• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Queen Elizabeth 1st on Religion.

Extracts from this document...


Queen Elizabeth 1st on Religion. This document is a first hand document : it's actually a letter sent by Queen Elisabeth to some English bishops. Thus, it reflects her intention in matter of religious policy at the beginning of the her reign in 1558. Indeed, she inherited the situation left by her half-sister Mary : she had to make an short-term choice, either to stay in a Catholic Nation, or to restore Supremacy, in other words, follow or not Mary's policies. In 1559, several bishops of the Church of England asked Elisabeth for a meeting : they wanted to Continue Mary's pro catholic policies, and claimed Henry the 8th had been quarrelled with the Pope because of the influence of heretics. Her answer "as to your entreaty for us to listen to you we wave it" (line 1) is the proof that she is not about to renounce Supremacy, or create a Catholic Nation under direct control of Rome domination. This letter is then the basis of her policy followed intensely throughout her forty-five year long reign. This document is basically composed of two distinct paragraphs, one dealing with a remote period in English history, namely the very introduction of Christianity in England, and the other one dealing with a much more recent period, i.e. ...read more.


These are tow foundations of the English church not founded at all thanks to the mission of St Augustine, but by the follower of Christ. Therefore, the Pope decision to establish Austin as archbishop of Canterbury was regarded as a real invasion for the primitive English Church : "Rome's usurped authority". If people accept this version of the foundation of the Church of England, it has a significant consequence ; in 1534, when the Act of Supremacy was drafted, it was just the return of a native tradition, that had previously been broken by the Church of Rome. Indeed, in every field at that time, it was important to prove your ideas and point of view was in keeping with tradition : if you want people to believe you are right in a debate you have to show you fallow a very old tradition. And, of course, this is what Elisabeth is playing on : supremacy was based on the primitive and native tradition of the English Church. The question of Rome authority, and more precisely the question of the Pope's authority, was highly criticized by Luther. It was indeed a matter of debate on continent in the quarrel between protestant and Catholics. We can discern in Elisabeth's written reply, a real disagreement. ...read more.


However, the bishops themselves were already members of the clergy under her father's reign and supported supremacy, or at least didn't go against its principles ; which was her reply. Then she addresses those bishops directly, pointing them out, revealing that the reason they previously accepted supremacy is the simple fact that supremacy didn't mean the introduction of Protestantism, but a return to the primitive and native tradition. Thus, very subtly, she is demonstrating them they are in real contradiction with themselves. * * * Therefore, according to this official version, going to become the founding myth of the Church of England, there were continuity between the reigns of Henry and Edward ; a continuity of a preservation of primitive tradition, broken by Mary and her catholic policy. Her message is then the exact opposite of what the bishops were excepting : she highly wants to restore this continuity, with tradition as a keyword. Thus, the importance of this document is that it is one of the very first official stage of this particular traditional myth : Thanks to supremacy and its protestant identity, the Church of England preserved all the oldest primitive traditions and the true Christian faith. This created the conditions for the emergence of a distinctive religious identity neither Catholic, nor Protestant but Anglican. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1500-1599 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1500-1599 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Was there a decisive change in ideas about masculinity and femininity

    more surely by drawing sharper lines between the sexes."12 The modifications in ideas about gender stemmed from the change in ideas about biological sex. The one-sex model was abandoned in favour of the two-sex model. This new model stated that men and women were fundamentally biologically different in ways that were defined at birth.

  2. Tudor Coursework - Elizabethan foreign policy.

    However, Philip II saw it differently he saw it in terms of religion. Philip II saw Elizabeth I helping foreign Protestant heretics. Philip went on to interfere in the French wars of religion, a further example of him being led by religion.

  1. The Authority Conflict: Machiavelli & Martin Luther

    Machiavelli and Luther agreed that people are governed by an evil natural necessity, but the former was against thwarting these desires, while the latter believed it was necessary to accept Christ and earn the grace that turns one virtuous. Though he did recognize the importance of, and therefore promote, morals,

  2. Why Were Some of the English Poor Laws passed between 1531 and 1598 Controversial?

    had obtained charities in the past. Such as the monasteries, whose dissolution in 1538 and 1547 created a gorge in poor relief which needed to be filled. Another factor creating hardship was the fact that the English population was growing at a rate of 0.6 per annum, and as Wrightson

  1. Why was it so difficult to decide between true and false visions and apparitions ...

    As well as this Augustine mentions how false revelations can be explained through insanity4. Particular attention was also paid to influential thinkers such as by Jean Gearson. In his writing Distinctione Verarum a falais(1400) Gearson suggests that for a revelation to be real it must possess five articles; correctness, annunciation, humility, docility and patience.

  2. To what extent was Elizabeth I able to create a positive image throughout her ...

    John Knox had also been decrying the "monstrous regiment" of women before Elizabeth came to power, but now he changed his tune, backtracking and coming to the conclusion that Elizabeth would be a good Queen as she was a protestant heroine and would rule as fairly and virtuously as a Deborah or Astraea.

  1. After the accession of Henry VIII, England began an inevitable change towards Protestantism, which ...

    Mary's strategy was to return to Rome. Mary rescinded the Edwardian Prayer Book, replaced Protestant bishops with Catholic ones and prohibited clerical marriage. Transubstantiation was upheld and images and altars returned. Repression was part of Mary's strategy, with almost 300 Protestants burned at the stake.

  2. A summary of the themes covered in St. Xaviers letter to the Society of ...

    Those who could read and write were asked either asked to make copies of the Christian Doctrine or learn and recite them to the fellowmen. All the village men met on a feast day when they celebrated and had meetings.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work