the UK targeted we can get spill over in the global market as it will be on the Internet. We will not need a distributor or anyone to oversee the site as people in Australia can monitor it from home – thus cutting costs. We would however require the services of an advertising or marketing agent in the UK. As they would have a much better understanding of the UK market and they would be more adept in obtaining information about our target market and developing ways to reach this market and attracting new markets.
NewsStand seemed to give us the perfect opportunity to promote the AFR to our UK market. Set up costs are low, as we only get charged a delivery cost (thus if no one subscribes we are not charged by NewsStand) and our customers would be receiving the total paper, not only sections as it is on afr.com. Thus we could become leaders in the Australian business market.
Since this was the most viable option we decided upon promotional campaigns as well as free trial offers to promote the AFR on NewsStand in the UK. We would promote the AFR on afr.com, but have a link to NewsStand for international subscribers, as this meant that Fairfax would hold control over its promotional material. So theoretically we are promoting afr.com.
6.0 OBJECTIVES
6.1 Organisation mission and corporate strategy
Organisation mission
AFR is a committed and resourceful group of like-minded professionals focused on delivering financial information to the community by always working to the three principles: candor, honesty and honour.
We are committed to providing accurate, up-to-date financial information to our readers and to maintain our excellence in reporting and to preserve editorial independence.
We aim to create new markets and opportunities to suit the changing needs of readers and advertising.
AFR ensures that as new print and electronic systems evolve, readers are served better and returns to shareholders are maximised.
Corporate Strategy
While identifying a strategy for our single business, we considered a few functional strategies to build competitively valuable resource strengths and capabilities. Our financial strategy, human resource strategy, sales marketing, promotion, distribution strategies as well as technology strategy shaped our business strategy.
Implications for our strategy
The most basic insight to emerge from economic analysis is that competitive forces are continually at work trying to grab a piece of any excess returns a firm might generate. In response to this conclusion, two options are available. One of these is to try and determine how the system can be altered or rigged so as to limit the power of these forces. This is the approach taken by both the competitive forces and strategic conflict paradigms. A better option for us, however, may be to accept competition as a fact. That is what we decided to do.
We are planning to earn a profit through our uniqueness as there is limited information access to Australian finance in the UK and AFR on is the first attempt by Fairfax to distribute this information by electronic subscription. The AFR on om then would turn its attention to guarding its position so that it can continue to earn high returns in the future. We would initially start from a resource-based approach.
However we are aware that the problems with this tactic are twofold. We are aware that in most cases, the continued focus on maintaining the status quo leads the firm into weaker and weaker positions and may eventually threaten its survival. To avoid this problem, we have decided to maintain the resource-based approach and to continually search for the new and innovative. By doing so, AFR on www.newsstand.com may be able to have something else unique to offer when its initial edge is lost to the competitive forces. This is not an easy task, however. Nonetheless, we believe that this appears to be both the more ethical and more profitable path to take.
Crafting our corporate strategy
In a diversified company like Fairfax, crafting corporate strategy involves four kinds of initiatives. The first one is making the moves to establish positions in different businesses and achieve diversification. This piece of corporate strategy establishes whether Fairfax is based narrowly in a few industries or broadly in many different industries. So our new business will be related to Fairfax industries and we are not entering the different unrelated business.
After our positing is identified in Fairfax related industry – we are distributing financial information to the UK market via the Internet, we consider the second initiative. Our next step is to concentrate on ways to strengthen our long-term competitive positions and profitability’s of the AFR on www.newsstad.com that Fairfax would need to invest in. We hope that Fairfax – our corporate parent can help its business subsidiary be more successful by financing additional capacity and efficiency improvements, by supplying missing skills and managerial know-how.
Our third step is to pursue ways to capture valuable cross-business strategic fits and turn them into Fairfax’s competitive advantage. If Fairfax diversifies into AFR on with related technologies, similar operating characteristics, common distributions channels; it gains competitive advantage potential not open to a company that diversifies into totally unrelated businesses. We believe that such cross-business “strategic fits” strengthen Fairfax’ competitiveness and provide a basis for greater profitability.
And finally we realise that Fairfax’s different businesses are usually not equally attractive from the standpoint of investing additional funds, so Fairfax would decide what investments are their priorities. Our team believes that AFR on is a promising business unit.
6.2 Company Product/Market objectives
- Financial Objective for the following three years:
ROA = Net Profit (after taxes) / Assets
* Based on the Balance Sheet of Fairfax 2002, the following is the expectation for the ROI for Fairfax in the following three years:
(The Net Assets of Fairfax in 2001 was $1,141.0 million, in 2002 it was $1,344.5 million, so the rate of growth was 17.8%, and was dependant on the percentage of the sales expectations shared from total revenue of Fairfax. We assumed these figures from the assets)
ROS = Net Profit (after taxes)/Sales
(Formula source: Roger J. Best, Market-based Management, p353, 2nd Edition, 2000, Prentice-Hall, Inc)
Long-term:
-To provide the most reliable, accurate and objective information that we can. To let readers feel they can trust the information they receive and the decisions we make as a result of using the product/service of Fairfax.
