• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What were the main causes of the East Asian financial crisis?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

MSc Development Studies 2003/4 Module: Images of Development What were the main causes of the East Asian financial crisis? The East Asian financial crisis of 1997 represented a major interruption in the rapid economic and social development enjoyed by much of the region in the decades leading up to it. In less than a year, some East Asian economies went from being examples of successful development practice to a situation of economic stagnation and decline. Growth rates that had averaged 8-10 per cent per year over many years turned negative, economies that enjoyed continuous high employment and experienced labour shortages suffered from rapidly rising unemployment levels, and stock market assets lost half their value. In a region where growth was dubbed 'miraculous', economies became structurally unstable and needed rapid intervention by international agencies such as the IMF (UNCTAD, 1998). The crisis arose from the large scale shift of funds out of domestic financial markets in the region, starting in Thailand (IMF, 1997). The effects of the financial crisis are still having an impact not only in the region but are also reverberating around many other parts of the global economy. This essay first attempts to define 'East Asia' by reviewing the different sets of countries in literature focussing on the crisis. It outlines the countries that suffered most as a result of the crisis, by examining pertinent economic and financial indicators in the region. It asserts that a discussion of the causes of the crisis is impossible without an understanding of the development process in the region before crisis, and examines the particular circumstances in the region that may have contributed to the onset financial crisis. It then looks at the context for the financial crisis and focuses on events in Thailand - the country where the crisis first took hold - in an attempt to identify the relative importance of the various underlying causes of the crisis put forward. ...read more.

Middle

Since many economies in the region were pegged to the Dollar, the competitiveness of their exports rose, encouraging still further influx of capital into the region. In 1995 the Dollar had reached its lowest level against the Yen and in response to warnings that this could trigger sell-offs of Japanese holdings of US Treasury Bonds, the Dollar was pushed up. When the Dollar gained in strength from 1995, this favourable condition in the region was reversed, leaving economies with losses in competitiveness and a reduction in export growth. In the region as a whole, export growth rates fell from an average of 20 per cent per year in the mid-1990s to only 5 per cent in 1996. The clear correlation between the relative strengths of the Dollar and Yen and the health of East Asian economies brought into question with wisdom of maintaining pegged exchange rates between a relatively small country's currency to the world's most powerful economy, as it exacerbated any problems the region already had. This phenomenon is discussed below. In addition to the part played by Japan and the US, Beams (1998) points to the role of China as an external factor that contributed to the build up to the East Asian financial crisis. The 50 per cent devaluation of China's currency in 1994 made its exports increasingly competitive: China already boasted cheaper labour than many of the East Asian economies where massive growth had fuelled rises in the costs of living and therefore wage rises. Investment began to move on from East Asia to China from 1994 onwards, putting further pressure on other East Asian economies by providing a certain amount of new competition in addition to diverting investment. As each individual country's economic growth slowed, they were also less able to export commodities to each other. Part of the success of development of manufacturing in the region was based on the ability of countries to trade intra-regionally, often engaging in 'work-sharing' which meant that countries engaged in different sectors ...read more.

Conclusion

Some economists, such as Beams (1998), asserted that the theories outlined above merely describe the symptoms of an over-expansion and subsequent contraction of the market - the so called 'boom and bust' cycles that are an intrinsic part of the capitalist economy - rather than explaining the causes of the crisis. In saying this Beams seems to blame the international capitalist economy itself rather than any of the factors discussed above that were pertinent to the East Asian crisis. It is certainly true that the crisis in East Asia exhibited many of the same characteristics as other crises in Mexico, Brazil and Russia. They were all emerging markets that enjoyed an influx of foreign capital previous to crisis, enabled through financial liberalisation. The crises were precipitated by currency instability coupled with a loss of investor confidence and contagion. But while the relevance of this assertion is undeniable, it fails to explain the particular set of circumstances and the nature of the pattern of events that was particular to East Asia. It is clear from this analysis that the East Asian financial crisis was caused by a combination of inter-relating factors. These were both underlying conditions - leaving economies in a fragile situation even if growth was strong - and chains of events that actually brought about the crisis. The most important underlying factors were financial fragility due to the large percentage of short-term investments; mismanagement of incoming funds by domestic financial institutions that were unprepared for the scale of investment and tended to give loans to low quality enterprises; external change that undermined comparative advantages and altered the inter-regional balances; and currency inflexibility that caused pressure of local currencies when the Dollar and Yen appreciated or depreciated. Although these were the underlying causes setting the right conditions to crisis, it is evident that the most important factors in actually bringing about and spreading the crisis were currency depreciation and contagion. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Political & International Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Political & International Economics essays

  1. Since the initiation of the open door and reform policy, China has experienced the ...

    During the period, according to China's statistics, the Japanese FDI in China was US$ 955 million, which covered 12.8 percent of the total foreign FDI in China, and it was much lower than the US$4320 million investment from Hong Kong and Macao.23 According to the statistics of Japan, the total

  2. "East Asia has both greatly benefited and greatly suffered from the effect of globalisation". ...

    Contrary to this, Asia began to experience waves of 'hot money' which is what leads us to the collapse, and reform of many financial institutions in the region, as a result of globalisation, which has shifted control increasingly away from the national governments to the MNCs and financial institutions.

  1. Doing business in emerging economics

    docks, water supply, electricity and telecommunication to be the priority of economy revival. The Chinese Government vigorously supports the Chinese enterprises to participate in infrastructure in African countries and intensify the cooperation in technology transfer and management. 2) Natural resources development: Africa is abundant of various natural resources.

  2. Economic growth in China

    percent of the total project sand 72.6 percent of the total capital investment. In the contrast, the manufacturing sector just covered 48 percent and 15.1 percent of the total respectively. Among the investment in the non-manufacturing sectors, the investment in the service industry occupied the highest ratio, which reached the US$ 320 million.

  1. Managing Financial Resources.

    All EU decisions and procedures are based on the Treaties, which are agreed by all the EU countries. Initially, the EU consisted of just six countries: Belgium, Germany, France, Italy, Luxembourg and the Netherlands. Denmark, Ireland and the United Kingdom joined in 1973, Greece in 1981, Spain and Portugal in 1986, Austria, Finland and Sweden in 1995.

  2. The Opium Wars - Causes and Consequences.

    for sailing through a port other than Canton and for inappropriately showing petitions to the emperor. 7 Meanwhile, the demand for Chinese tea, porcelain, silk and other decorative goods by Europe and America increased in a steadfast fashion, and Westerners began to have to pay for Chinese produce by means

  1. Causes and Effects of the Global Financial Crisis

    (Wikipedia, Causes of the 2007â2012 global financial crisis, 2012) During the years leading to the crisis, i.e. between 1997 and 2006, the price of the typical American house increased by 124%. This housing bubble resulted in quite a few homeowners refinancing their homes at lower interest rates, or financing consumer

  2. Discuss the assertion that the sole purpose of the tax system is to promote ...

    in many OECD countries. For a company to have to pay VAT they must provide goods or services and have a turnover greater than the taxable threshold in their country. All businesses above the threshold are required by law to register for VAT.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work