Secondly, sales ethics also matters because it promote trust. Trust is conceptualized as an expectancy held by an individual or group that the word, promise, written or verbal statement of another party can be relied on (Ganesan and Hess 1997, 440).According to Strutton, Petton and Lumpkin (1993, 1), it is imperative that sales people gain and maintain the trust of prospect customer and clients. Once trust has been built between the customer and the seller, the connection between them will change from the transactional base to the relationship base (Murphy, Laczniak, and Wood 2007, 45). This changes will allow salespeople to be more involved with each customer, have a greater knowledge of consumer and generally provides greater flexibility in making decision that enchance customer satisfaction. Trust also can generate the repeat buying from consumer.
Thirdly, ethical behaviour in sales will bring a positive effect on the long term profitability (Herndon, Fraedrich and Quey 2001, 73). The formation of ethical behaviour of salespeople can begin from inside the organisation with building the ethical climate. According to Ming and Chia (2005, 54), creating an ethical culture within an organization may provide ethical standard for its members.Ethical climate will generate less stress among the sales people. Policies and rules will reduce ambiguity and the salespeople will likely to know how to respond to the ethical problem. Then, When there is a trust between sales manager and sales people, there will be less conflict. For Instance, Diageo PLC, the leading of spirits and alcoholic beverage producer has gain the trust from the government and also from the consumer due to the clean and ethical image (Corporate watch UK 2005).
In the short term, unethical behaviour, such as abusive labour contracts, fraud, bribes and emezzlement can lead to profits more readily that fairness can, but almost always end up being detrimental in the long run. In some cases, such practices can even lead to costly legal penalties. If a public scandal ensues, the loss of reputation can be dramatic, as well as the investment of much time and money, might be necessary to recover credibility and trust (Mele 2009, 12).
One can argue that acting ethically might mean some additional cost. Investing in worker safety could lead to a loss in competitiveness if one’s rival fail to do likewise. Laws and the reinforcement can help to avoid such situation but, if this is not the case, sales manager should do their best. Competent sales managers will seek to run business that are both ethical and profitable (Mele 2009, 13).
Sales ethics is an oxymoron
If one looks at the purpose of ethics/morality and the common conception of the purpose of sales, one can make a fairly good case that sales ethics is an oxymoron. Morality or ethic is incompatible if following the rules of business practices inevitably to the exclusive pursuit of self interest. The majority of large company has established code of ethics but it seems to be the case that they have failed to reinforce the message. Based on the research by Bartlett and Preston (2000, 200), eventhough the company has code of ethics, but many employees cannot see that ethics is active in the work enviroment.
If the only responsibility of business is to increase profit, it is quite sensible to claim that there is not such thing as business ethics. Given the pressure of the marketplace, the stock market, and the notion, sales manager have a fiduciary responsibility to increase profits. Thus, there is no wonder that they will become bottom line oriented. For example, more than 30,000 people have lost their job in Jack Welch’s 17th year career as CEO at GE, earning him the nickname of “Neutron Jack” -for the bomb that destroys people but leaves buildings intact. For most business people, such moves have made Welch America's premier corporate changemaster, the wunderkind of Big Business. His methods are extolled in business schools, praised by the media and copied by others (Duska 2000, 113).
In the sales division, salespeople are typically put under great pressure to increase the bottom line sales and make profits by such means as commision, quota, and other sales-force management techniques. It is very usual that they maybe led by this pressure to lie to consumers, conceal information, make unrealistic promises, disparage the competition, and oversell (pushing products to the consumer who do not needs the product). Salespeople may also be tempted to cultivate customers by offering or agreeing to pay kickbacks or outright bribes, with or without the company’s knowledge. Since salespeople often work away from the office without close supervision, they also have the opportunity to misrepresent their work, pad their expenxe account, or otherwise cheat their employer (Boatright 2009, 275).