-To bring readers the best possible Internet experience, ensuring that all the websites of the products provided by Fairfax are easy to use and are viewed as leaders in the field.
- To be the most competitive media company in Australian electronic publishes market.
- To continuously expand the market share and increase sales revenue in both Australian and abroad markets.
- To benchmark Fairfax against other competitors at home and leading companies abroad.
Short-term:
- Focus on News and Classifieds
- Charging for online classified
- Maintaining a leadership position
- Driving synergies between print and online
- To obtain no less than $10m EBIT in 2003 profits thereafter.
With costs expected to remain flat, continuing improvement in profitability at Fairfax, and barring a further downturn in advertising markets, Fairfax is expected to resume earnings growth in 2003. The magnitude of which will depend on the robustness and timing of a recovery in advertising markets.
7.0 RECOMMENDED MARKETING STRATEGY
7.1 Target markets
Our target market are Australians who locate to the UK with an interest in the Australian business environment and any business person or firm who has investments in Australia or any kind of interest in Australian financial situation.
We examined our consumer characteristics and decided that the major segmentation variable for our consumer market is demographic segmentation. As such, we divided the market into groups on the basis of variables such as age, family life cycle, gender, income, occupation, education, nationality, and social class. We believe that our consumer wants, preferences, and usage rates are associated with demographic variables. These variables are also relatively easy to measure, so we gathered information that helps us target our market.
After our market- segment opportunities have been identified, we evaluated different market segments and chose to apply a product specialization pattern of target market selection.
Product specialization is our preferable choice because we are offering a certain product (AFR) that we sell to several segments. We intend to build a strong reputation in the specific product area through a product specialization strategy. However, using product specialization, we realize that it might be risky as one day the product may be supplanted by an entirely new technology.
We used Maslow’s hierarchy theory in trying to understand how our product would fit into our consumers’ plans, goals, and lives. We believe that AFR helps our customers to satisfy their esteem needs such as self-esteem, recognition and status, as well as their self-actualization needs such as self-development and realization.
We identify a profile of the average The Australian Financial Review (AFR) reader as follows: achievers in there 30s and 40s with young families, highly mobile, with high income, and active lifestyles.
AFR Monday to Friday (M-F) readers are predominantly male (73%). 28% are aged between 25-34, 36% are aged 35-49 and 29% are aged 50+ years. AFR readers have an average age of 42.3, which is slightly younger than the average of the general population.
69 % of AFR, M-F readers (72%) are in the AB socio-economic group. They are highly paid group; 30% have a personal income of $100,000+. 18% have a personal income of $130,000+.
The majority of readers have a university degree (60%). AFR readers are almost all employed. Most are working full time (80%) and a further 9% are working part time. 6% are retired.
The bulk of AFR readers are professionals or managers (62%). 41% work in Business, Property and Finance. The next most popular industries among AFR readers are Manufacturing, Public Administration and Defense and Community Services.
AFR M-F readers are more concentrated in capital cities than the general population.
In terms of media usage AFR readers are large print consumers. They do not watch a lot of commercial television, and are also below average on commercial radio listening, although they do listen to the radio in their cars.
They have embraced the Internet and go out of their way to learn more about new technology. Over 90% have access to the Internet, with the majority of those using it at least once per week. They see the Internet more as an information tool than as an entertainment tool.
AFR, M-F readers are relatively active. They are more likely to try and do as many sports as possible. They are extroverted and have a full social life.
They do not take advantage of special offers at supermarkets, and they do not buy home brand products. They believe quality is more important than price. They are less likely to go out of their way in search of a bargain.
AFR, M-F readers are more likely to consider themselves to be “a bit” intellectual, and believe it is important to have responsibility in their job. Success is important to them. They consider themselves to be leaders.
In terms of cross over readership, 23% read the Weekend AFR, 19% read BRW, 12% read Personal Investor and 10% read Shares.
Weekend AFR (W/E AFR) readers are very similar to AFR M-F readers, however there are some differences between them.
They are more likely to be male (71%), 19 % are aged 25-34, 34% are aged 35-49 and 38% are aged 50+ years. Weekend AFR readers have an average age of 45.01, which is slightly older than AFR M-F readers.
They also belong to AB socio-economic group (65%). They are a highly paid group, although not to the same extent as AFR M-F readers; 22% have a personal income of $100,000+. 12% have a personal income of $130,000+.
The majority of readers have a university degree (57%). Over ¾ of all Weekend AFR readers are employed. Most are working full time (59%) and a further 18% are working part time. 12% are retired, which is a higher percentage than AFR M-F readers.
50% of W/E AFR readers are professionals or managers. The industries within which they are employed are more diverse than AFR M-F readers are. 21% work in Business, Property and Finance, 13% work in Community Services, 8% work in manufacturing.
Like all business publication readers, W/E AFR readers are more concentrated in capital cities than the general population.
In terms of media usage W/E AFR readers are large print consumers. They do not watch a lot of commercial television.
Over 85% have an access to the Internet, and ¾ use it at least once per week.
