• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Which was the greater threat to Elizabeth's Church, Puritans or Catholics?

Extracts from this document...


Nadim Haji 13.4 22/02/04 History Essay - Mr White Which was the greater threat to Elizabeth's Church, Puritans or Catholics? From the beginning of her reign Elizabeth made her mark as the new ruler of England. However if it was not foreign invasion or an internal plot she feared, then it was being a single woman in a mans world, and amidst all this Elizabeth sought acceptance from her people. Now along with all of this Elizabeth had to juggle the impending danger of various religious groups threatening not only her but also the entire kingdom, and not to mention its potential for a civil war. Elizabeth saw religion as 'the ground on which all other matters ought to take root...' and this meant that she took it very seriously, and an attack or threat to her church was also one on her. Both Puritans and Catholics surrounded Elizabeth wherever she went, and few were public about the views, which made the threat an even bigger danger as it could not be met head on. The Puritans, who were considered the great threat to Elizabeth's uniformity, existed largely in the House of Commons. They predominantly had a disliking for the Settlement and being in parliament was the ideal place to express their 'views'. This was certainly the way the Puritans in parliament were wanting things to go, because it meant that they would now be able to attempt to influence and reform the church further in their favour from the inside. ...read more.


What then proceeded was a direct assault on Elizabeth in the form of pamphlets, a pamphlet warfare began between the Elizabethan Church and those for Presbyterianism. For a time the Elizabethan Church was on the defensive as it was the Presbyterians posing the threat. The situation infuriated Elizabeth, moreover because those who were against her were now trying to convert others and it was situations like this that had the potential for civil unrest had they gained much momentum. One of the reasons I believe Puritanism was so appealing and popular was because of its patriotic allure, simple because it opposed the papacy and Roman Catholicism. Upon Elizabeth's accent to the English throne, she inadvertently brought back Puritans from exile. They saw her as their saviour, and they saw the time as an opportunity to reconstruct the Protestant church and the hope of once again converting the mass of Catholics. They too acted as a pressure group, especially as they viewed Elizabeth's changes as reminiscent of the Catholic mass and not the Prayer Book. It is difficult to assess just how widespread and strong the Puritan movement was; we do not know for certain that the lay patronage played a part in protecting Presbyterian, but we know that they were anti Whitgift as opposed to pro Presbyterian, and there was also large scale anti Whitgift action in both parliaments. Catholics in England posed a greater force to be reckoned with, not to mention historians estimates that 50-70% of the population was still Catholic. ...read more.


In conclusion both Catholics and Puritans posed great threats to Elizabeth's Church, but they both had very different angles, perspectives and prospects. The Puritans were the in the minority, and they felt hard done by Elizabeth's settlement, but they should have felt lucky knowing that most of the country was still Catholic. Attempting to up against the queen and the majority of the nation was not the best idea. The Puritans didn't even have central ideals, because they each wanted different things, with some being to radical and some not at all. They were too divided; instead they made themselves a less menacing force simply by being so indifferent about what they wanted. The Puritans ended up with a large number of different groups, some more influential than others, but none of them large enough to achieve any real goals to change the Settlement and Elizabeth's Church to a more Protestant direction. The Catholics being long established, and England being surrounded by Catholic countries surely posed a bigger threat to Elizabeth's Church; there was always a threat of invasion from a foreign power, and it eventually did come in the form of the Armada and resulted in the country uniting together. There was also the Pope whispering down people's necks to get Elizabeth to convert back, and there were the large numbers of priests who were secretly performing Catholic ceremonies and there was not much that could be done because Elizabeth knew that outside the major towns Catholicism was still the dominating force no matter what she instated in her Church. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1500-1599 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1500-1599 essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    "From her arrival in 1568, Mary Stuart posed a major threat to the security ...

    3 star(s)

    The security of Elizabeth's throne is definitely challenged here, although it does not go ahead, it is warning of what can happen, and foreign involvement from the leading two Catholic powers in Europe, i.e. Spain and France in supporting Mary Stuart cannot be taken lightly.

  2. Marked by a teacher

    Was there a decisive change in ideas about masculinity and femininity

    Women's labour was valued within the household however her husband was still expected to be the main provider. "it was this impression of ability and sufficiency which house holding men were anxious to maintain since it...conferred a degree of authority"10 Despite this women were still not deemed as equals in

  1. Tudor Coursework - Elizabethan foreign policy.

    Philip was worried about Protestant traders from England. Philip banned English trade and merchants. This is a good example of how Elizabeth I and Philip II's relationship differs over religion. Whilst Philip banned trade for bringing in Protestant influences. Elizabeth reacted by banning trade from the Netherlands under a trade

  2. In what ways has Roman Catholicism been an example of both religious tradition and ...

    This shows that while just 100 years earlier Roman Catholicism had been tradition it was now a dissenting force in the England of the 17th Century. It was in 1633 that the Roman Catholic dissent started to gain power as William Laud began to move the Church of England back towards Catholicism with the support of Charles I.

  1. Assess the impact of the opening of the Atlantic World in the 15th, 16th ...

    The Dutch however were very persistent, as resistant merchants lived by the maxim "God is good but Trade is better". Having been removed from Brazil, the Dutch were now looking for a new place to grow sugar; this place would be none other than Barbados.

  2. Assess the view that the Dutch rebels challenged Philip IIs rule primarily in defense ...

    not content with being able to practice their belief privately, but campaigned for their freedom to do so without risk of persecution - this is often regarded as the start of the first revolt. The town magistrates could have prevented this 'heresy', but they were no longer prepared to proceed

  1. Did the acquisition of Portugal in 1580 represent a greater success for Philip II ...

    Furthermore, Lepanto dealt the Turks an enormous military blow. They lost 200 galleys and 30,000 men8, as well as their admiral Ali Pasha9, so although the capture of Cyprus suggests otherwise, the Christian victory at Lepanto greatly reduced the Turkish threat. Therefore the victory at Lepanto did, to an extent, represent a success for Philip in terms of defending Europe and Catholicism from the Turks.

  2. Anne Boleyn - historians such as G. W. Bernard, E. W. Ives and Retha ...

    He challenges the de Carles poem Bernard relies on because the woman in the poem is never specified and because Anne had a close friendship with Elizabeth Browne and therefore the woman's betrayal would, "contradict[s] their friendship." Ives also believes that indirect interpretations of events altered their original meanings and he supports this possibility with specific examples.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work