• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Organisations show an increasing awareness, in this current economic climate, of the costs of different HR processes. Discuss how organisations can attempt to balance the requirements of cost constraints with the need to develop effective, valid and relia

Extracts from this document...


Question One Organisations show an increasing awareness, in this current economic climate, of the costs of different HR processes. Discuss how organisations can attempt to balance the requirements of cost constraints with the need to develop effective, valid and reliable selection processes. "Selection processes are when an organisation chooses an applicant for a post from a pool of applicants"i. During this current economic climate employers are trying to reduce operating costs, the review of selection processes, has been seen by many to be one way of reducing cost, however when recruiting, employers need to ensure their selection processes select the most appropriate person. CIPD (2009) reported that the average cost of recruitment and selection of an employee is �7,750 (including induction, training, time and resources)ii Kline (1993) stated 'reliability' and 'validity' are key for selection methods to be technically sound as a measure of both immediate suitability of a candidate and also of prediction of his/her future performanceiii. Reliability can be defined as "the consistency of your measurement" e.g. if a candidate was given the same test paper twice, they should achieve a similar score. Validity is defined as "the strength/effectiveness of a tool and the conclusion of what it measures" e.g. ...read more.


Pilbeam&Carbridge (2002) state these types of interviews show 0.6 predictive validityvii. Harel et al (2003) reported that interviews that are structured and job related increase fairness and standardisation; this improves the validity and reliability, unstructured interviews are more social and personality based. I agree with this statement because everyone should be treated fairly and also for the procedure to remain consistent for all. Gareth Roberts defined psychometric testing as "a mental measurement that measures candidates ability or personality"viii. Ability measures vocabulary and numeracy, and looks at the aptitude required for a particular role, whereas personality tests look at personal characteristics, values and beliefs. It could be argued that personality tests do not accurately measure performance in all types of jobs, so ability testing is more accurate when assessing/predicting a candidate's ability to perform a specific job, however the merits of the different tests will vary depending on the job type. Psychometric testing only has a validity of 0.4, however it was reported there is medium popularity within organisationsix. Doving (2005) reported 51% of employers in Europe are conducting psychometric test in selection. The problem is the requirement to have competent experts to implement the system effectively and professionally. ...read more.


Justification for cost is important, therefore there has to be a balance between the cost of associated processes and the effectiveness of the process. Employers are looking at online profiles e.g. facebook etc. People Management (2010) reported that 4 in 10 HR managers did not hire a candidate as a result of negative online profilingxv. This could potentially indicate to employers what people are like out of work, in their social environment and if they will prove suitable e.g. work ethics, beliefs and values of the prospect employer. Overall selection processes are important within any organisation. The ultimate objective is to select the best candidate e.g. the person with the right skills, qualifications and competencies, who will be able to apply these to the job, whilst at the same time ensure that the cost of the selection is kept to an absolute minimum. The cost of selection will vary for different types and levels of jobs e.g. Director of HR will typically cost more than a HR assistant, also the process will need to differ in order to ensure appropriate selection. In this current economic climate I believe that the need to adopt the correct selection process is possibly more important than ever before. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Human Resource Management section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Human Resource Management essays

  1. "Why is effective recruitment and selection important to organisations? Which selection techniques are the ...

    Testing is another method that may be used during the selection process. Testing is usually a follow up from an interview. It is mainly used when selecting applicants for managerial or at professional level. You will tend to find that testing is used only used for these positions as they

  2. OB - Personal Reflection paper

    Large corporations and government agencies typically are the organizations that fit this description. This connection will directly apply to me if I go back into the field and then become a professor.

  1. Compare and contrast TWO modern recruitment/selection methods (e.g. psychometric tests) with more traditional systems ...

    we now get more international applicants because of the access to the web (IRS Employment Review, 2002)." In addition to attracting diversity, online recruitment can improve the quality of candidates. What's more, 98% of graduates, 93% of IT specialists and 95% of scientists use the Internet as part of their daily routine.

  2. Concept of Validity and Reliability in Relation to Selection of Staff.

    hence selection Policies and Practices in my organisation would use clear and defined criteria that will be based on thorough job analysis and will prove to lead to successful job performance. The process would be transparent and easy to understand and simple to follow.

  1. Recruitment and Selection

    The recruitment and selection model in Appendix 1c shows the process and the implications line managers have throughout this process. If HR and line managers can maintain a talent management strategy in the selection process, they could recognise the full potential of a candidate but also something unique and special about them that allows them to perform higher than others.

  2. Audience Requirements

    If they are already very keen to hear what you have to say to them then you don't have to work to hard, but sometimes your audience will need to be won over. One thing you could do is to get to the point quickly, and explain how the topic is relevant to the audience.

  1. Human Resource Management: Development, Activities, Planning and Recruitment

    Making the appointment Good practice Bad practice * Agree starting date; * Make any necessary pre employment checks; * Issue appointment letter. * "Letter of Appointment" sent by wrong part of University - e.g. department rather than Human Resources; * Appropriate terms and conditions are not given to the successful candidate.

  2. Dissertation proposal "Critically evaluate recruitment and selection process in employment agencies in ...

    selection: "Almost without exception, faced with mature 'developed' markets, major companies are turning to Eastern Europe and Asia as the source of their future growth. If they fail to find ways to work in these very different cultures, the most significant opportunities of the next 20 years will be lost to them."(Hall, 1995 p:25)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work