Weekend AFR readers are similar to AFR M-F readers in that they consider themselves intellectual, and believe it is important to have responsibility in their job. Success is important to them. They place less importance on having security in their job than readers of AFR M-F.
In terms of cross over readership, 36% read The AFR M-F, 32% read The AFR Magazine, 17% read AFR Boss, 18% read Personal Investor and 18% read Shares.
The majority of our market is in their 30s and 40s with high incomes to match their highly active lifestyles.
They are highly mobile, high achieves with high income. When they are not spending time on their businesses, they are spending it with their families.
7.2 Market positioning
In the UK newspaper market report [reference: ], it is understood that the market environment in which to position a newspaper can be describe as:
- The competitive marketplace. There are more than 100 TV channels, more than 1500 business magazines, more than 1500 regional newspapers, 25 national newspapers, more than 200 radio stations, 200 consumer magazines, and cinemas and poster contractors.
- The advertising expenditure. In the year 2001, the UK advertising expenditure was around £11,739,000,000, 42% was spent on newspaper, 30% on TV and the rest was spent on magazines, outdoor poster etc.
- The research shows that about 15% of the UK Internet audience used newspaper sites in last 3 months in the year 2002. Moreover, 22% of campaigns run on UK sites.
It is necessary to understand the current situation faced by NewsStand Inc. Publications delivered by NewsStand are in demand by paying customers in more than 100 countries. There are more than 40 publications currently producing digital editions with NewsStand. The major groups can be described as newspapers, newsletters, and magazines. Some examples of the newspaper groups are: The New York Times, The Boston Globe, International Herald Tribune, The Press and Journal, The Australian, The Globe and Mail, The Scotsman, The Tampa Tribune, Star Tribune, Tarun Bharat, The Morning Bulletin, China Daily, New York Law Journal, Die Presse, Express & Star, International Express and The New York Times Book Review etc.
Therefore, based on above information, newspaper positioning into the UK market is very strong and competitive as compared with other Media’s. In the future there may be a trend to publish on the Internet, enable people to obtain information more easily.
7.3 Marketing mix
7.3.1 Product/service
-
Core product: news/information (business)
-
Actual product: AFR on NewsStand, the complete paper available and delivered over the Internet.
- The content is displayed in the exact format as the printed version. All the articles, images, and ads are presented precisely as seen in the paper copy.
- On-time delivery: the readers in UK can get the electronic edition of AFR by exactly the same time as the readers in Australia.
- Accessibility: Subscribers can simply download the AFR and enjoy them just like their printed form.
- Easy to read: Zoom in to text and pictures to maximize your easy, comfortable reading.
- Convenient: Auto-schedule downloads – have the newspaper waiting for you.
- Flexible: Key word searches – gives you the power to perform further research on any person or topic instantly.
- Portable: No need to be online – read in the park, train or on the plane.
- Compact: Save past issues on your computer. Fast, neat and highly compact means to retain information for quick reference later.
- Efficient: Zoom to articles with a single click – makes your
reading experience highly efficient.
-
Augmented product: access to afr.com, more comprehensive Australian business information that is available easily and at a discounted rate.
Due to the competitive nature of the news service, Internet and business industries, the AFR although popular in Australia needs to make itself competitive in an international market and set it self-out from the rest. Ways in which Fairfax can achieve this is by:
- Promoting itself strongly with the AFR. As well as being an established, informative, accurate and reliable Australian business that has strong brand recognition.
- Subscribers can gain access to the afr.com and all the advantages that come with it. That is access to the premium page, where you can download full text article, gain access to the past 8 days for free (for further past days an additional fee of $2.20 is charged), access (but not able to down load – unless one subscribes to) all of Fairfax publications over the internet and you can personalise your page in order to get what you want.
Fairfax is a highly reputable company, with award winning standards of excellence for all its publications. Fairfax has positioned themselves as the leaders in business information and is proud of their service to the Australian community. They now must establish this same pride and market dominance in the UK market. This can be achieved through establishing customer value through promotion, free trials and brand/name recognition.
7.3.2 Place (distribution)
We believe the best distribution of AFR to the UK will be through NewsStand.
NewsStand is like a cyber newsagent. In that one can buy (over the Internet) an issue of any newspaper they have connected to them on a per issue basis or on a subscription basis. NewsStand has established software that enables users to receive one whole publication, while a nominal fee will enable additional copies of that same publication.
NewsStand has fixed fees i.e. delivery fees, so that Fairfax will be charged this fee, then the additional money left over, from subscription goes to Fairfax. There is no subscription cost for Fairfax to get on NewsStand. Thus if no AFR’s are sold, Fairfax pays nothing to NewsStand.
In order to set this distribution up, all Fairfax needs is time for research and money for this research, as well as money to go toward marketing, advertising and promotion. This can all be done in house, as who knows Fairfax better than the people who work at Fairfax.
It would be advantageous if Fairfax sets up a link to subscribe to AFR via NewsStand on their own web page i.e. afr.com, and promote this link. This not only promotes brand/name recognition but it also enables free advertising for Fairfax and total control of how they advertise their product and promotions.
