• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Primary Source Analysis of a document from the New York Daily Tribune, written on February 13, 1865, titled "Negroes of Savannah".

Extracts from this document...


Jerry Tran History 213 Primary Source Analysis The source of the document was clipping from the New York Daily Tribune, written on February 13, 1865, titled "Negroes of Savannah". The document was a couple of minutes of an interview between the colored ministers and church officers with the Secretary of War, Edwin M. Stanton, and Major General Sherman. The meeting took place on January 12, 1865-8 P.M. at the city of Savannah, GA, Headquarters of Major General Sherman. Among the colored ministers and church officers that had attended the interview were of African descent and originated from bondage. Some of them were released from their bondage and received their freedom by purchasing it or by the will of their masters. There were twenty members of the colored people and an appointed representative, Garrison Frazier, to "express their common sentiments upon the matters of inquiry"; some of which were various issues being addressed by Stanton and Sherman for the duration of the interview. The source addresses the African sentiment towards various issues apparently in South and the rest of the country. The South was clearly being the aggressor and the issue of slavery was increasingly becoming important to the war. ...read more.


The fifth issue was questioning the intelligence of African Americans and their ability to "maintain themselves under the Government of the United States." Of course Frazier replied without question, and stated that "there is sufficient intelligence" to attain their goals. The next issue being addressed was the how their lifestyles should be lived, whether amongst the white people or through segregated colonies of their own. Frazier's own personal preference would be to live in segregated colonies because of the "prejudice against us" in the South would be take many years for the Southerners to accept the freedmen in the south. This idea was not the expression of the majority, which Frazier clearly states as his own words. He does not seem to be a racist amongst the issue of prejudice, but he knew that the Whites or Southern Whites at that would not succumb so easily to embrace African Americans as an equal nor as a human being. The next issue addressed Frazier's position with causes and objects of the war and their understandings. Frazier spoke of the "South is the aggressor", rebelling against the newly elected President Abraham Lincoln, "without knowing what he would do." ...read more.


Frazier speaking for all, "we have confidence in Gen. Sherman," to help protect the interests of colored people saying "could not be under better hands." But his opinion is only formed from the basis of recent and short acquaintances with Gen. Sherman, which seems to exemplify the idea that the sentiments are subject to change if Sherman's idea decides to change. Overall, the document had seemed to be in a neutral point of view, because the ideas and sentiments expressed by Frazier was neither racially expressed nor was it in any way favoring that of "colored people." The statements made by Frazier were merely his opinions and thoughts upon the matter war, self-sufficiency, slavery, and freedom. Never once were racial remarks used, all answers were replied in an ordained and proper manner which seemingly was without anger nor malice towards the questions being addressed. Throughout the conversation, Stanton and Sherman had addressed Frazier accordingly, which they seemed to treat each other as an equal neither expressing any idea of inferiority on the part of Frazier and his assembly of black ministers. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Philosophy and Theology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Philosophy and Theology essays

  1. WWII Analysis

    While the United States' use of bombardment proved to be effective for the landing, properly coordinated tank fire, coupled with effective tactical maneuver, proved equally important for achieving success during the ground war. In an engagement with the Japanese on 19 January near Ridge 300 on Nafutan Point, I Company,

  2. Female power and victimhood in Genesis: a literary analysis of the story of Hagar

    Hagar and her son are depersonalised and totally undermined; verse 13 even sees an apparent undermining of God's promise to her in chapter 16. She ends the episode not by running away, as before, but by being cast out without a voice8.

  1. It has sometimes been remarked how much has been written, both by friends and ...

    some kinds of moral goodness to a greater height than had ever been attained before, though much even of what is supposed to be peculiar to them is equalled in the Meditations of Marcus Antoninus, which we have no ground for believing to have been in any way indebted to Christianity.

  2. "The journey, not the arrival matters" Frankenstein and On Giants' Shoulders

    "Einstein imagined what it would be like to ride a wave of light at the speed of light."3 This demonstrates the ability of the imagination and the amazing possibilities that it creates. However the possibilities that Einstein's theories have created have not been the focus of On Giant's Shoulders.

  1. The geopolitical differences of the Netherlands and Germany seemed to have formed the origin ...

    National opposition grew. The developments due to the Reformation were welcomed by the resistance. By taking on the Calvinist belief it gave the opposition the opportunity to demarcate from Catholic Spain. The opposition was led by William of Orange, a German count of Nassau who possessed prosperous lands in the Low Countries.

  2. So why History of Ideas?

    Some of their proposals weren't too far off the target- many modern day beliefs have been formed by expanding on and making more precise the early theories. For example, Anaximander, who I mentioned earlier, put forward the first theory of evolution.

  1. Anselm of Canterbury, also known as Anselm of Aosta and Anselm of Bec or ...

    Anselm, at Henry's behest, once again departed from England for three years (April 1103-August 1106), this time to consult with Pope Paschal II. The investiture controversy was settled only in 1107, twenty months before Anselm's death, when King Henry formally forswore the right of investiture at the Concordat of London.

  2. Should witches be procecuted in our new democratic and constitutional state?

    there is no way that missionaries can liberate society mentally from participating in killing and causing harm resulting from their belief in witchcraft, yet they are the one who confused people from the beginning. However, no attempt has been made to research in detail the nature of the beliefs in

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work