• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Transaction Cost Economics - Fisher Body

Extracts from this document...


This essay draws upon the underlying dimensions of Transaction Cost Economics as a justification of why General Motors (GM) decided to acquire its producer in closed auto-bodies, Fisher Body in 1926. Prior to the Transaction Cost approach of organisation coined by Ronald Coase, understanding why firms existed was impoverished. Throughout conventional economics, emphasis was placed on mathematical modelling and mindless abstractions in which economists were fixated by what determined price, that any approaches to the study of organisation generally focused on efficiency (Williamson 1981). The theory of perfect competition and monopoly sees the firm as a black box where certain inputs are entered into and as if by miracle, products are produced. Where conventional economics overlook the different ways in which activities can be coordinated, Transaction Cost Economics deems the 'transaction as the basic unit of analysis and holds that an understanding of transaction cost economizing is central to the study of organisations.' (Williamson 1981) Another words, by characterizing the transactions appropriately, it can help address the importance of costs in coordinating, issues regarding vertical integration and the determination of efficient boundaries between firm-type and market-type coordination. ...read more.


According to Williamson this was logical because where the 'three critical dimensions of transactions' (Masten 1996: 390) namely: frequency, degree of uncertainty, and asset specificity was present, the most efficient government structure emerged, this being vertical integration. Where GM integrated backwards in their supply chain in order to internalise transactions within one organisational structure, markets and hierarchies represent alternative government structures. If General Motor's assets were non-specific, then they could have purchased its assets through a normal market relationship based on relevant prices. But as we can see with such market structure, it poses the possibility for agents to act opportunistically. With GM and Fisher Body, we see the emergence of a vertically integrated firm as an efficient response to the transaction cost associated with market-type coordination. Therefore, by adopting Transaction Cost Economics as a way of analysing organisations we can predict that vertical integration hierarchies will take place within an industry, like that of Fisher Body and General Motors, through the present of these three distinct dimensions1: i) the frequency of a transaction, ii) the uncertainty surrounding the transaction and iii) the level of asset specificity associated with the transaction. ...read more.


As a result, 'it was the threatened expiration of these provisions, not holdup, that was the primary source of contractual difficulty between GM and Fisher.' (Freeland 2000: 44) Along with these limitations as stated by opposing economists such as Coase and Freeland, further dispute was made to the validation of a hold-up in the Fisher body-GM case study. These include accounts of how Fisher Body's decision to move its plants away from GM was in fact not true (Freeland 2000), and it was also stated by Coase (2006: 265) that Fred Fisher, one of the Fisher brothers, became a director of GM in 1922 thus, making it inconvincible that Fisher Body adopted an inefficient production process. But what is important to note is not the number of arguments presented by either opposition, rather Transaction Cost Economics provides one of the many theories associating with industrial organisation. The classical example of Fisher Body and GM is one that illustrates the potential and explanatory power of the Transaction Cost Economics framework. Whether or not such theory purely describe firm behaviours, 'TCE, with efficiency analysis at its core, has an important place in the multiparadigm world of organization theory, but to claim that it is the only paradigm would be foolhardy. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Management Studies section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Management Studies essays

  1. General Management - organisation, leadership and theories.

    A leader can break down any reluctance to give feedback by supporting the efforts of followers to work in a way that satisfies both themselves and their company. A good leader knows and consistently uses some of the many techniques for learning follower's needs and assessing how they experience their environment.

  2. Leadership Theories - this review seeks to determine which theoretical perspectives, theories and schools ...

    In this sense, the literature on organization identity and identification seems pertinent. Finally, an issue that arises from this study is related to the significance of each of these perspectives in developing leaders and leadership. In other words, what do we need - and should - be developing to increase leadership effectiveness and performance in organizations?

  1. Project Cost management

    the skill set of the team in place and map their roles in the project. At the end of this phase the manager will need to produce a Statement of Work (SOW), which is a document that can provide a description of the services or products that need to be produced by the project.

  2. Are the constructs of the psychological contract, trust and organisational commitment as relevant in ...

    commitment as explained by Western literature are applicable in the South African context. This is done by determining the influence of leadership, by using these constructs, on the behaviour within an organisation. Any discussion of organisations and leadership in the South African (SA)

  1. Complexity Theory

    Simulation is also a particularly useful method when empirical data are challenging to obtain (Davis, et al, 2006). For example, simulation enabled us to unpack the distinct effects of environmental dimensions that are difficult to disentangle in actual environments. Finally, simulation is especially effective for research such as ours that

  2. Tata Nano. The launch of the People's Car by Tata Motors is a defining ...

    There are hardly any signs of fatigue as he poses for pictures before the interview is scheduled to begin. As the coffee comes in, Tata sends word to remind his driver to have his meal as he is going to be late.

  1. industrial relationship

    Evidence supporting the claim is based on peoples 'stated intention to leave' rather than the number of victims who actually leave. Wollf, C (IRS. 2006a) pointed out that 34 percent victims make formal complaint; however, 52 percent victims choose to look for other job.

  2. Import/Export Economics of China

    This puts the enrollment numbers somewhere near 5 million with a graduation rate nearing 97% - though there is no available breakdown of this figure (Chen). With such high graduation rates there is difficulty for the graduates to find local jobs; in fact the most recent numbers suggest that 10%

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work