To add to the overseas subscription, people in the UK can not only subscribe to the AFR (via NewsStand) but they can also get access to the premium web page through afr.com. This not only is a value-added bonus but it also promotes the name and reputation of Fairfax as a market leader.
To monitor these distribution channels, NewsStand has tracking links on their web page in order to give and receive referral fees. This is all part of the NewsStand’s fixed costs.
The only problem with this method of distribution is that once you buy a copy or subscribe to AFR via NewsStand, you only receive one copy of it. So the readership to circulation is 1:1. Which is not brilliant for advertisers and thus Fairfax, as with the one paper you are only reaching one person. These ratios are different for physical copies, with them it is more like 2.4 readers read the one newspaper. In order to rectify this the reader can either print out a copy of it or for a nominal fee (maybe $0.20) download an additional copy in order to increase the reader to circulation ratio.
7.3.3 Price
Price is the sum of money consumers pay in exchange for the benefits of a
product or service they receive. One of the main factors that affect pricing decision is the segment the product is targeted to. The average AFR reader is quite well off, probably middle to higher class who can afford a lot of life’s luxuries.
Value is achieved in its $2.50 price tag in Australia for a physical copy. Since we are targeting a similar market in the UK, we are going to stick with this same pricing. We decided to benchmark against The Australian, as they were our closest Australian competitors.
Comparison between the Australian and AFR (all in AUS$)
Our pricing plan may look like this (all in AUS$):
7.3.4 Promotion
On top of these standard rates (mentioned above) we will have two promotions running together. The first is that when you buy one paper you receive the AFR free for two weeks (6 days per week).
The second promotion which will work in conjunction with the one above is to promote the Australian appeal, that is, once you subscribe to the AFR for a year for 6 days you receive an Australian gift – such as a gimmicky inflatable Kangaroo and a Fairfax AFR pen.
Both of these promotions will run for 6 months every year for 3 years. After the promotion is complete a 6-month evaluation will be conducted in order to monitor the success and failures of it and ways to improve it or adjust it.
We will also be targeting group subscriptions, such as members in the Chambers of Commerce or large multinational corporations in the UK with a special promotion, such as if over 200 employees subscribe, they will be entitled to a 5% discount each. Of course this will be for a limited time, possible for 3 months per year over a 3-year period. We believe this will create good will between Fairfax and the large firms and word of mouth will spread from this promotion.
8.0 ECONOMIC EVALUATION
8.1 Planning Assumptions
Expected Case Assumptions and Facts
The current population in the United Kingdom is 59 million. Of which 18% are immigrated Australians which totals roughly to around 10 million. There are overall 49 million readers of the newspapers daily, among this 49 million, 576,000 weekly readers which read the “Financial Times”. This is the local business paper in the United Kingdom. (Source: )
So the best way in which we estimated the first years expected sales was by correlating the Financial Readers and the Australians and the total copies which we could analyse for the first year expected sales was 500,000.
Worst Case
The worst guess was not much of the worry since the paper is published through the Internet. As such we expected to gather subscribers from a market which did not exist in United Kingdom before. The only thing which may hinder us and that should be watched carefully is the tax system. The current tax rate is 22%. But due to the unrest overseas and Australia’s cost for military deployment, we may expect the tax rate to rise to 25%.
Best Case
The Best Case has already been mentioned. In that the paper is published over the Internet, so it can be accessible by anyone, anywhere in the world, not just in the UK. Since the major expenses are directly related to sales or subscribes of the newspaper it does not effect our costs negatively if we underestimate the market. Another thing, which happens when the market is underestimated, is that the productions targets are not achieved so the customer keeps waiting for the product which may never turn up. This is also not a problem for us since it is an Internet product, it can be distributed in millions of copies with no extra cost or extra time, and this is our competitor advantage.
Also the tax system should be considered for the best case scenario. Maybe the government has occurred lots of expenses in the Iraq war and it is going to collect the taxes by increasing tax rate, but may be they will plan establish some connection in selling oil. This could in fact lead to a boom in the economy, which would in fact reduce the tax rate to even lower then its current rate, so we assumed that rate to be 19% at the best. Since it is involving the government strategies it can never be analyzed and the profits can change accordingly the change in government policies. The Best and the Worse which we could think of for total subscriber copies is 10% lower or higher then the expected Sales. The reason could even be the Australian Dollar (AUD) getting stronger or Weaker to the Great Britain Pound (GBP)
Pricing Tactics
Fairfax is planning to price the AFR in the same way it is priced in Australia. It is planning for two types of editions in the beginning, one edition will be Monday to Friday and other will be from Monday to Saturday, both editions will be sold in three types of price plan. They are one month subscription another is six month subscription and the last one is one year subscription all these options are available to both types of editions. Also subscribers can buy one off copies at the standard rate. The pricing plan for both the papers are detailed in the below tables
Table 1 (Monday to Friday Edition)
Table 2 (Monday to Saturday Edition)
Table one shows the total number of copies, which is estimated by us for Monday to Friday edition. The reason we have we have estimated these figures are for the following assumptions.
