• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Critically examine the concept of embourgeisement and assess the extent to which this has take place in modern Britain."

Extracts from this document...


"Critically examine the concept of embourgeisement and assess the extent to which this has take place in modern Britain." Contemporary discussion of social class still tends to be couched within the theoretical frameworks laid down by Karl Marx and Max Weber in the last nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. The world has, however, changed in significant ways since the days when they were writing. Perhaps most importantly, in the early twentieth century manual workers (in manufacturing and agriculture) formed the overwhelming majority of the working population, and it was therefore the character of the working class which held the attention of sociologists. One of the most significant changes in the class structure in the past half-century has been the decline in the size of the working class and the growth of the middle class. During the 1950s and 1960s a number of sociologists claimed that a process of embourgeoisement was occurring. It suggested that the affluent member of the working class become more like members of middle class in their lifestyle and attitudes. According to the Haralambos and Holborn (2004)p.32,'the most usual way of defining the middle class is to see it as consisting of those individual who have non-manual occupations, that is occupations which involve, in some sense, an intellectual element'. ...read more.


After 1980s, many household had two cars. Jacqueline Klein and Ferdinand Zweig argued that the working classes adopt the lifestyle and the consumption patterns of the middle class and the material affluence possibly with change in political attitudes. The 'embourgeoisement' hypothesis seemed particularly persuasive in the aftermath of the decisive of Labour in the 1959 general election. Conservative Party in 1950s won three elections with increased majority each time. As with the 1979 election, twenty years later, there was a swing against Labour among the working class. "D E Butler and R Rose suggested that Labour might be experiencing particular trouble in hold the affluent working class vote". (O'Dnnell M 1977, p172) they found the number of traditional working class was declined and they should try to widen the basis of political support to include as many middle class people as possible. Despite the strong support for embourgroisement, the evidence on which it was largely impressionistic. John Goldthorpe, David Lockwood and their collaborators put the embourgroisement hypothesis to test in 1960s. They chose luton, then a prosperous area in southeast England with expanding industries. They looked at affluent workers in the car manufacturing industry and found there were still differences between the manual workers and the middle class, which suggested that embourgroisement had not taken place. ...read more.


But the evidence, in fact, shows that the "middle class" is an ideological illusion. In a feature for the Times Press, Karen A. Davis writes that high-tech consultants and managers, who used to earn more than �100,000 a year, discovered after suddenly losing their jobs that their middle-class lifestyle has completely disappeared. I totally agree with Lockwood and Fiona Devine' view that embourgeoisement had not taken place. According to Marxist perspectives of social stratification, there are two major social groups: a ruling class and a subject class. The power of the ruling class comes from its ownership and control of the means of production. The ruling class exploits and oppresses the subject class. The middle class, although they have high wages, they are wage maker. I think that the middle class are still working class, because they do not own the mean of production and I said in last paragraph which the "middle class" is an ideological illusion. The theories of "embourgeoisement"are aimed at concealing the actual proletarianization of the so-called "middle class". The influent workers and "middle class" are becoming heterogeneous, although they have largely different. The process of "embourgeoisement" or proletarianization will make working class more powerful and solidarity. In conclusion, the "embourgeoisement" is taking place rather than taken place. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1800-1899 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1800-1899 essays

  1. Comparing economic change in Britain and China from 1760 to 1914

    These regulations were definitely not beneficial for the development of commerce and economy. Actually, the rulers in Qing dynasty could not be unaware of these problems. However, in their views, comparing with economic growth the safety and stable of their political power was more crucial, and those gathering behaviors were tend to arouse innovations and uprisings.

  2. An In-depth comparison of two major Confederate Commanders: Robert. E. Lee and Braxton Bragg, ...

    Here it is already clear that there is heavy criticism of Bragg's tactics on the first day of Chickamauga. Connelly believed that Bragg had over stretched himself and missed out on two perfectly good opportunities to push the union forces back.

  1. The turno pacfico system, although fraudulent and corrupt, was the best means to ensure ...

    The king would choose the government that the party bosses and caciques had agreed upon beforehand, and would then complete the encasillado, which was essentially a rigged election that ensured victory for said chosen party and allowed power to be handed over peacefully - putting an end to long military interventionism.

  2. To what extent can Britishness be equated with Protestantism during the long eighteenth century?

    Successes in these wars led to vast colonial gains such as the acquisition of Bengal in 1757 only strengthened the idea, as will be discussed, that the defeat of popery at home and abroad and the spread of Protestantism could lead to a British Utopia of Liberty at home with a vast Empire7.

  1. Liberal Divisions and the 1870 Education Act

    On 12 June - with the fate of the bill still uncertain - Forster submitted to Gladstone a memo of the rivalling amendments that had been proposed by the representatives of the many sections of the Liberal Party. Jacob Bright, Member for Manchester favoured limiting 'the rights of discretion given

  2. To what extent did Sir Robert Peel reshape the modern British state, 1841-46?

    Gash and Blake argue these two budgets helped to push Britain toward becoming a free trade country.[18],[19] It can be argued that Peels reforms acted upon the laissez faire which was then later practised by the liberal party in the 1850?s and 1860s.[20] Furthermore the controversial repeal of the corn laws was first proposed during the 1842 budget.

  1. It didnt happen here. Why didnt socialism prosper in the USA in the period ...

    There were many failures as well however, at least in part due to the repressive policies that were often used by the authorities in dealing with strikes. Strikebreakers were commonly employed to undercut union power , and hired muscle such as the ?Pinkerton Detectives? [63], often physically assaulted workers.

  2. Why did Britain industrialise earlier than Germany?

    This helped other industries such as the chemical and electrical industries develop in the latter part of the nineteenth century. The German chemical industry became the most advanced in the world. This great industrial and economic triumph existing only after the German states were unified shows that of its numerous

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work