• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How labelling, streaming and the self-fulfilling prophecy lead to working class underachievement.

Extracts from this document...


How labelling, streaming and the self-fulfilling prophecy lead to working class underachievement. Aim I aim to find out how labelling, streaming and the self-fulfilling prophecy (s/f) lead to working class (w/c) underachievement (u/a). Using Ball's theories on streaming and Hargreave's study on s/f and labelling which link w/c u/a to in-school factors, I will explore the concepts that these factors can lead to a pupil not fulfilling their potential. I am interested in this subject which I drew from the educational part of the syllabus as I live in a w/c environment where I have seen w/c children u/a within the educational environment, also I have seen pupils treated differently depending on their class background. (102 words) Context and concepts Ball's study of banding provides my main focus for streaming. At Beachside comprehensive the students were placed in bands based upon information supplied by the students previous school. The bands where meant to be based upon academic criteria but Ball found other factors which effect the band a student was placed in. Ball attributed the diverse behaviours of pupils on the stereotypes which teachers place on different bands. ...read more.


Hargreave's says that labelling leads to s/f and s/f can lead to u/a, this means that a w/c stereotype can lead to a w/c child u/a. (407 words) Main research methods My chosen research method is covert observation (c/o). This is watching a situation without the participants of the study knowing that they are being watched. I will do this by not telling the participants that they are being studied. A person not knowing that they are being studied is an advantage because they will not change the way they act because of the study. From c/o you gain qualitative data (q/l), this looks more at people's feelings and emotions of the person within the study, q/l is subjective and more closely involved with the people then quantitative (q/a) methods. Q/l may be less objective then q/a but it gives more in-depth information into the area. I have chosen this area because it is hard to gain numeric data on the factors that I am researching, collecting q/l data will give me the information I need to conclude if school factors do lead to w/c u/a. To carry out my research I will pose as a student teacher in a comprehensive school where I will stay for 6 months. ...read more.


Another problem is bias, I have to be mutual towards both teachers and students, and I cannot jut take one side because my results will become flawed. Finding funds for my research is difficult because my research does not produce clear evidence. If somebody finds out that I am carrying out the research they may start acting differently which will affect my results, if somebody does find out about my study, the school I am in will be removed from my study to keep my data more accurate. I will have to get permission from the 8 schools to do the research; this may be difficult because they may not agree with the ethical side to the research. After I have finished my research I will have to tell the people what I have done, and ask for permission to publish my findings. It will be difficult for me to record my data, and the data I record may not be accurate because it is just my interpretation of incidence. Covert observation is not a does not produce numerical data witch may cause problems. The data I record will be my opinions of what is happening, and if another person carried out the research, they may not see the same things as me, so my research is difficult to repeat. (302 words) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Teaching section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Teaching essays

  1. How labeling, streaming and the self-fulfilling prophecy lead to working class underachievement.

    Band 1 students where pushed to achieve, and band 2 students where encouraged to take low-level exams. Ball produced a strong relationship between class and streaming. Because Ball saw a relationship between class and streaming and he saw how lower streams where not given the same motivation as band 1

  2. Outline and evaluate the process of Labelling and self-fulfilling prophecy As factors in the ...

    Marxist Pierre Bourdieu argued the role in education system was to reinforce class differences, he believed that it was achieved by promoting the 'Dominant Culture' of the ruling classes in the classroom through use of language, ensuring working class students were less likely to understand or be understood.

  1. Problem formulation - Background of the dissertation.

    Weakness: * The study life is longer than the other countries, 4-6 years. * Teaching language is in German, student got to learn German six month before enrolling. * Very very expensive (for the intermediary company) * Recruiting program is too complex: Sign up ---- test (English)

  2. Learner-Based Teaching in ELT Class

    The cause of children's language learning superiority may not be in the age of the person, but in the context of learning. The child happens to be learning language meaningful and the adult is not. By inference, we may conclude that the foreign language, mainly English for Chinese learners, classroom

  1. Comparative Study

    In addition, Bakeries, chemists and eateries are also covered. > Selling-in: Minimum productivity advocated is 60%. However, this is not strictly adhered to or followed up. Primarily aided by trade schemes and consumer promotions. > Selling-out: High focus on Consumer promos & FODs. > Relationship building: No structured effort observed on the part of the company.

  2. This study sets out to investigate the evolving educational role of the academic librarian ...

    As the information environment continued to diversify, and access to information began to expand, it became apparent that academic staff were no longer sufficiently able to guide and influence their students in their studies, because they did not possess the skills, knowledge and expertise necessary to facilitate their learning (Powis, 2004).

  1. A Study of The Effect of Music on the Developing Child

    a waste of energy and that the stimulus itself poses no threat. If the stimulus is changed even slightly the foetus begins to react to it again, suggesting that it can distinguish between different sounds. Even more complex behaviour has been recorded before birth.

  2. Do separate class placements "work" for students with disabilities?

    For example, the teacher in the general education classroom may be using a whole language approach to instruction, while the teacher of students with disabilities uses a highly structured, skills-based approach. Third, why take a student with a reading problem and put him with others who have the same type of problem?

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work