- In Australia the total number of Financial Review sold is distributed among two editions. The first one is Monday to Friday and the other is Monday to Saturday. The ratio of distribution among them is 7:3 that means when 10 copies are subscribed seven are for Monday to Friday and three are from Monday to Saturday edition.
- Assuming that United Kingdom have a similar type of economy, culture, technology and so forth we assumed the ratio to remain the same as well for the United Kingdom market i.e. is 7:3.
-We also priced the AFR as per the same strategy, which is currently used in Australia.
-We then analyzed the average price per copy of the paper by dividing the total number of copies in that particular time to the subscription price. Then we have put the weights on each subscription out of 10. This means, how many of the first option we want to be subscribed to and how many of the second and so on.
- After that we estimated the copies sold, which is explained in the first paragraph and then dividing them by the ratio, which would give the estimated copy per subscription option. Each estimated copy is multiplied by average price of that copy which gives the total revenue.
- The same procedures imply for 2005 and 2006. The only change is ratio, because we considered since the project will be known to the public and they will be aware of it, their subscription policy will be rather long term then the short term which changes the total revenue considerably.
- The estimated sales were 700,000 and 1 million. The reason to estimate them by such figures was that since the paper has been made aware to many people now we will advertise this in many sites which are aimed at our target market, such as the UK Chamber of commerce, ‘Yahoo UK’ and so forth.
Promotion Tactics
The promotion tactics was done in a quiet similar way to the pricing tactics. We have put weight on the age on each types of category, in which we plan to promote the paper. Then after setting a fixed benchmark of the amount to be spent, we distributed them as per the weights. The table below explains the weights and types of promotion tactics.
In the promotions we are concentrating on the online advertisements to sites, as the research shows the United Kingdom Market is fast and rapidly developing in technological and internet commerce market. So we feel that we can reach the customers directly and speedily through this resources and technology available. Secondly we placed more weight to online marketing and to continuously increase our budget comparing to others. Our core product is also traded on line through e-commerce and so it is better to use the media in which your product is traded through to get better outcomes. The company does not ignore other types of promotional tactics although they are not being financed as much as online marketing. Some other ways in which we would promote the product is through TV advertisements, trade shows and telemarketing.
The whole marketing budget is done by putting all these things together and calculating the total estimated profits and sales in all the three scenarios and over the three years. The total estimated sales for every year including both the editions are listed in the table below
These figures are used to calculate the break even as well the net profits of the project for all three scenarios as per the worst and the best case assumptions. All Figures below are in Australian dollars.
The only cost, which was not considered earlier, was the fixed cost. In this section we have decided to employ four executives in Australia who will take care of the all the operations in United Kingdom market. Of which one will be an accountant who will look after the payments and financial aspects. One will be a technical supervisor who will consider all the issues of delivering the daily electronic copy to NewsStand. One will be a marketing director who will look after the promotions and other sales issues. All these three directors will be assisted by an assistant and will have a managing director who will be responsible for the whole project. All this will be based in Australia and the salaries are estimated to be AUS$280,000 per annum for the three years.
Miscellaneous expenses include such things as stationary, additional staff if required travelling expenses and so forth. We estimated this to be roughly $120,000 per year.
News Stand Delivery Charges are directly related to the number of copies sold. We estimated this to be 15 cents (AUD) per copy subscribed so they are calculated accordingly to the number of copies subscribed.
Break Even Analysis
Break even analysis is based on two types of costs. They are fixed and variable. Fixed costs are overhead type expenses that are constant and do not change. Variable costs are directly related to production in this project they are directly related to number of subscriptions. The formula, which we used to find the break-even point, is detailed below.
- Fixed Costs/ {1- (variable cost per unit/selling price per unit)}
The fixed cost of our project is 400000/(280000+120000)
- Variable cost per unit = Total Variable Cost/Total Subscription issues
Which = 575000/400000 = 1.15
To determine the selling price per unit we have averaged the prices of all the options, which are available for the subscription of the AFR. This amounted to $ 2.44.
So the full equation is presented in the following way:
Break Even Revenue = {400000/ (1-1.15/2.44)} = 756589.15
The table below shows the monthly cost and income and the occurrence of the break-even point.
From the figures it seems pretty clear that project will break even somewhere in the mid of July and August.
9.0 IMPLEMENTATION AND CONTROL
9.0 Implementation and Control
9.1 Implementing the project plan
To ensure the success of the implementation, the responsibilities and ownership of the tasks, related to the release of this product, must be divided among the people involved in this project. An implementation and action plan must be made stating details such things as the dates and months by which a particular activity must be completed. In the ideal situation, the plan can be started in the year starting in January 2004. The research for the market situation in UK can be started in January 2004 and will take approx. 2 months and will end within February 2003. Meanwhile the competitor review will be started in February 2004. It will help to identify the potential competitors and their existing products in the UK market, and thus the strategies for Fairfax’s plan for the UK market can be fine-tuned. The market research department of Fairfax will carry out the research. A separate office, responsible for attending to the new customers and dealing with NewsStand.com, will be setup in March 2004. Meanwhile the advertisements will start in March 2004 till June 2004 to gain market awareness. We estimate to start our promotions from July 2004 to December 2004 (ideal for the festive season for gift subscriptions). The frequency of the advertisements will be based on the financial allocations made for advertising and promotions. The marketing program will be set out like the one above for years 2004, 2005 and 2006.
