• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Eu Directives Problem Case. Difficulties arise in situations such as the one faced by Gunilla, where Directives are improperly transposed or ignored by the implementing national authority.

Extracts from this document...


Define directives with the help of case laws? This scenario exposes a discrepancy in the legal system of the European Community in relation to the enforcement of Directives. As a consequence, after a general commentary about directives advice will be given to Gunilla accordingly. Generally speaking, sources of European Community law take precedence over all forms of national law. However, it is not appropriate to apply the same treatment to EC legal instruments en masse. Certain forms of EC legislation differ in terms of their characteristics and the way in which they deliver enforceable law. DEFINATION OF DIRECTIVES: The Treaty of Rome specifies, in Article 249, that Directives are:- "binding, as to the result to be achieved, upon each Member State to which they are addressed, but shall leave to the national authorities the choice of form and methods."1 Moreover, Member States may decide that the existing legal framework they have already ensures that the objectives of the Directive can be obtained by enforcing the already existing legal rules and no further measures are necessary. Despite this flexibility, Member States are obliged to make sure that the objectives of the Directive are attained. For this purpose they are obliged to take the necessary measures for implementation or confirmation as to whether the national law already contains the rules ensuring the attainment of the objectives. ...read more.


Mary's22 the court decided that the definition of 'the State' should be a 'broad one'. Schools and other educational establishments would therefore be part of the 'the State'. An emanation of the State could be defined as a body that had been made responsible, pursuant to a measure adopted by the State, for providing a public service that was under the control of the State and which exercised special powers for the purpose, beyond those which operated between individuals. The powers of the local authority and the Secretary of State for Education meant that education was a public service under the control of the State. Grant maintained Schools would therefore be part of' the state'. Also the case of Marshal v Southampton23 shows that 'the State' is 'the State' regardless of what functions it is performing. Gunilla should also be informed that damages may be awarded as a remedy in situations where a Member State fails to transpose EU law. Where applicable the liability of the Member State is determined by the non-implementation of a Directive and a technical breach of its EU duties. In this case the United Kingdom could be compelled to rectify directly the damage done to Gunilla by this failure. ...read more.


Therefore the EU and other Member States could find the UK is in breach and bring an action against it and as Gunilla's rights had been breached by the State's actions it may be found liable and has to pay reparation to the citizen. It may well be, therefore, that Gunilla has claim for compensation against the UK. Any damages they do obtain must compensate them in full for losses directly incurred because of the breach31. Conclusion:- Direct effect, indirect effect and State liability are crucially important for the protection of individuals' Community law rights in national courts. On the basis of the above considerations, one may identify several important principles that guide the transposition of and the implementation of directives. First, it is the principle of discretion, which allows a member state to choose the form and the method of implementation. Secondly, an important principle is the obligation imposed on member states to implement directives either through adopting national measures or through adapting already existing measures so that the result pursued by the directive in question is achieved. Thirdly, the implementation of directives is subject to the administrative control of the Commission under Article 226, to the indirect control of other member states under the procedure under Article 227 and to the judicial control of the Court of justice pursuant to the two provisions. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree European Union Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree European Union Law essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Council Directive 2004/707 on transporting retired people (fictitious), adopted on 1 November 2000, requires ...

    3 star(s)

    public security is considered with public policy and is based on the individual conduct of the person. Bill's previous conviction was almost nine years ago, his conduct or behaviour since has not been an issue. To help clarify his case the Directive 2004/38/EC states that before a decision can be

  2. The Luxembourg Compromise is, in fact, an agreement in case very important national interests ...

    These views were supported by the Greek invocation of the veto over in 1988, concerning a proposed devaluation of the drachma. This resulted in the proposal being adjourned until the next session of the Council. Whilst the recognised effect of the Luxembourg Compromise is to give the Member State a

  1. In advising Sophie as to what remedies she might have in community law, the ...

    By applying this principle, it was ruled that a directive could be invoked against 'a body, whatever its legal form...' by this it could be said that British Gas would be a 'public' body against which a directive might be enforced, this was then decided by the House of Lords in Foster v British Gas.

  2. EU - problem question

    However, given that the reasoned opinion is not binding as of itself, the next stage will be to bring proceedings before the ECJ. Court proceedings depend on the action taken by the Member State following the earlier proceedings. In the present scenario, the UK have kept the 2007 Act in

  1. The rule against the horizontal direct effect of directives should be abandoned" Discuss.

    States to achieve an end result upon their discretion.14 Grad v Finanzamt Transtein15 was the first case to consider the possibility of directs effects of other forms of community law16. Finally in the case of Van Duyn v Home Office17 was confirmed that directives could also give rise to direct

  2. The Principle of Direct Effect

    the objectives of this Treaty.'7 Given that the implementation period has expired it is possible to argue that the UK is in breach of Article 5 and has failed to take appropriate measures to facilitate the achievement of Community objectives.

  1. EU Law - Albatros Pool problem case. Mark and Sunita must be advised that ...

    Sunita is a member of the Dove pool swimmers club. In July 2005, both Mark and Sunita contract bad cases of asthma. As a consequence, Mark and Sunita have been absent from work due to illness since July 2005. The medical consultant for lung diseases at the local hospital in

  2. What was the relationship between the Factortame case and the Treaty of Rome 1957?

    In terms of the relationship between the substantive issue concerning directly effective rights and the enforcement action brought by the Commission under Article 169, reference is made to the matter of NV Algemene Transporten Expeditie Onderneming van Gend en Loos v Nederlandse Administratis der Belastingen [1963].[82] Herein, the importer argued

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work