• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Data Protection

Extracts from this document...


DATA PROTECTION The Data Protection Act has been a topical subject in recent press after the death of the two young girls Jessica Chapman and Holly Wells who were murdered by their school caretaker Ian Huntley. It has become apparent that the misinterpretation of the Data Protection Act by the Humberside Police force has led to such a tragedy. After great investigation during the Soham trial, the eight principles of the Data Protection Act were bought to the attention of the government and there had been an urgent call for analysis and review of the existing act for both in the interest of police intelligence forces and the safety of the general public. The Data Protection Act is an act that protects individual's data from being exposed freely and from being misused. The acts main objective is to protect individuals' civil rights and to ensure that the information held about them can be rectified or updated. There are eight main underlying principles that compose the Data Protection Act. "Information which is referred to as 'personal data' should be processed fairly and lawfully" (Bainbridge, 2000, Introduction to Computer Law). This is one aspect, which the Humberside police force had difficulty in understanding since 'it is up to individual police forces to decide what information should be retained.' At the same instance as choosing what information is being kept of criminals there should also be a valid reason for it, as it is in the interest of the police to protect criminals as well as keep their records. ...read more.


(Bainbridge, 2000, Introduction to Computer Law) "A balance must be struck.... protect public from crime" (www.Guardian.co.uk Q&A Data protection Act an the Police 18/12/2003). If personal data of Ian Huntley was 'adequate' enough to cause injury and relevant to the safety of the society then the previous allegations should have been retained and precautions should have been taken towards him; although the originality of the information was not gathered for the purpose of vetting he was clearly a threat to the Humberside community. There obviously had been severe confusion about the information that Huntley had presented to the police officers and there had been an element of police misinterpretation and wrong human judgement. This led to poor police intelligence and awareness and the failure of storing both his surnames of 'Nixon' and 'Huntley' as one. Not only was this an error but 'one member of staff...wrong date of birth of Huntley' (www.bbc.co.uk Police chief admits Dec 2003) "Personal data shall be accurate and, where necessary, kept up to date" (Bainbridge, 2000, Introduction to Computer Law) then surely the previous allegations should have been collected and kept up to date on the criminal records database. It has become apparent that the reason for information not being kept up to date was due to "the backlog of un-entered case results and the absence of strategic prioritisation" (www.bbc.co.uk 18/12/2003) this initially meant that there was no strategy as to what information needed to be kept and updated and what information needed to be eliminated from being stored for a further period of time as necessary. ...read more.


Referring back to the quotation in question, it seems as though if the police had "Deleted all the information regarding Huntley from our data files because of the Data Protection Act requirements..." then how were still 'retained on magnetic tape' it remains a mystery and that even though the information was available through another source how could the Data Protection Act be misinterpreted remains unquestionable. The eighth principle did not appear to be an issue in the case of the Huntley. This principle would have only applied if Huntley were to escape or leave the country and therefore he would be a risk in another country. The Data Protection Act has been a central source of blame during the Soham trial. It is evident that the Data Protection Act is a 'cumbersome and inelegant piece of legislation' with no guidelines to explain what information is required for retention and for what length of time. In hindsight it is easy to claim that there is a need for common logic application in order to comply with the piece of legislation however, understanding the law in its correct format lies beyond human judgment in such critical cases. To discourage such situations from re-occurring the information commissioner should most definitely consider sending all police administration staff on training and ensure that there is almost a correct way of making an intuitive judgment on collecting and storing information. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Employment Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Employment Law essays

  1. Employment and Law

    Stress can be considered as a reaction that some one can have to excessive pressure at work. As in this case it is clear that due to increase in workload, Lillian has suffered from anxiety, panic attack and depression. It is important for Lillian to show that the psychiatric injuries

  2. Employment Law

    Once the employee has proved that he was dismissed, the burden of proof passes to the employer, under s.98 ERA 1996, to show the reason for the dismissal and that it fell within one of the categories for fair dismissal25, which are related to the ability or qualifications for the

  1. Discuss and analyse the legal concept of protected trade dispute. Explain also whether, in ...

    other words, within the 12 weeks basic period under The Employment Relations Act 2004 and taking into account other factors such as lock-outs by the employer etc. Any dismissal in the time periods covered by this section is ultimately classified as unfair, with no exceptions to the rule.

  2. employment law

    If a contract is for a fixed term or expressly stated to be terminated only in certain ways, and it is terminated before the term expires or in an improper manner, it will constitute a wrongful dismissal. In Sapp v.

  1. Employment Law - Sex Discrimination

    Sarah had the right to have her complaint taken seriously and not to be victimised as a result of reporting the harassment. Sarah could argue that she was victimised in being told that her services were no longer required if she can prove that this occurred as a result of her complaint of sexual harassment against Ron.


    Hopkins received both praise and criticism regarding her performance skills. At the Interior Department job she had her work praised as "outstanding" by an OGS partner, whereas a consultant stated that she screamed obscenities during a review. During the State Department project, Hopkins received a raise and a promotion.

  1. Selwyn states that it is difficult to categorise working individuals because of the complexity ...

    Employment was simple in the nineteenth century, in most circumstances the employer and employee were referred to as the master and servant. Through this controlling type of relationship, the control test emerged, where the courts would investigate the degree of control the master exercised over the servant.

  2. IR Laws unnecessary or indispensible

    the pastoralists.20 The use of military personnel and police to counter strike action by workers was to be repeated on several occasions throughout the 20th Century.21 For many years, unions and strike action remained workers' only remedy,22 but practically, the consequences were all too often social injustice,23 limited advancement of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work