Assuming that the subscriptions are as per the market research and assumptions which were made, the target sales will be are achieved by August 2004. The breakeven will be achieved in the eighth month i.e. in August 2004 and the sales revenue of A$ 756589.15, which is the breakeven point, will be reached.
9.2 Monitoring of Action Plan
PROJECT PLAN
To ensure the success of the project plan, it is recommended that the following steps be taken:
-
Form championship and ownership teams. Sometimes one person is the champion of the implementation of the marketing plan. It is suggested that Fairfax should create an ownership team. An ownership team will force the exclusive talents of many people, which will certainly outperform a single champion.
Compensation. By relating monetary or any other type of compensation, for those who are responsible for the implementation, to the performance, people will be motivated to do their jobs efficiently, since financial compensation usually is an incentive for most people when it comes to performing well.
Management Involvement. If the senior management does not take the marketing plan seriously it sends a signal through the organization which will weaken the motivation of the ownership team. Therefore it is necessary that the senior management must be involved in implementation process in order for the marketing plan to be successful.
Sustaining the marketing plan
It is essential to sustain and support the marketing plan. It takes some time to achieve the set goals and succeed; communication must run smoothly; resource must be allocated, moreover skilful and intelligent staff is needed.
-
Time to succeed: It takes time for a company to succeed in a new market, Fairfax’s entry into the UK market is easy and it also does not involve much financial risk but there will most likely not be a high market penetration at once. Market penetration may take time and will test the skills of marketing team and patience of people behind its implementation.
-
Communication: It is important that everyone related to this project must fully understand the marketing plan and not just the senior management and the ownership team. The internal communication must be quick and without any distortions when it comes to the marketing plan. The external communication with Newsstand.com, the target customers, related government agencies (e.g. foreign trade promotion boards, chambers of industry, information and broadcasting ministry etc.) are also important. It is the aim of advertising and promotion activities that the target customers are made aware of the AFR, its benefits, the high value of the information provided by AFR and where can it be acquired.
-
Resource allocation: This is the most important step for successful implementation of a marketing plan and it should be ensured that monetary and managerial resources (e.g. expert advice, research information etc) are allocated as and when needed.
-
Required skills: Fairfax should ensure that the right people are employed for the implementation and they acquire proper training and are equipped with required skills. This will also ensure smooth implementation and control.
Adapting the Marketing Plan according to environment
For the marketing plan to be successful it should be adaptive and should be flexible in terms of changing according to the changes in the environment it operates in. Several factors that contribute to the adaptive nature of the marketing plans are feedback measurements, continuous improvement, persistence etc.
-
Feedback measurements: To be able to improve the marketing plan, Fairfax has to measure the performance of certain key processes. We recommend Fairfax use the feedback tools such as metrics of customer awareness, intention to buy, interest in our product, trial and re-subscription etc. It is also recommended that Fairfax measures the business responsiveness to customer inquires and problems.
-
Continuous improvement: It is essential that the market plan be fine-tuned according to the rapidly changing environment. This will ensure the success of the marketing plan. By continuously improving the marketing plan it will be possible to adapt it to the environment in which it is has competing.
9.3 Contingency plans
A contingency is a situation, which is unexpected and can affect the business adversely. For this project, the various contingencies that can be thought of are as following:
- The targeted subscriptions may not be attracted.
- The targeted sales may not be achieved.
- An increase in the tax rate by government in the UK or Australia.
- Change of government in UK, which may lead to change in the media policies (currently no restrictions on the newspapers – just one condition that the name of the publisher must be printed on the newspaper) in UK.
- Restrictions on the flow of news due to change of the policies of government in UK.
- Restrictions on the flow of news due to changes of policies in government in Australia, which may restrict Fairfax from distributing news outside the country.
- An increase in demand for the AFR in UK (means more publishing and printing expenses in case of any other physical printed newspaper).
- An increase in the fee charged by NewsStand.com, which may affect the profits of Fairfax.
In case the targeted subscriptions are not achieved within the first year or a period under review, marketing strategies may have to be changed. Under new plans, a change in marketing mix (Place, Price, Promotion and Product) will be implemented to achieve better results. The promotions and advertising budget will be reviewed to control the situation. Another option will be to review the pricing strategy to achieve targeted sales revenues.
As mentioned in the budget plans, another worst case can be an increase in the tax rates. In that case the profit of Fairfax from this operation will suffer a downfall. Also in case of any change in media policies due to government change or some other reasons Fairfax might have to work under controlled environment or the news it is distributing may be limited by the government policies or affected by the policies. In such a case the reliability of the news decreases and the customer’s loyalty decreases and they tend to find an alternative source, which may lead to the erosion of market share of AFR in UK.
