• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

No one best style of leadership

Extracts from this document...


'There is no one best style of leadership.' Discuss this quote, illustrating your answer with relevant theory and case examples. The style of leadership used by managers should depend upon the type of staff within a company. Different situations require different approaches and skills. It is wrong to say that there is one best style of leadership which can be applied in conjunction with all subordinates. Mullins seventh edition text book defines leadership as 'a relationship through which one person influences the behaviour or actions of other people'. Boot et al (1977) refers to it as 'one of the most fundamental aspects of management.' The proof that there is no one best style of leadership lies with the number of leadership theories which exist in today's society. From contingency theories to transformational theories, whether a firm is lead in an autocratic, democratic, or a laissez-faire structure, is reliant upon the culture, structure and task of the specific organisation. I will be using Marks and Spencer to illustrate concepts of leadership, exploring the idea that there is no one best style of leadership. Marks and Spencer, ranked one of 'the most admired companies in the UK', was once considered a well trusted, expanding organisation, and was the benchmark to which many firms compared themselves. ...read more.


Fiedler has himself 'revised or at least elaborated on the original assumptions about behaviour that could be based on LPC scores.' Fiedler (1972). This revision of his theory, in conjunction with the doubts expressed by critics portrayed a lack of belief of the theory. Another contingency theory is the Vroom and Yetton theory. This is based upon two aspects of a leader's decision- quality and acceptance. It analyses the effects a leader's decisions has upon a group's performance, and of the motivation and commitment of staff following the decision. The theorists suggest seven decision rules which must be answered by staff to conclude which leadership style is desired for a specific situation. Similarly to Fiedler, this theory was also later updated by Vroom and Jago, suggesting a total of twelve variables. The third theory is the Path- Goal theory. This is a 'different type of contingency approach, seeking to link leadership to the motivation of subordinates' Warr (1971). The theory is derived from the expectancy theory of motivation, and suggests that the performance of workers is dependent upon whether the managers satisfy their expectations. The theory exemplifies four types of leadership behaviour, and suggests that all these styles of leadership can be used by one person, depending on the situation. ...read more.


Adopting a contingency theory allows managers to adjust to a particular theory- best desired for the specific situation. However, contingency theories can lead to a lack of trust from employees, and leaders may interpret this style as inconsistent. A leader should be able to have a 'powerful impact on group performance' Vecchio (2000). Leadership is perhaps as it's most important when a firm is at a time of change and uncertainty. This was the case for Marks and Spencer, who needed a leader to change the organisation, and to restructure the original path- goal theory of leadership. After Peter Salsbury had joined the firm it was still clear, even with the introduction of his transformational leadership approach that there was still need for a change in the leadership strategies that were being used. Different employees respond to different styles of leadership, so it is impossible to say that there is one best style of leadership which can be used in conjunction with all subordinates. Whether it be a type of leader who is most appropriate for a particular stage of an organisation's development, or a style of leadership used for a group of followers- different types of situations should, theoretically be approached in different manners to ensure success. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. Assessing your own leadership - management at Costa Coffee.

    I have a circle of friends and colleagues that I invest time in building social relations. So I can discuss about my business with them and this will help me to improve my business. When I take the weakness main thing I need to concern the risk taking part because

  2. Leadership. There are many styles or ways that a leader can use to motivate ...

    Consistency: an individual who does what he says. The discrepancy in the actions brings distrust. Good in handling situations quality. Loyalty: one who is ready to protect others putting oneself at risk. Openness: on whom people can be reliant that he will always be open about things.

  1. Transformational Leadership. Transformational leadership involves the provision of leader influence on subordinates, but ...

    This convergence of approaches you can see in the leadership studies: ideology is not important now but ideas. The problems of leadership at the moment are quite sharp, and therefore is very important study of the phenomenon of leadership. Let us turn to the analysis of the concepts of manager's

  2. Management and leadership within health visiting team in Edmonton locality.

    The framework for overcoming rigid and obsolete assumptions is proposed in the section on implementing a quality service. By using A.S.T.R.E.A.M for setting goals I have arrived at the following objectives in the box below, some of which are derived from Enfield Primary Care Trust (EPCT)


    Firstly, a lot of rich information was forthcoming, so it was important to capture notes as the meeting progressed, whilst facilitating the discussion and keeping others involved. Secondly, a tendency to bias could happen from the researcher, who has had the advantage of an in depth literature review of the subject.

  2. What are the attributes of an effective leader? Discuss with reference to well ...

    Manager rather than discuss it with the Branch Head who is more senior. It was believed that the Assistant Manager develops interpersonal relationships with the staff members; hence earning their respect. On the other hand, the Branch Head is seen as an autocratic leader, focusing strictly on tasks and how

  1. The purpose of this exercise is to introduce the relationship of selecting, evaluating, building ...

    Upon taking a closer look, you might find someone you didn't expect performing a job not often equated with them. The "them" in this case are women and minorities. Women in construction, by themselves, are a relatively new addition to the male-dominated field industry.

  2. The link between national culture and leadership style. Can one expect discrepancies between the ...

    A good way to make a careful study of this topic is to use Hofstede?s model of ?national culture?. According to Hofstede, the nationalities can be classified by five prominent dimensions: 1) individualism-collectivism, 2) uncertainty avoidance, 3) power distance and 4)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work