• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

SERVICE QUALITY DIMENSIONS. The literature review illustrated that the most common model used in hotel industry is SERVQUAL, even though it is also most criticized. Using comparing method, this study examines the differences found between the number of s

Extracts from this document...


SERVICE QUALITY DIMENSIONS Abstract The article reviews the issues on measuring service quality, on defining the dimensions of service quality and the way in which the measuring models applies to hotel industry. The literature review illustrated that the most common model used in hotel industry is SERVQUAL, even though it is also most criticized. Using comparing method, this study examines the differences found between the number of service quality dimensions, the service quality dimensions content and the rank of each dimension. This paper also gather the recommendations made by researchers for improving the future studies on service quality in hotel industry. Keywords: SERVQUAL, service quality dimensions, hotel industry, literature review 1. INTRODUCTION The relationship between service quality and organizational performance in service industry has often been emphasized and demonstrated by an large amount of examples. In 1980 Jan Carlson, the president of Scandinavian Airlines System, managed to turnaround a loss year into a profitable business, by managing "moments of truth". This is the reason that strongly supports the significant impact of service quality on the business performance of those who adopt customer orientation approach. The same opinion is embraced by Juran and Gryna (1993), which claimed that in a log-term view, the most important factor affecting business performance is the quality of goods and services offered by organization compared to its competitors. [10] Thus, since 1978, when one of the first service quality models was developed, a variety of other models tried to explain the factors that determine the quality of services and to measure the service quality dimensions in order to satisfy its customers. So far, studies show that there is no universally valid definition of the concept of service quality, as there is no single model to capture all the attributes that determine quality. This is primarily due to the subjectivity of customers and their needs and expectations in continuous development. ...read more.


Although SERVQUAL model was one of the most criticized models, most researchers have made them research based on it, but some output differences appeared in the number of dimensions proposed for defining quality, (Garvin, 1987, Knutson et al., 1990, Saleh and Ryan, 1992, Getty and Thompson, 1994, Akan, 1995; Mei et al., 1999; Akbaba, 2006). (Table 2)Other research started to structure and operational SERVQUAL model, using different methodologies instead. (Oberoi and Hales, 1990, Webster and Hung, 1994, Ekinci and Riley, 2001, Tsaur et al., 2002, Juwaheer, 2003, Wilkins et al., 2007). (Table 2) A brief description of the most important contributions of these researchers will be presented in the following. For a better analysis of research the models were classified in three distinct areas: the application of SERVQUAL model exactly how it was proposed by Parasuraman et al., application of SERVQUAL model with little changes on some items and application of SERVQUAL model by using a different methodology. Table 2. Summary of service quality dimensions proposed in hotel industry Year Authors Dimensiones Application of SERVQUAL model with little changes on some items 1987 Garvin (8) performance, features, reliability, conformance, durability, serviceability, aesthetics, perceived quality 1990 1994 Knutson et al. Getty and Thompson (LODGSERV) (5) responsiveness, reliability, assurance, empathy, tangibles 1992 Saleh and Ryan (5) conviviality, tangibles, reassurance, sarcasm avoiding, empathy 1995 Akan (7) courtesy and competence of the personnel; communication and transactions; tangibles; knowing and understanding the customer; accuracy and speed of service; solutions to problems; accuracy of hotel reservations. 1999 Mei et al. (HOLSERV) (3) employee - behavior, physical appearance tangibles, reliability 2003 Ekinci et al. (2) intangibilities, tangibles 2006 Akbaba (5) tangibles; adequacy in service supply; understanding and caring, assurance, convenience Application of SERVQUAL model by using a different methodology 1990 Oberoi and Hales (2) Functional components, technical attributes 1994 Webster and Hung (7) tangibles, reliability, communication, responsiveness, security, understanding, convenience, 2001 Ekinci and Riley (7) decoration, cleanliness, staff behavior and attitude, output quality, accessibility, timeliness, reliability 2002 Tsaur et al. (8) ...read more.