Also if the popularity of AFR increases in the UK, this will lead to an increase in demand of the AFR. Fairfax can easily handle the supply of this increase in subscriptions without putting up any extra costs for production since there are no problems of production of the newspaper because it is available on the internet and does not require any time or physical raw materials to produce extra copies.
It is also part of the strategy that Fairfax should sign a legal contract, stating that the fees charged by NewsStand.com will not be increased for at-least the next three years. This should be done to avoid any losses or decrease in the projected profits due to hike in fees charged by NewsStand.com.
10.0 APPENDIX
Appendix 1.
The Australian Financial Review - Daily Sections
EGN
- Early General News incorporates the daily highlights of national and international news and events.
- The section covers the latest economic data and trends, business trends and relevant court cases, as well as the key political events of the day at both national and state level, all with a particular emphasis on the ramifications and consequences for business.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Companies
- This section is the engine room of the AFR and the biggest daily section. It offers Australia’s most comprehensive coverage of companies making the news. When a corporate takeover occurs, key management changes are made, an annual general meeting convened or a profit/loss announced, ‘Companies’ knows about it.
- Each Thursday, ‘Corporate Review’ provides an in-depth analysis of a major company. Each Friday, ‘Corporate Focus’ provides explanations for why things happen, how they happen and who is responsible. It is a must read for senior management, CEO’s, managing directors, financial directors, government unions and investment bankers.
-
the attached PDF file for more information about this section...
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Information
- Information is the country's only daily IT news section and the premier venue for news about the business of technology. The special pull-out section each Tuesday is the most recent development of this section.
-
Analysing the costs and benefits of IT business solutions from a business perspective rather than a technical point of view - Information is the section dedicated to reporting on global and local information technology developments, covering fields such as Internet commerce, telecommunications, networking, software and a host of supporting industry issues.
- A must for CIO, CEO, CFO’s and those people who sign off on new technology expenditure.
-
the attached PDF file for more information about this section...
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Financial Services
- Financial Services analyses the sectors related to retail banking, managed funds, life and general insurance and investment banking, mortgage managers, building societies, credit unions, friendly societies, debt capital markets and analysis of the borrowing plans of Australia’s major companies
- It’s about the strategies, the funding, the profits and the people inside this industry.
-
the attached PDF file for more information about this section...
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Property
- Property carries a range of news, features, analysis and profiles focusing on the listed property trusts, developers, fund managers and private investors.
- Comprehensive daily coverage includes:
Monday Rural property
Tuesday Tourism property
Wednesday Commercial & industrial property, property trusts & funds
Thursday Commercial & industrial property
Friday Residential and personal investment property
-
the attached PDF file for more information about this section...
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Market Wrap
- In line with global trends the Australian Financial Review developed a 20-page lift out, a dedicated section that contains expanded tables, inclusion of global markets, additional local and international editorial coverage from Monday to Friday.
- Further editorial movements have seen the popular ‘Rear Window’ column now appearing on the outside back cover of Market Wrap as well as ‘Alex’.
-
the attached PDF file for more information about this section...
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Rear Window
- Located on the inside back cover Rear Window takes a satirical look at the day’s news.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Monday
Marketing & Media
- Each Monday this section takes a thorough overview of the media, marketing and advertising business, by focusing on the contracts, the campaigns and the people behind them... the key players in the industry and their movements.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Tuesday
Enterprise
- Enterprise aims to provide Australia’s small and medium size businesses with useful and timely information on topical issues including tax, regulatory and legal issues, superannuation, communications, utilities, workers’ compensation, access to finance, property issues, franchising, exporting, information technology, employment issues and development of business and entrepreneurial skills. A must read for all people involved in their own businesses.
-
For more information on advertising please the Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Wednesday
Managed Funds
- Managed Funds follows the trail from the investor through to the big fund management companies into the ‘hot’ investment sectors of the economy. Our writers explain the investment strategies of various fund managers and analyse their success or failure by profiling the key players and decision makers in the industry. Interest in this section has prompted it to grow to a pull-out section each Wednesday.
-
the attached PDF file for more information about this section...
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Special Reports
- In an outstanding series of special reports, our team of specialist writers look in depth at the impact of industries, issues and new developments on business and business managers. Weekly, full colour special reports liftouts cover subjects as diverse as financial services, information technology, management and human resources, legal affairs, property, power and resources, transport, infrastructure and overseas economies.
-
For the complete list of special reports titles, .
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Thursday
Arts & Sale Room
- Arts & SaleRoom covers editorial based on antiques, old wares, coins.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Friday
AFR BOSS
- Appearing on the 2nd Friday of every month (inserted into the Australian Financial Review)
- AFR BOSS was launched in March 2000 and since then the publication has grown in popularity with progressive Australian executives.
-
Appealing to people who are aware that the key to success is understanding that "knowledge is power and arming yourself with the right knowledge is essential".
- For advertisers AFR BOSS provides a rare level of access to senior managers and upward moving managers.
- Inside AFR BOSS you will find up-to-the-minute lead stories on management issues from Australia and around the world.
