• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Changing definitions of equality lie at the heart of educational policy during the twentieth century". Do you agree?

Extracts from this document...


"Changing definitions of equality lie at the heart of educational policy during the twentieth century". Do you agree? Maximilian Hirn, Essay 4 The want of education and moral training is the only real barrier that exists between the different classes of men. Nature, reason, and Christianity recognize no other. Pride may say Nay; but Pride was always a liar, and a great hater of the truth. - Susanna Moodie From the very beginning Britain's national education policy was crucially determined in its pace and direction by three elements: attitudes to social order and equality, concerns about economic and military strength and financial constraints. This was already apparent in the process that led to the introduction of universal elementary education in the late 19th century. The creation of a comprehensive system of elementary schooling was for long held up not only by a reluctance to foot the bill for such a large public project but also by upper-class fears that, as one MP expressed it: ...giving education to the labouring classes of the poor...would teach them to despise their lot in life, instead of making them good servants...to which their rank in society had destined them 1 Elementary education's eventual introduction in 1870 owed much to concerns that British industry and military were falling behind Prussia's due to insufficiently educated workers and soldiers.2 Furthermore, with the expansion of voting rights, that is, the increasing equality of British citizens, elementary education came to be seen not as a threat but as a necessary instrument to instil loyalty to the state in the lower classes.3 In any case, it provided the basis upon which the national education system we know today developed in the following 100 years. Economic, military and financial concerns all continued to play a considerable role in educational policy. But in the twentieth century they were overshadowed in importance by the changing definitions of equality. ...read more.


The Hadow Report was complemented by other papers, such as the Spens Report (1938) and Norwood Report (1943) which expanded on Hadow's ideas and envisaged the tripartite division of secondary education into grammar, technical and modern schools. Finally, the government published a White Paper on Educational Reconstruction (1943) in which it acknowledged that the new layout of the education system was to be 'based on a recognition of the principle that education is a continuous process conducted in successive stages'. When the Education Act of 1944 turned these suggestions into law12, it meant the end of the formal two-tier structure of state education. Free secondary education for all children between 11 and 15 was introduced. The system was to be tripartite, divided into the classic Grammar schools, secondary modern and technical schools. Pupils were to be selected for the different types based on their school records, parental wishes and the results of what became known as the 11+ examination. Despite these deep reaching changes in social attitudes and law, the private schools managed to retain their elitist character. Similarly, access to universities did not expand substantially until the 1960s and despite improvements the student body continued to have a strong social bias against children with working class background. Universal secondary education certainly was a great advance over previous policies that had excluded the majority of children from any systematic instruction between 11 and 15. However, social problems persisted and the dream of a society where class did not hinder individual development remained elusive. The secondary technical schools failed to fulfil earlier hopes placed in them and were soon abandoned by government planners. Furthermore, it emerged that the educational quality offered in Grammar schools was greatly superior to that in most secondary modern schools, the latter often being little more than a 'depository of the unsuccessful - the rag bag into which children who have not made the grade are put'.13 In this context the 11+ examinations which seemed to favour children from middle- and upper-class background became increasingly controversial. ...read more.


(1830-91), 188:1549, quoted in: Hamerow; p.163 4 Halsey, A., Webb, J., Twentieth-century British Social Trends, Macmillan Press LTD, 2000, p.182/183 5 ibid., p.183 6 ibid., p.225 7 The others were Cambridge, Durham and London (and Birmingham since 1900). A number of so-called university colleges had been founded in the second half of the nineteenth century in some industrial cities, but the vast majority of their students were part-time and few were involved in degree level teaching; see: Aldrich, R. (ed.), A Century of Education, p.77 8 Harrison, B. (ed.), The History of the University of Oxford, Volume VIII, Clarendon Press, 1994, p.56 9 Aldrich, R. (ed.), A Century of Education, p.153 10 Fisher, H., Introducing the Education Bill, august 10th, 1917; quoted in: Maclure, S. (ed.), Educational Documents, England and Wales, 3rd ed., 1985 11 ibid. 12 Among other things the Education Act 1944 raised the school leaving age to 15, introduced free, compulsory secondary education and replaced the old arrangement of 'elementary' and 'higher' education by primary, secondary and further education, that is, 'a continuous process conducted in three successive stages'. The new priorities were also reflected in the redefinition of parental legal duty from causing one's child to receive 'efficient elementary instruction in reading, writing and arithmetic' to a duty to cause the child to receive 'efficient full-time education suitable to his age, aptitude and ability.::'. New school support provisions brought many schools formerly ran by the Church under state control. 13 Aldrich, R. (ed.), A Century of Education, Chapter 2: Secondary Schooling 14 see the in-depth study of 88 working-class children done by Brian Jackson and Dennis Marsden in the early 1960s; referred to in Aldrich, R. (ed.), A Century of Education, p.154 15 Ball, S.J., Beachside Comprehensive : A Case-Study of Secondary Schooling, 16 April, 1981 16 Early-Leaving Report (1954), Crowther Report (1959) and Newsom Report (1963) 17 Halsey, A., Webb, J., Twentieth-century British Social Trends, Macmillan Press LTD, 2000, p.227 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Teaching section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Teaching essays

  1. Reflective Report On Group Project

    states that 'respondents to self-administered questionnaires are relatively unlikey to answer to please you or because they believe certain responses are more socially desirable' (cited by Saunders et al, 2003 p283). Saunders et al go on to comment that 'respondents to telephone questionnaires and structured interviews are more likely to answer to please' (2003, p283).

  2. The vitality of the Welsh language and the bilingual future of Wales.

    southern counties who use Welsh at least some of the time has slightly increased as well in the last decade. 3.2 Social- and sociohistorical status. In the original, ethnolinguistic approach underlying this paper, one has to make a distinction between the social status and the sociohistorical status of a group of language speakers.

  1. The Hidden Curriculum:The Nature and Function of Character Education

    Unlike other situations, the motto 'do as I say, not as I do' cannot be used, simply because children will not understand this concept. They must see how to treat others with respect in order to understand the consequences, both negative and positive, of their actions.

  2. Evaluation of Birzeit University MBA Program

    Students are required to submit a project write up (thesis) reflecting various cross-disciplinary aspects covered throughout the M.B.A. program as part of the Strategic Management in the 21st Century course. Instructors Qualifications: The American University of Sharjah has over 200 full-time faculty, and the School of Business and Management has

  1. An Examination of Governance in Higher Education Institutions in England.

    money (accountability), integrity and transparency are important considerations for stakeholders in universities (see appendix 10 for principles of good governance and standards of public life). This discussion enriches the most important governance areas identified within the report including academic involvement in governance, academic regulations, the dissemination of governance, and leadership

  2. Describe the provision of schooling in england and wales

    The Act also proposed raising the school-leaving age to 16, but was not followed through until 1972, and provided for community colleges, offering education for both children and adults. This was, however, only followed through by a few LEAs.12 In 1967 the Plowden Report was effected.

  1. Look at the main Education reforms throughout the 20th Century in terms of their ...

    This had a profound effect on the organisation and curriculum of the countries post war primary schools. The Norwood report referred to three types of children: - * The academic * The technically minded * The 'rest'. The Norwood Report also said that these children were: - * Interested in

  2. Schools as Organisations. Summarise entitlement and provision for early years education.

    I have to respect the rights of every child with whom I work and not discriminate against any child because of their nationality, disability etc. I must ensure they are as inclusive as possible and respect their privacy, but also work closely with teachers, support staff within the school and

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work