To what extent were the revolutionaries in France and Austria responsible for their own failure?

Authors Avatar

To what extent were the revolutionaries in France and Austria responsible for their own failure?

The 1848 revolutions took place in most parts of Europe was considered to be one of the heights of nationalism and liberal development in the 19th century. However, despite the wide extent of influence of this revolution and its impact, it was put out within the year after with very little, if any, success at all. The revolution did not prevail mainly because it was a "leaderless" revolution with little or even no organization at all, while much of the time was spent in lobbying and negotiating by the idealistic and inexperienced intellectuals, rather than fighting against the counter-revolutionary forces and doing the practical things.

The 1848 revolutions were considered as a "leaderless" revolution.  Most of the uprisings in the period were more like public activities without some capable and popular leaders to lead the mass. In Italy, the once considered liberal Pope Pius IX refused to take up the responsibility in leading the revolutionary forces to rise against Austrian reactionary forces. This led to the neutrality of the Papal States in the revolution and her sound existence in under Austrian restoration while the Austrian Army suppressed the revolutionaries.

Join now!

Another factor contributing to the failure of the 1848 revolutions was the lack of organization between revolutionary groups. Although revolts were widespread throughout Europe, little or even no organization or cooperation whatsoever existed between revolutionary groups of various countries or even regions of a country. This is pretty much due to the different aims and goals among revolutionary groups of various kind: Those in France were divided in the form of governments and their philosophies as Monarchists, Bonapartes, Republicans, Socialists. Red republicans – radicals said that they would support hopers of the urban masses. Unfortunately they weren’t united. Their leaders ...

This is a preview of the whole essay