• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast the prosecution of witches in Scotland and England.

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast the prosecution of witches in Scotland and England. The treatment of and prosecution of witches differed to a high extent in Scotland and England in the 16th and 17th centuries. Many factors played a role in the prosecution of witches in Scotland and England and the differences between the two countries such as different legal systems, differences in religious beliefs in each country and politics also played a key role. Witches were prosecuted on the basis of different legal systems that existed in Scotland and England, which judged the extent of punishment for witches. In England, witches were prosecuted through statute law whilst in Scotland, witches were prosecuted through the use of Roman law, which was more inquisitorial than the English approach. The Scottish and English process of witchcraft punishment differed as the approach taken in Scotland was a lot more vicious with the use of violent torture. This was not the case for the England method. The much less physical methods in England were likely to have stemmed from differences in religious belief between the two countries. Witches were believed to have signed a pact with the devil and as a result, the Scots, where Puritanism was highly followed, found the need to use torture to construct evidence, which would have been used in witchcraft trials. ...read more.


The 1547 law also stated that if a person was found to be practicing 'black witchcraft' in order to harm another human being, that person would be liable to a prison sentence of one year. The systems used to prosecute witches reveal profound differences between England and Scotland in this respect but with the death penalty the consequence of killing by witchcraft, the English prosecution system was moving towards one that was more in line with her Scottish acquaintances. The interrogation of suspected witches used by the English and Scottish differ to a high extent. It can be strongly argued that Scotland had the most brutal methods of interrogation of suspected witches on the continent. Witches were tortured in a despicable fashion. For example, some suspected witches would have their fingernails torn off while others may have had their legs shattered and on some occasions, witches would experience both forms of torture plus more. Other forms of torture such as isolation and sleep deprivation were also commonly used in the interrogation process. The aim of these acts of torture in the interrogation process was to force suspected witches into confessing to being a witch as well as naming their accomplices. ...read more.


In England a different legal system was used from that in Scotland and took a much less extreme approach towards the interrogation of suspected witches. Different religious beliefs in Scotland and England may have explained the profound differences between the English and Scottish prosecution system. Although the English prosecution system was brought more into line with that of Scotland in terms of the introduction of the death penalty for those found guilty of killing through witchcraft, the manner in which witches were killed differs greatly with the burning of witches in Scotland as opposed to hanging witches in England. This indicates major differences in the extremity of the punishment in the eyes of the Scottish and the English. After the mid 1600's, the prosecution of witches began to decline and there is little evidence of witch-hunting and witch prosecutions there after (in the 17th and 18th centuries). However, when witch prosecutions were at their peak, there were mainly differences rather than similarities between the Scottish and English approach to the notion of witchcraft and resulting witch prosecutions. 1 Alan C. Kors and Edward Peters. 'Witchcraft in Europe. 1100-1700. A Documentary History' (University of Philadelphia Press. Inc., 1972). P. 194. 2 Christina Larner. 'Witchcraft and Religion. The Politics of Popular Belief'. (Oxford, 1984). P. 31. 1 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree English Legal System section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree English Legal System essays

  1. Why was there so much variation in the judicial prosecution of witchcraft within Early ...

    In Wurzburg in Germany for example, 900 people were executed, and in Scotland the North Berwick Trials were based largely on the accused having made compacts with the devil6. The Scottish belief in demonology also shows how the 'zeal for prosecuting witches was infectious'7, as it was an idea brought back from Denmark by James VI.

  2. Free essay

    Bail procedure in England and Wales

    In 1974 Robert Martinson, American researcher held a debate, focused on rehabilitation programmed for prisoners, called 'what works'. At the end of the debate, a conclusion was made that 'nothing works'.7 However in 'The Coming Penal Crisis' (1980), by A.E.

  1. Legal Systems in Scotland

    Only in special cases does it stand as a court of first instance. Appeals are heard by at least 3 Senators, the chief justice is the Lord President, and judges in the Inner House do not sit with a jury.

  2. Feminism as an ideology

    The first chapter I have chosen to discuss is 'He knows he can make money out of you', where Smith discusses the portrayal of the female in movies as an evil or helpless character and that the chauvinist directors such as Brian De Palma and Hitchcock impress this image on unsuspecting audiences.

  1. Are Evil Intentions A Crime?

    During a routine traffic stop, it was discovered that the trunk of the car Phillips was driving contained an extensive arsenal of riffles, ammunition, and other such items considered to be part of a classic "bank robbery kit" (Robinson 4).

  2. Social transformation impacts directly and indirectly upon crime and the reactions to it. Discuss ...

    and crimes as proto-political resistance (Hobsbawm 1972:5). It is however important to note that the concept of what is and is not a social crime has been highly debated (Lea, 2002:37) For the rural masses, who were excluded from political representation in the eighteenth century, food riots were another form

  1. The method of trial used in England from approximately the tenth to the twelfth ...

    in cases where the charge was only a matter of general suspicion, "a charge in which not only witnesses but even a specific accuser would be lacking."14 One source notes the importance of oaths in stating, The oath, the corner-stone of medieval judicial procedure, was, in some sense, an ordeal,

  2. You are asked to review and critically evaluate the current law applying to Scotland ...

    For prosecution under s.1, it is necessary to show that the accused drove a "mechanically propelled vehicle", in a public place, in a dangerous manner, and thus caused the death of another person. 'Dangerous driving' is defined in section 2A of the Act6 (1)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work