• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

What is action research? How can this be identified in the study?

Extracts from this document...


MEDD4022- Organisational Improvement through Action Research Introduction The author selected a study on a piece of action research carried out by an American teacher on interventions implemented to improve reluctant readers' performance, Kwok (2009) carried out an action research project to establish what promising strategies could increase third grade reluctant readers motivation and improve their reading stamina (See appendix one). This paper critically analyses the action research and puts it to trial judging its claim to being "action research". This was chosen as the findings from the research may be interpreted and applied to organisational improvement through using similar strategies to improve staff performance or for educational leaders to utilise to help their staff to improve classroom performance. What is action research? How can this be identified in the study? The definitions of action research cited in literature are abundant and diverse. Cohen and Mannion (1998), symbolic writers in research, claim action research to be an "on the spot procedure designed to deal with a concrete problem, located in an immediate situation.." One should consider two key words here, designed and problem. "Designed" emphasising the genetic composition of action research to be a systematic structure and a framework, but "problem" implies that action research is a problem solving tool, this is not the case as Cohen and Mannion (1998) continue to explain that an important feature of action research is it's cyclical nature; "the task is not finished when the project ends" it is crucial to continue to reflect and monitor and review the practice. ...read more.


Elliott (2000) would deem Kwok (2009) research to be that of action research, "a study of a social situation with a view to improving the quality of action within it." This could be interpreted to mean that unless change happens, one cannot be seem to be undertaking action research. The author in particular critiques the data collection phase of Kwok (2009) study, she does not directly involve participants but rather draws her own observations, and she study is very practitioner focused. Brown and Dowling (1998) state the very ethos of action research discourages taking important decisions other than by direct to the participants. This begins to hold Kwok (2009) study of "action research" under scrutiny. The author offers the idea that Kwok (2009) could be considered continuing professional development rather than action research. After surfing the literature, there appears to be a thin line between improving own practice by generic and every day methods and what constitutes action research. What would appear to differentiate the two is the means by which the research/improvement has been carried out. Has the research followed a model? There are several models that can be followed when undertaking action research, the earliest formation from Lewin (1930). He formed an action research cycle of planning, acting, observing and reflecting. A rather simplistic model; the issue being that once one has reflected, there maybe a need to revisit and adjust the direction or process that is being utilised in the research. ...read more.


This would work well used to make organisational improvement or to base leadership changes upon as the reflection gives time for democratic discussion and involvements, hence making the employees more subjective to change. Regardless of its critics, action research is evidently effective as a methodology. Kwok (2009) sustained improvement within the classroom, and with it's cyclical nature, improvement is continuously monitored, so any invasions to the change would be quickly identified and rectified, therefore improvement is continuous and sustained. In contrasting paradigms such as positivist and interpretive approaches, there is a definite linear holt to the process. For example, in medicine, research may be carried out on the effects of aspirin in curing headaches. A positivist approach would direct the research around quantitative data, maybe identifying the participants whose headaches were cured by the drug. An interpretive approach may focus on how well they were cured and how taking the drug affected each individual. Both approaches would end with qualitative or quantitative data evaluation, if action research was used as an approach, it may direct the focus on evaluating how effective the drug was, it may investigate what else could be used, either way it would continue until the headaches were cured. The traditional paradigms are associated with concluding the study as apposed to continual monitoring the issue or chance and taking the reins to sustain the improvement or change. This would clearly flag the action research paradigm as the ideal to follow for organisational improvement or leadership development upon which to base practice. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Education and Teaching section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Education and Teaching essays

  1. Language Development. I have chosen to observe Kaitlin for my assignment focusing on ...

    ask Kaitlin "what do ducks say" and Kaitlin replies "quack quack" Next step - To continue to give lots of praise and encouragement and introduce short repetitive stories or flashcards. Appendix 2 Observation 2, Dinner time Date - 2nd April 2010 Time commenced - 11.20am Time Completed - 11.30am Method

  2. Describe the difference between the pre-normalised and normalised child.

    He would rather cling to adults. He has a passive nature. Spontaneous and self discipline marks the beginning of yet another stage in character formation in a normalised child. Self discipline refers to persevering and completing cycles of activity that are freely begun.

  1. Explain how practical Life Exercises in the home and Montessori school can provide the ...

    The exercises lay the foundation for all the other subject areas in the Montessori classroom. This is the area where the child may first choose independent work. The practical life area contains many attractively displayed object familiar to the child, including a variety of items commonly used in the tasks of daily living, like eating dressing and cleaning.

  2. Wellbeing in Education. Critically explore the relevance and application of the concept of ...

    Find the source or root of the problem (problem focused psychology) and aim to improve the wellbeing of an individual through the theories found within the concept of positive psychology. If an individual is able to identify the stressors then this may allow the individual to make sense of that stressor and eventually to gain mastery over future stressors.

  1. What are the Benefits and Challenges of an Integrated Foundation Phase Curriculum in terms ...

    In the Foundation Phase in particular, teachers need to plan and prepare resources for continuous provision of children's play, enhanced provision where a resource is made relevant to a theme or topic and the focused tasks facilitated by a qualified member of staff.

  2. How can models of community education help to prevent youth re-offending in the community?

    There are many models of community education: lifelong learning, self-determination, self-help, leadership development, institutional responsiveness, integrated delivery of services, decentralization, community involvement and effective use of resources (NCEA, 2008). Lifelong learning is the process of learning within the community which is at any point of turn in life.

  1. Theories of Motivation in Education.

    He also suggests that disengaged students allow external forces to control their level of engagement and motivation. In order to really understand what motivates young people and how to maintain motivation in the classroom, there needs to be a shift away from behaviour modification and punishment towards actually understanding the individual's needs, goals, aspirations and feelings.

  2. Modeling complex phenomena: An investigation of two teaching approaches with fifth graders.

    In addition, as Penner (2001) supports, any experience that students have with modeling-based teaching gives students the opportunity to think and talk about natural in similar ways with those of scientists. In this context, it is thought that the development of efficient models leads to quality outcomes, that can't be achieved through other educational processes (Harrison & Treagust, 1998).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work