• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Classroom management as method and manner".

Extracts from this document...


The research article that I have chosen to review is from a peer reviewed journal, the "Journal of Curriculum Studies". The main reason I chose this particular article is because the title, "Classroom management as method and manner", is eye catching and concisely presented. It gives the immediate impression that the article is very focused on the key issue of classroom management. The language contained within the summary is accessible in the sense that it is relatively simplistic and is not interspersed with highly technical jargon. However the summary is at times vague and long winded. For example, the sentence that begins, "We examine classroom management, manner, beliefs about classroom..." bombards the reader with a lot of information that is hard to digest all at once. I had to read the summary several times before I was able to decipher the key phrases from it. There is no doubt that the summary contains key ideas that correspond to the main body of research within the article, namely its emphasis upon "moral and intellectual goals". However it does not succeed as a good prelude to the article. It is too long winded at the beginning and does not highlight the purpose of the article clearly enough. This article is divided up into sections of manageable length. This gives it direction and makes it easy to follow. ...read more.


is helpful as it presents an opportunity to learn from two teachers who have had the benefits of time and experience in perfecting their classroom management skills. I found that I could learn from reading about the way in which these teachers interacted with the children. For example, Darlene deals with disruption during one lesson in a subtle and effective manner. She avoids halting her lesson in response to a minor disruption. Instead she controls the situation by "putting her hand up, moving towards the child, or saying his name quietly without interrupting the lesson." (p709) This vividly displays one approach of dealing with a discipline issue and helps me to visualise how I can put certain theory that I have read into practice. For example, Cohen et al recommend "stopping unacceptable behaviour before it escalates" (2000, p 286). In this passage the article displays a good example of how to do so. One of the main aims of the article is to examine the "holistic view" (p 705) of the teacher and in turn to see how this approach translates into the practice of classroom management. This is topical with regard to the changing role of the teacher and also in light of the new developments within the Northern Ireland Curriculum, proposed by CCEA (Northern Ireland Council for the Curriculum, Examinations and Assessment). Throughout the article there is great emphasis placed upon instilling in children basic values such as trust, politeness and mutual respect. ...read more.


(1970 cited on p 709) However the use of other related literature is one of the negative traits of this article. The authors relied too heavily upon the opinions and theories of others, so much so that it is hard to distinguish between their ideas and observations and those they paraphrase and quote. This is evident when during the second case study a quote from Wolfgang is used to comment upon the teaching style of Kai. (p 716) In cases like this the authors do not share enough of their own insights with the reader and their writing subsequently lacks conviction. Within the individual case studies the authors have devised lists of the qualities displayed by each teacher. This helps break the narrative and is a good recap for the main points discussed. The main points drawn from each case study are then clearly presented in tabular form within the analysis section. The two lists of the methods and manners employed by each teacher serve as a useful basis for comparison of their two styles. This table also serves as a checklist for good practice as regards classroom management. The authors have used a number of different research methods, ranging from interviews, video recordings and first hand classroom observations. They have a very thorough approach and explain in detail how they conducted their research in the opening sections. However, I feel that they could have made more use of the student interviews they conducted and this would have added an interesting dimension to the article. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Teaching section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Teaching essays

  1. Individual Practice Project

    After having consulted these identified texts the research question and its associated aims became clearer. The author agrees with those texts that emphasise the link between environment and learning. This has become a major theme within the research. It facilitated a methodology designed to explore this link.

  2. Group Management Classroom and Group Management.

    217), thus leading to granting students greater independence and autonomy through socialization. An effective conduct management plan should also refer to teacher control and administration of consequences. The following components of such a plan are focused on in this summary: acknowledging responsible behaviors, correcting irresponsible and inappropriate behavior, ignoring, proximity

  1. Comparative Study

    > Some companies like HLL give their TSIs more flexibility to modify the schemes by O/Ls. Chaper : 7 WORKING NORMS FOR TERRITORY - IN - CHARGE. The working norms for the TSI in both Parle and Perfetti have been framed keeping in mind that the TSI is the only

  2. behavior management

    (Rogers, 2007: 55) On occasion, negative discipline can be favourable to positive discipline. "I would be a hypocrite if I said I didn't shout at pupils. I do, but I try to limit these instances to the times when I really need to make a point quickly." (Dixie, 2007: 62)

  1. Reflective journal Assignment 1: Classroom management

    The elements that I cannot control include the high sugar energy drinks that they may have just consumed, the lack of sleep that they had the previous night, any emotional difficulties that are the result of a difficult home life and even a lack of breakfast.

  2. My Personal Classroom Management Plan

    I would thoroughly explain all of the rules and expectations to my students to ensure comprehension. I also would send home a copy of my classroom management plan for parents to review along with their students. It is important to create parent involvement in the classroom to promote good behavior.

  1. Classroom Management

    also could reflect the fact that whether the teacher was meeting the needs of the whole class. In this case, it might be possible that the teacher was not doing a good job in maximizing the interest of students in class.

  2. Write an essay assessing the advantages and disadvantages of structured observation as a method ...

    relationship among variables? have all indicated a reliance on ?quantitative data? (SG, p.79; Cohen et al.(2001) p.16), in other words the application of empiricism. However; when applying the? tenets of scientific faith? to the extraordinarily complex concept that is human nature as it impacts on the educational world, we must

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work