• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why did Chartism Fail?

Extracts from this document...


Why did Chartism fail? The question why Chartism failed and why it was so quickly has never been answered to a satisfactory level. If Chartism was a reaction to hunger and to the disorganisation of traditional industries then the good economic climate which followed the Great Exhibition of 1851, the increase in stability of Britain's industries in this period and the organisation in which new industrial workforce was allowed to develop is enough to say why Chartism declined and died. The 'hunger Chartism' was the rational movement moved into the organisation of consumer cooperatives, new model trade unions, reading-rooms, mechanics' institutes, local government, friendly societies and other organisations which skilled workers developed at the end of the nineteenth century. This implies to some extent a betrayal by the skilled and frequently employed of the ambitions of the less fortunate associate. This could mean that the idea of 'a conscious move by the employing class to divide the skilled workers from the rest'. The Chartist period shows a conflict between the 'hegemonic middle class and the traditional culture of the British working class'. This conflict is only seen by the end of Chartism and by the inclusion of articulate members of the working class into the traditions and values of the middle class. (Thompson p. 330) In the 1860s when parliamentary reform was looked at again under the leadership of the Reform League many of the old Chartist leaders e.g. ...read more.


However, we also have to look at why Chartism failed, is it because of the leadership, the flawed leader being Feargus O'Connor. Chartists aimed for one man one vote but this was not achieved until after the Second World War and their vision of Parliament who would be responsible to the whole people, was never achieved. Working men were carefully admitted into the electoral system between 1867 and 1919, but as more people were admitted the rules changed. The power of the non-parliamentary elements of government, civil service, the judiciary and other advisory organisations, were only accessible to those who had been educated within a system where the working class people were excluded. The first working men to enter Parliament went through the cordon sanitaire of Liberalism. These men were 'safe' men who showed reliability by cooperation with the Liberals in local politics or industrial negotiations. 'The Chartists' aim of a free, universal system of education, controlled by the communities in which children lived, also died with Chartism'. The post-Chartist years were regarded by a series of Factory Acts with educational provisions, similar by an increase in a network of 'provided' schools, offered by rival religious bodied which were supported by government grants in the 1870 Act after this school attendance became compulsory. The Chartists aim of an education system moved further away in the post-Chartist period and finally disappeared. ...read more.


Julian Harney and other leaders in the movement in East London believed themselves to be apostles of 'that great philosopher and redeemer of mankind, the Immortal Thomas Paine' they established the East London Democratic Association in 1837 and broadcasted its objective ' the achievement of a democratic and republican England-a natural society based on the principles of liberty, equality and fraternity'. The hungry people of the industrial North and Midlands attached more importance to the social and economic consequences which were a result from gaining the franchise than to manhood suffrage itself. The aspirations were too sectional and often too formulated to be seen as an economic programme of the whole movement supplementary to the Charter. Therefore, everyone agrees that the achievement of the Six Points was a crucial first step. (Mather, p. 26-27) Chartism failed in its purpose on effecting an immediate transition to democracy they contributed to the slow evolution of the British constitution in a democratic direction. The Chartists campaign had encouraged a portion of the middle class in taking up franchise reform to win over the working class support in order to win against Toryism and aristocratic privilege. The Complete Suffrage movement of 1842 and the New Reform movement of 1848 were both linked to the Chartists. The Chartists learnt slowly that constitutional change could be brought about if they cooperated with the middle class radicals; the movement played a part in building up the pressure which produced the 1867 Reform Act. (Mather, p. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree 1800-1899 section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree 1800-1899 essays

  1. Did Disraeli achieve his aims in his social reforms 1874-80?

    But is did represent the most substantial implementation in domestic reform on the nineteenth century, and did go some way to improve the quality of life for many, as it became the basis for some future reforms. It also represents the best effort at social reform considering the mood of

  2. Why did the 'constitutional, gradualist route' of Gladstone's Liberal ministries fail to achieve his ...

    basis for gradual improvement".14 Kimberley's prognostication was very close to the truth. Neither act actually destroyed the root of the problem; the chance to pacify Ireland through land reform was squandered. Although the second Land Act accomplished what the first did not with reference to controlling rents, Gladstone's failure to

  1. US History. The Womens Rights Movement Through the Civil War.

    New Jersey: (Ruters University Press, 1992), 1. 5Duncan, Joyce. Shapers of The Great Debate on Women's Rights. (Connecticut: Greenwood Press, 2008), 63. 6 Kerr, Lucy Stone Speaking Out for Equality,2. 7Flexner, Century of Struggle, The Woman's Rights Movement in the United States, 64. 7Ibid., 64. 8Duncan, Shapers of The Great Debate on Women's Rights, 63.

  2. Liberal Divisions and the 1870 Education Act

    national system of education, and the �20,000 grant was initially equally distributed between the British and Foreign School Societies. However, by 1834 the latter had exhausted its local funds and was thus unable to make a proportionate advance. By 1839 the National Society was taking three-quarters of the grant.

  1. What interpretations can be made as to the extent of brigandage and also the ...

    This was extremely difficult when the lack of roads throughout the country created a distinct lack of communication. In actual fact, there were twenty-four communes in Naples alone that were not provided with suitable roads. These areas were often populated by the lower classes that faced a daily battle against economic hardship.

  2. 'The Republican Party of 1860 bore little resemblance to the Republican Party of 1900'. ...

    Douglas, Abraham Lincoln declared that a black man 'is not my equal in many respects - certainly not in color, perhaps not in moral and endowment. But in the right to eat bread, without leave of anybody else, which his own hand earns, he is my equal and the equal of every living man'.

  1. Biography of Thomas Wentworth

    A scandal arose in 1631, in which a Sir David Foulis of Yorkshire began spreading rumors of Wentworth embezzling Knighthood fines. For this attack on his character, a tactic not unfamiliar to government figures of the period, Wentworth brought swift and extreme vengeance, charging Foulis with libel and sending him to prison for seven years.

  2. It didnt happen here. Why didnt socialism prosper in the USA in the period ...

    better working conditions, not as a tool of the masses to achieve revolutionary political goals, sometimes referred to as ?business unionism?[51], and a key factor in the disconnect between organised labour and political socialism The rapid economic expansion during the post-reconstruction era, referred to by Mark Twain (1835- 1910)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work