This situation is exacerbated if the moral judgment from society accept the unethical behaviour. For instance, In Indonesia, bribery is a common act in the sales enviroment, thus to succesfully develop the sales in Indonesia, the sales division has to accept the bribery, such as give money to the client’s purchasing officer to allow her/his company buy from us.
Conclusion
People have long debated whether ethics contribute to profits. A frequently asked question is whether sales ethic is oxymoron or not. First, we must make clear that ethics focuses on what is good or bad from a moral perspective. Consequently, the value of ethics is not as an instrument for profits but lies in its intrinsic worth.
To sum up, in the real life, sales ethic is an oxymoron. Actually, almost all of the company do the sales ethic in the eyes of public, but this sales ethic is an intrinsic to maintain its continuity and keep the long term profitability. Providing that the company do sales ethic because of those objectives, they do not do the sales ethic since it is not the ethic’s intrinsic worth. Eventhough the company looking ethical, but it is doubtless that they still do the unethical behaviour, although it is not serious, for instance, shadow prices and excessive ads (the food is bigger and more appealing in the ads than actual). This situation is exacerbated with the acceptability of moral judgement by the public for the unethical behaviour.
References
Bartlett, Andrew and David Preston. 2000. “Can Ethical Behaviour Really Exist in Business?”. Journal of Business Ethic 23 (2) : 1999-209. .
Boatright, John R. 2009. Ethics and the Conduct of Business. New Jersey : Prentice Hall.
Carroll, Archie B. and Ann K. Buccholtz. 2003. Business & Society : Ethics & Stakeholder Management. Ohio: Thomson.
Corporate Watch UK. 2005. Diageo PLC : A Corporate Profile. Accessed March 21, .
Duska, Ronald. 2000. “Business Ethics : Oxymoron or Good Business?”. Business Ethic Quarterly 10 (1) : 111-129. .
Fisher, Josie. 2004. “Social Responsilibity and ethics : Clarifying The Concept”. Journal of Business Ethics 52 (4) : 391-400. .
Ganesan, Shankar and Ron Hess. 1997. “Dimensions and Level of Trust : Implication for Commitment to a Relationship”. Marketing Letters 8 (4) : 439-448. .
Hair Joseph F., Rolph E. Anderson, Rajiv Mehta, and Barry J. Babin. 2010. Sales Management : Building Customer Relationship and Partnerships. USA : South Western Cengage Learning.
Herndon, Neil C., John P. Fraederich, and Quey- Jen Yeh. 2001. “An Investigation of Moral Values and Ethical Content of Fine Corporate Culture : Taiwanese Versus U.S. Salespeople”. Journal of Business Ethics 30 (1) : 73-85. .
Lysonski, Steven J. and Eugene M. Johnson. 1983. “The Sales Manager as a Boundary Spanner : A Role Theory Analysis”. The Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management 3 (2) : 8-21. .
Marcus, Alfred A. 1996. Business & Society : Strategy, Ethics & Global Economy. USA : IRWIN.
Mele, Domeneo. 2009. Business Ethic in Action : Seeking Human Excellence in Organization. New York : Palgrave Mcmillan.
Ming, Tien Tsai and Chia Mei Sih. 2005. “The Influences of Organizational and Personal Ethics on Role Conflict among Marketing Managers : An Empirical Investigation”. International Journal of Management 22 (1) : 54-61. .
Murphy, Patrick E., Gene R. Lacznick, and Graham Wood. 2007. “AnEthical Basis for Relationship Marketing : A Virtue Ethics Perspective”. European Journal of Marketing 41 (1/2) : 37-57. doi : 10.1108/03090560710718102.
Pettijohn, Charles E., Nancy K. Keith, and Melissa S. Burnett. 2011. “Managerial and Peer Influence on Ethical Behavioral Intentions in a Personal Selling Context”. Journal of Promotion Management 17 (2) : 133-147. doi : 10.1080/10496491.2011.580694.
Strutton, David, Lou E. Petton, and James R. Lumpkin. 1993. “The Relationship Between Psychological Climate and Sales Manager Trust in Sales Organization”. The Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management 13 (4) : 1-14. .