• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Each of the four major powers had their own motives in the peace settlements after the Napoleonic Wars.

Extracts from this document...


Each of the four major powers had their own motives in the peace settlements after the Napoleonic Wars. To a certain extent restoration did occur after 1815, once Napoleon had been finally exiled, and indeed was part of the four Great Powers' aims. However it is arguable as to how far this was their primary objective. In considering whether restoration or stability was the main goal of the major powers, 'restoration' should be considered a complete return to a previous state. 'Stability' is therefore peace and an equilibrium of power and authority that would prevent further war and conflict in Europe and the wider world. Many changes and events, needing contemplation, occurred during the period under investigation. For example, revolutions, growth of a middle class (and with that nationalism and liberalism), as well as various congresses and treaties resulting in a 'Congress System' and a 'Concert of Europe'; these all indicate the priorities, either restoration or stability, of the nations and their leaders. It is possible, as summarised by Lowe and acknowledged by many other historians including Pilbeam, to identify three core aims of the great powers, after the Napoleonic wars, at the Congress of Vienna in 1815. These were, to make the French pay for their misdeeds, further their own interests, that 'rulers expelled by Napoleon were to be restored ... ...read more.


was the main aim of the great powers as: 'The Allied governments were in accord that it should be a monarch [that replaced Napoleon], but the return of the Bourbons was far from clear-cut'11. Indeed the Comte de Provence was moderate and 'seemed to offer some guarantees [to maintain stability], but his heir ... was a strident anti-revolutionary ultra-royalist...'12. Indeed, the Comte de Provence was restored to be the monarch, however, differing from pre-war France, with a constitution as '...the returning Louis XVIII had agreed to a constitutional form of rule ...the Charter...'13. Therefore this was 'not a restoration'14 and '...deposed monarchs were only restored where convenient for the Allies'15. The only real autocratic restoration took place in Austria16. It has been argued that the restoration of territory to the pre-1789 arrangement was impossible, yet this is not so. It wasn't impossible to restore the borders of 1789, yet to re-establish the borders and maintain peace and stability, however, was impossible because '...territories ...were added to restored states in order to preserve the balance of power and to build up a strong defence...'17, even if this balance of power and defence did not later occur, as so in Italy18. Indeed 'We speak of a 'restored' Europe, but this was barely perceptible on a map' as it was 'reconstructed'19 and 'Above all, there was no attempt to restore the Holy Roman Empire'20. ...read more.


However this partial return to 1789 Europe, in itself, does not indicate that restoration was not the key aim of the Great Powers as they may have merely not achieved it. Yet still, the evidence indicates that with, many territorial borders changed, the existence of constitutions and 'legitimacy' (in the place of divine right), and the suppression of revolutions, threats and opposition to order, that restoration could not have been the main aim of the major nations. The sheer number of treaties and the organisation of the 'Concert of Europe' and the 'States System' stand alone to indicate the great powers' eagerness to co-operate, discuss and maintain peace and stability. Restoration was undoubtedly desired, yet simply as a tool for maintaining stability and as there was little alternative: 'rulers expelled by Napoleon were to be restored ... as the best guarantee of peace and stability ...'34. Indeed 'The prime concerns of government in the post-1815 decades were with domestic stability...'35 and threats to this stability, revolutions and new ideologies, were indeed dealt with. While monarchs were indeed restored, they were restored to altered thrones, realms and subjects. Therefore restoration of dynasties did occur, yet only if it would result in adding to the stability, and the maintaining of a 'Balance of Power' in Europe. Therefore the events of 1815 to 1848 do undeniably bear out the judgement: 'Stability not restoration was the goal of the great powers in 1815'. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1800-1899 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1800-1899 essays

  1. To what extent can Napoleon be seen as "heir to the revolution" in his ...

    Primary schools were left in the hands of the local authorities as they were less important in Napoleon's plans. Younger children were not his focus as they were not old enough to form their own views and beliefs, so he would be able to deal with them later.

  2. "Discuss the aims of the Congress of Vienna and the Consequences it had on ...

    This meant that no great power could have the opportunity that Napoleon had to conquer Europe. Their second aim was to prevent any political revolutions from occurring. In order to achieve this they wanted to stamp out any new ideas that had arisen, such as liberalism and nationalism, known to be the driving force of these revolutions.

  1. Did Kaiser Wilhelm II at any time exercise real power?

    Tripitz was able to persuade the Kaiser to reject a seemingly fair proposal by the British government in 1908 that would repair Anglo-German relations in return for a decrease in the rate of German battleship production15. In the few months leading up to the outbreak of war, and throughout the

  2. Why did the German economy out strip its rivals in Britain and Europe between ...

    This established the basic welfare program for Germany and between 1885 and 1900, 50 million Germans received from the program benefits worth $750 million, $250 million more that the workers had contributed. Germany regulated hours of work and conditions of pay.

  1. 'It has been claimed that Britains financial institutions were too oriented towards overseas investment ...

    These old-established industries had networks and friends,that they could count on them,when they did have investment requirements. In general,during this period there was no extra demand for capital from these old-established industries,but what is not clear is how small medium-sized industries got the financial support that they required.

  2. It has been argued that Britains poor development of industries based on science and ...

    Even when adjustments were made and new machinery were installed,owners were not discharging employees in order to avoid strikes. This led to over-manning and to a situation ''inappropriate to the conditions of mechanised mining''.Similarly,in cotton industry,the introduction of self-acting mule came as a result of disaffection and strikes among spinners.

  1. The revolutions would not have occurred without the economic crises that hit Europe in ...

    petition proposed by the citizens of Mannheim, alongside Germanic state-wide petitions, demanding trial by jury and freedom of the press. In the Italian states the revolution was led by intellectuals and agitators who desired freedom from foreign rule, notably Austrian in the north, and a liberal government.

  2. Compare and contrast the European-indigenous encounter in Australia with that of New Zealand. In ...

    The ensuing stampede to colonise, cultivate and exploit the resources and peoples of the new worlds shaped the geo-political history of our globe, and along the way trampled beneath its zealous hooves a multitude of unique cultural legacies. Focusing attention on the British encounter with the indigenous natives of Australia

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work