• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Problem of the Grudge Informer describes a situation that two major philosophical theories of lawLegal Positivism and Natural Law Theorygreatly disagree on.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Scott Schauer Philosophy of Law 7/21/10 Legal Reasoning to the Grudge Informer Dilemma The Problem of the Grudge Informer describes a situation that two major philosophical theories of law-Legal Positivism and Natural Law Theory-greatly disagree on. It provides a legitimate question for Natural Law theorists about the objective moral order of justice systems, which is accessed by reason and more specifically, the extent of which morality can play in criminalizing an apparent regime of terror. On the other hand, Legal Positivists challenge that whether a law has an integral moral aspect makes no difference to the prosecution of an otherwise anarchist government. For them, law is a system of orders or commands enforced by power. It is a pure human product. Herein lies the debate of the 'Grudge Informer.' The Legal Positivist position holds that the informers were acting out of obligatory concern for the laws of that time and are therefore, legally guarded by those laws for any legitimate criminal offense. The Naturalist would respond indignantly towards the rigid legal position of the Positivists and would consequently punish every 'Grudge Informer' for acts of willful harm and perhaps murder. ...read more.

Middle

To accept the first deputy's recommendation would take on a strict positivist role, which is insufficient to the misconduct performed by the informers. In the second deputy's recommendation the same resolution is reached, but by the conclusion that there were no laws at all during that time. He says, "What they did do was neither lawful nor contrary to the law, for they lived, not under a regime of law, but under one of anarchy and terror" (Fuller 161). He admits that it was a "war of all against all" and that the "so-called grudge informers were just one phase of that war" (Fuller 161). Logically, this cannot be a significant reason to overlook the atrocities that the informers intended to commit. The second deputy is essentially sweeping the entire period of the Purple Shirt regime under the rug, including the grudge informers. It occurs to me, as in the first deputy's recommendation, that an apathetic attitude is suggested toward the wrong actions of the grudge informers. Something must be done simply to avoid another reign of terror. To not act would be the most harmful act. ...read more.

Conclusion

Somewhere in between those two extremes lies the problem of the 'Grudge Informer', which is why the third deputy offers punishment on a case-by-case basis. This particular group of people within the Purple Shirt regime knowingly used the legal system to the benefit of themselves and not of the entire society. In this case, the grudge informers were operating under unjust laws even though they were following their laws. Saint Thomas Aquinas would agree with me when he declared, "An unjust law is a human law that is not rooted in eternal and natural law" (MLK 80). This brings us back to the debate between Naturalists and Positivists in which I am inclined, as is the case for Fuller, to believe that there is some internal morality within law; that "Law is not merely order, but good order" (Adams 44). The informers themselves exemplified the positivist tradition in that they didn't hesitate at the possible morality of the situation, but followed the law with tunnel vision and consequently should be punished accordingly. Like Fuller, my perspective of the 'Grudge Informer' is not strictly from the naturalist's but, rather, one that doesn't agree with the positivist's. As a result, neither Fuller nor I would agree with any deputy but the third. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Philosophy and Theology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Philosophy and Theology essays

  1. Natural Law.

    According to St. Augustine the eternal law 'is transferred into the human heart not by passing from one place to another but by imprinting itself on the heart, as the image of a ring passes into the wax without abandoning the ring' (De Trinit., bk.

  2. Esolving Problems on behalf of the following terms - Utilitarianism, Situation Ethics, Secularisation, and ...

    there is a disturbance in nature; therefore breaking the 'Natural Laws' and therefore it is morally wrong and it is against God. Second Issue - Aborting a deformed foetus: A person with perceptions connected to Utilitarianism would disagree that the deformed foetus should be aborted because the consequences of the

  1. Nonviolence: Martin Luther King, Jr. and Tich Nhat Hanh

    and injustice which are the fertile soil in which the seed of communism [as social strife] grows and develops" (King). As a result of this revelation, part of King's speech calls for peace through an attempt to understand the enemy and the effects war has had on the Vietnamese people.

  2. "Heaven and Hell are concepts without philosophical foundations". Discuss.

    Relating to this is the question "are heaven and hell required to defend the goodness of God in the face of evil and suffering?" The theodicy's I am going to look at are those of Augustine and Irenaeus. The Augustinian theodicy represents the traditional Christian response to the problem of evil and includes both philosophical and biblical strands.

  1. "The Aesthetics of Saint Thomas Aquinas"

    Clearness of Beauty - Claritas Claritas refers to the expressive capacity of organisms or the radioactivity of the form of things. "The beautiful for St. Thomas is the same good, and they differ in aspect only. For since God is what all seek, the notion of good is that

  2. Is the only good saint a dead saint?

    This network of relics added prestige and indeed power to relic sites. The shrine of Felix outside Nola in Gaul became a provincial centre, whilst the keeper of the shrine, Paulinius, rose from a humble ascetic to an imperial arbiter in the papal election of 419.

  1. Anselm of Canterbury, also known as Anselm of Aosta and Anselm of Bec or ...

    Indeed, this rightness accords with a Rightness that is one and the same in them all, and that continues to exist even when the things themselves and their natural rightness perish. Anselm (borrowing from his own Monologion 18) infers that this Rightness, which is perceptible by the mind alone, is eternal.

  2. 'Look at you. You black, you pore, you ugly, you a woman. Goddam he ...

    Celie and Shug confide in each other about the events of their lives. Shug explains to Celie why she has no children 3'My kids went they grandma, she say.' Celie tells Shug of the sexual abuse she has suffered throughout her life.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work