-
For more information on advertising please the AFR BOSS team in your state.
Executive Recruitment
-
Executive Recruitment is the place to find recruitment ads for high-end positions such as senior management and professionals across all industry types.
-
the attached PDF file for more information about this section...
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Legal Affairs
- This section carries a mix of news and commentary aimed at a wide range of lawyers, from those who are still studying to those at the top end of the legal market place. With an emphasis on treating law as a business. Legal Affairs aims to inform those in the legal profession about industry trends and what their competitors are doing.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Review
- Review is a blend of sophistication with clever, informed opinion to suit the AFR’s existing readership but also to draw new readers to a format that enjoys a unique position in the marketplace.
- Each week it explores ideas and currents of thought in culture, literature and the fine arts, economics, politics, public policy, history, science, the environment, philosophy and religion. The section aims to keep pace with intellectual and cultural trends, to provide a forum for discussion and, where possible, to anticipate the direction of ideas.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Government Business
- The AFR is the only newspaper which provides a weekly editorial section dedicated to Government Business. It provides the reader with an analysis of the political, financial and social issues which affect the government sector of the economy.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Australian Financial Review Magazine
- Published on the last Friday of each month The Australian Financial Review Magazine is inserted free into The Australian Financial Review newspaper.
- Editorially it covers various topical aspects within The Australian business, political and social arena. The AFR Magazine is an intelligent and aspirational product aimed at an affluent audience of senior professionals and business decision-makers.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review Magazine team in your state or to visit The Australian Financial Review Magazine on this site.
Saturday
EGN
- Saturday EGN covers all of Friday’s major stories breaking across the nation and the world and are given more coverage and analysis. It enables readers to be brought up to date on the ramifications of the week just gone and the resulting issues for the week ahead.
-
the attached PDF file for more information about this section...
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Business
- Weekend Business is designed for the weekend reader and encourages a "scan" selection for the reader who understands that on the weekend, time is not necessarily of the essence, but business information is. This section now includes a one page summary of IT information and property.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Perspective
- Perspective is the feature of the AFR Weekend edition.
- It provides investigative reporting at its best in revealing what is really driving current events and as such is a showcase for some of the best writing in the AFR.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Smart Money
- Smart Money provides intelligent reporting on wealth creation and protection - for individuals working towards a safe and secure future. Smart Money also incorporates Smart Funds, a presentation of retail managerial fund prices, fund sizes and investment return.
- It is targeted at high net worth individuals who are well educated, wealthy and financially sophisticated, working towards a safe and secure future.
-
the attached PDF file for more information about this section...
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Observer
- Examples of the world’s best feature articles, global issues and events, challenging ideas, controversy and intelligent travel writing.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Performance Tables
-
The AFR performance share tables are an enhanced set of informative tables. All the usual data on market leaders, the Australian share market, market performnace, warrants, derivatives, interest rate securities, futures, commodities, overseas, money and bond markets are all listed here. Course of sale data is now located on .
- The AFR is also the paper of record for the financial markets sector: Fund managers, stock brokers, investors, managers and financial professionals in banks and other financial institutions.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
After Hours
- Provides reviews of significant Australian and international performance art, cinema discussion and reviews, prestige and luxury motoring, sport and the country’s most respected wine column.
-
For more information on advertising please The Australian Financial Review team in your state.
Appendix 2- Industry five Forces
(Sources: Siegfried P. Gudergan, 2001, chapter 6, p. 128)
Appendix 3
AFR’s Market Attractiveness
(Sources: Siegfried P. Gudergan, 2001, chapter 11, p. 246)
Appendix 4
AFR’s Competitive Advantage
(Sources: Siegfried P. Gudergan, 2001, chapter 11, p. 248)
Appendix 5
Portfolio analysis and strategic market plans
Very attractive
Market/segment
Very unattractive very weak very strong
Market/segment (competitive advantage)
(Sources: Siegfried P. Gudergan, 2001, chapter 11, p. 249)
Appendix 6
Buying Decision Behavior
(Sources: Kotler, Brown, Adam, Armstong, 2001, chapter 6, p. 211)
11.0 REFERENCE
- Brown, Linden & Fletcher, Richard. 2002. International Marketing - An Asian-Pacific Perspective.
-
National Statistics Online
-
Reading of national daily newspapers: Social Trends 32, available:
-
E-Commerce Inquiry into Business 2000, available:
-
PPA- Consumer magazine and marketing
-
Data and trends – advertising, available:
-
John Fairfax Holdings Limited 2002 Concise Annual Report, available:
-
NewsStand Inc.- The Print Version on Your PC, available:
-
Australian Bureau of Statistics
Australian Social Trends 2001, Population - Population Growth: Leaving Australia, available:
-
The Press and Journal– Scotland’s leading regional newspaper, available:
-
Financial Times– All times are London time, available:
-
The Australian- Australia’s national daily newspaper, available:
-
The Observer: ad info: display- products and services advertising
-
UK newspaper market pres, available:
-
Siegfried P. Gudergan, 2001, Contemporary Marketing Management, Pearson Education Australia Pty Limited