[16] Researchers Martinez J.A. and Martinez L. (2010) made a critical study on the conceptualization and measurement of service quality, treating the most important service quality models in terms of types - reflective or formative. They classified the using this criteria and SERVQUAL model is framed in the category of formative multidimensional models. First weakness of these models is the fact that the service quality construct is formed by its dimension and this does not exist separatly from its dimensions. For this reason it all relevant dimensioins should be included in the model. Secondly, there is absolutly necesarry to distinguish the attribute-level performance from global judgements about the service as disparate entities, with divergent meaning, antecedents and consequences. [9] Likewise, Martinez and Martinez recommended to develope more creative models, multidimensional and hierarchical, based on phenomenological research, which consider existing processes depending on context. 6. CONCLUSIONS Literature clearly shows that there is still much work to be done in this area, that of measuring the quality services, considering that many of these conceptual models and their empirical testing leads to a limited way to use them in practice due to differences arising on the number of dimensions, their definition and importance. SERVQUAL model limitations refer specifically to the fact that this is not universally valid (Carman, 1990), dimensionality of the service quality may depend on the type of service studied (Babakus and Boller, 1992), involves a difficulty in analyzing the differences between expectations and perceptions (Asubonteng et al., 1996) and cultural background influence customer perceptions on service quality (Akbaba, 2006). However, in the hospitality industry, SERVQUAL is most often used for determining the level of service quality, whether it was applied as proposed by Parasuraman et al., whether it was applied with small changes in creating the items (LODGQUAL, HOLSERV) or was used only as a logical framework, applying different methodologies from those originally proposed. A significant recommendation in order to improve research in this area is that of methods using both qualitative and quantitative, using phenomenological techniques that lead to creative models in quality services. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Management Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Management Studies essays

  1. 'List and critique each of Deming's 14 points. Explain how each point can be ...

    Deming advocated the use of the Shewhart cycle, also known as the PDCA cycle (Plan-Do-Check-Act), as an approach to process analysis. This cycle inevitably leads to redesign and improvement. 6. Institute training on the job. It is essential to train as many members of the corporation as possible to recognize

  2. Total quality management - Federal express case study.

    Their efforts have also come to no avail (Francis, 1997). Most employees do not want the union at FedEx. The Teamsters continue to argue that employees would be paid more if they had a union representing them but most disagree (Hundley, 1998).

  1. Strategic Analysis of Burberry Ltd. In this report three models will be used: PEST ...

    To achieve this aim, the following objectives are to be investigated: * Environmental forces and its impact on Burberry * The resources capabilities of Burberry * Competencies and core competencies of Burberry 4. Strategic Analysis A key requirement for the process of strategic analysis for Burberry is the examination of

  2. Leadership Theories - this review seeks to determine which theoretical perspectives, theories and schools ...

    Relational Team leadership "defines leadership as social problem solving, where leaders are responsible for (a) diagnosing any problems that could potentially impede group and organizational goal attainment, (b) generating and planning appropriate solutions, and (c) implementing solutions within typically complex social domains."

  1. What are the common sources of incompatibility in cross-border alliances?

    However the dilemma of poor performance or failure of international alliances due to the common source of incompatibility, culture, can be minimised. Holt and Wigginton (2002) emphasise that Hofstedeļæ½s research on dimensions of cultural values provides a useful model to get a better understanding of cultural diversity among different nations.

  2. Case study on Clifford Chance.

    It forms for a long time communication. ACAS (2000) suggests that good communications can improve decision making, employee commitment and help develop greater trust (Torrington, P100). But how greater trust can intervene to reduce the resistance to change? In the theory of human resource, it goes by the name of "halo effect" (Torrington, P105).

  1. A critical review of Biedenbach et al, 2008, The Challenge of Organizing Change in ...

    Biendenbach cites other authors but it is not clear if he shared the same perspectives as these authors or does he have his own opinion about the issue. An organization?s Capabilities is important as it defines the organizations skills, it is a valuable concept and is stressed throughout the study.

  2. Enterprise rent-a-car total quality management

    To identify why these deficiencies are occurring, focusing particularly on those are that forefront of customer service and consequently evaluating employee management. 1. To provide better and more regular training to front line service employees 2. To provide better incentives for each and every employee to offer continuous personalised customer service.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work