• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Night and Fog or the Shindler's List

Extracts from this document...


NIGHT AND FOG OR THE SHINDLER'S LIST[ML1] Night and Fog by Alain Resnais and Schindler's List by Steven Speilberg were respectively the first and the last movies that are about the Holocaust. After reading Speilberg's Oskar by Omer Bartov, which states different ways of representing the Holocaust, without any doubt, one is disturbed by his question: Can documentaries be used more effectively and truthfully than fictions? As this paper is written to find an answer to this question, examples of both documentary and fiction representations will be compared by analyzing the sudden reaction of Alain Resnais with Night and Fog, which is rebelling and the Schindler's List of Steven Speilberg, which is the first, probably the last movie possessing "hope" about the Holocaust. .[ML2] As a result of the analyze, the reasons why Night and Fog is a better representation of the Holocaust compared to Schindler's List will be mentioned. Schindler's List, which is the latest movie about the Holocaust, is probably the most spectacular one also, takes a more hopeful, positive side about the Holocaust compared to other representations. The talent of Steven Speilberg combined with the use of technology of the 90s resulted [ML3]in an extraordinary work, not only addressing the Holocaust, but also the human values[ML4]. ...read more.


Without any doubt, Schindler's List is still very grieving, and it makes people feel terrible and cry, but at least, it does not show the horrible reality that people used to see.[ML7] If, today, the discussion of representation for these works was brought up, Night and Fog by Alain Resnais would fit better to the requirements of a Holocaust representation compared to Steven Speilberg's Schindler's List. Some people say that Night and Fog is too old and some of the events might not have been discovered, but as a documentary, it is very natural, neither exaggerated like other Holocaust movies, nor like happily ending ones, including [ML8]Schindler's List.[ML9] In the movie, the concentration camps, with the fingerprints, and some recordings from the World War II, which have nothing to do with discovering events during the Holocaust, are exposed to the viewer. It is also another point of view that Night and Fog is too short for a representation.[ML10] Yes, it is short, but it is very precise, just focusing the Holocaust and especially the concentration camps.[ML11] It is neither like Claude Lanzmannz's Shoah, which is boring and lasts nearly ten hours, nor like fictional ones, during which, I curiously wait the end of the movie rather than paying attention of details of the event or environment. ...read more.


Anyway, your writing is definitely improving. B- [ML2]This main claim is very vague and doesn't help the reader to follow the argument to come. You should mention that you think SL is good in the way that it presents a hopeful message, but Night and Fog is ultimately more representative. Then the reader will know where you are heading. [ML3]resulted in [ML4]human values [ML5]Was the film quickly made by virtue of appearing "only" 10 years after the war? And in what ways does it seem quickly made? [ML6]I think you mean to say "fiction movie." [ML7]good, balanced point [ML8]Delete indicated text [ML9]The way that many parts of this sentence are pieced together sounds awkward. One might say, "Some people say that N+F is too old and some of the events might not have been discovered, but as a documtary, it is very natural . . . " [ML10]who says this? [ML11]Good point; well stated [ML12]The passive voice, "it is assumed" sounds awkward. Who assumed? You might say, "it seems that Spielberg . . . " But do you think the black and white was meant to make the film more watchable? Emir Kisagun 4 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1920-1949 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1920-1949 essays

  1. Free essay

    The Holocaust was not planned from the beginning, it was the result of a ...

    This viewpoint is supported in the J.Noakes text, 'Nazism, The Rise to Power, 1919-45' which also refers to the growing anti-Semitism within Germany prior to Hitler's ascension to power. For Noakes, the social dislocation caused by rapid urbanisation of the late 19th Century led to a rise in anti-Semitism in groups who had been disrupted by this.

  2. The Holocaust

    After she could no longer live there, she moved from farm to farm, hiding in dug outs and barns where ever anyone would hide her, until Kozowa, Poland was finally liberated by the Russians in 1941 (Beker, 2001). Those who took the risk of hiding Jews and other being persecuted

  1. What effect did World War II have on life in Barking and Dagenham?

    In fact, 27% used domestic shelters, 9% went to public shelters, and 4% used tube stations. The rest, that is, 60% were either on duty at night or didn't take any precautions and stayed at home. Most people in London who didn't have access to a garden, a trench in

  2. What were the Main Features of the Stalinist System

    This in part was due to Stalin's talent for manipulation but also in the potential he saw in the role of general secretary, a post that was considered unglamorous and unwanted and earned Stalin the nickname of "Comrade card index by other party members."

  1. Can anyone claim to be the owner of "truth" in the writing of history?

    Unites States contribution stating that it was "too negligible to deserve extended mention." Thomas also suggests that the authors in each country believe that their "own men and materials outdid the central powers" (Thomas, 1969, pp28-30) This is a perfect of example of historians missing out facts as evidence to

  2. "The only true patriot in the story of Risorgimento" "Garibaldi very nearly wrecked ...

    Garibaldi was a fighter and enjoyed being the leader of the 'people'; Cavour on the other hand was a diplomat. If Garibaldi had got to Nice war with France would have almost been inevitable. Garibaldi would have attacked and been defeated by the French and repercussions of an event like

  1. Stalin's Personality cult

    This accomplished two things developing the ?cult?. First, he proved that he was the right leader for the people of the Soviet Union and no one else could do a job as well as him. Secondly, he could develop another plan which would keep his followers under his control.

  2. J. Robert Oppenheimer: An Unappreciated Genius

    ?She was born without a right hand; the glove contained a primitive prosthetic device, a spring between the artificial thumb and forefinger? (Pais [4]). On April 22, 1904 Robert was born in his parent?s small residence. While he was still very young his family moved into a large furnished apartment near the Hudson river.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work