• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Exclusion Clauses and the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 case question.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Zero Plc is a large company specialising in the sale and supply of office equipment. Heather is the owner of a small estate agency company called Cellsoon Ltd. In the past, Heather has purchased a number of items of office equipment for her company from Zero Plc. Zero Plc regularly sends copies of its promotional literature to Cellsoon Ltd detailing the range of products which it offers and the different purchase options provided. Zero Plc provides five different purchase options which vary in price depending upon the amount of after-sales service provided and the extent of the liability accepted by the company. The company's literature also states that "Full details of our terms and conditions can be obtained by written request to our Head Office". One day, Heather's office telephone switchboard broke down. Heather urgently needed a replacement and so telephoned Zero Plc. Heather orally agreed to purchase a suitable "low cost" office switchboard machine for Cellsoon Ltd with no after-sales service being provided by Zero Plc. A copy of the printed terms and conditions was subsequently delivered with the machine. Heather noticed a clause in these terms and conditions which stated: "The liability of the company for loss or damage howsoever caused shall be limited to the sum of �1,000. The benefit of this clause shall extend to the company's employees." Three weeks after taking delivery of the machine, it burst into flames, badly burning Heather's arm. ...read more.

Middle

This was too late for it to be incorporated into the contract, as the contract was already concluded when the order was confirmed. * Heather has purchased office equipment from Zero previously; she also receives their advertising literature, which states that Zero offer different levels of service and extent to their liability. The advertising also states that their terms and conditions are available by written request. Heather could have sought clarification of their trading terms during her previous dealings. We know Heather did make previous purchases, but we do not know if it was always the "low Cost" option or how often Heather has dealt with Zero. Assuming their previous transactions were always on the same terms and had been regular, the clause could be incorporated into the contract on the grounds of previous dealings. Stage Two -Construction It is necessary to look at the "words" used in the exclusion clause, and consider; how the courts may construe them in their natural everyday meaning, in comparison to any legal interpretation of the "words"? Generally any wording in a clause, which is ambiguous, would be under the Contra Proferentum rule, meaning it will be construed against the party that included the clause and is seeking to rely on it. The exclusion clause attempts to restrict liability "howsoever caused". This term is wide enough to include both strict liability and negligence. ...read more.

Conclusion

Zero is a large Plc and heather's business, Cellsoon Ltd, is a smaller business. It would be appropriate to expect a large company to have resources available to cover the liability or to insure itself against a liability. Cellsoon Ltd could have insured against damage to their property. Heather purchased a "low Cost" machine for her company which offered no after-sales services, the low cost option could be considered an inducement under Schedule 2 (b). Schedule 2 (c), examines if Heathers could reasonably have known of the terms existence through her previous dealings with Zero, this is similar to the common law test of notice via previous dealings. The Sale of Goods Act 1979, imposes a implied liability, for goods to be of satisfactory quality. Zero cannot limit their liability for goods which are unsafe; the goods heather bought were unsafe and defective, which caused the fire and consequential damage, Rodney was careless in performing his pre-delivery check, therefore the goods were shipped with a safety defect. Zero cannot therefore limit their liability for the consequences. CONCLUSION There is an overlap between the common law approach to exclusion clauses and the statutory provisions of UCTA 1977, but by following the three stage approach it is possible to advise Heather. Liability cannot be limited in respect of her injury; she will have a claim for this. Provided Zero cannot prove that notice by previous dealings was incorporated and reasonable, they will not be able to rely on the exclusion clause in respect of the damage to Heathers premises. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Contract Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Contract Law essays

  1. This executive summary deals with the Marilyn M. case.

    product and 10% for the cash flows without the new product (exhibit(?)). The reason I have chosen 12% as the rate for the Marilyn M. cash flow is for two reasons: first it represents that the Marilyn M. project is riskier.

  2. Critically examine how the law on exclusion clauses in contracts has developed and the ...

    In Houghton v Trafalgar Insurance Co Ltd [1954] 1 QB 247, [1953] 2 All ER 1409 an insurance company refused to pay out on a claim relying on a clause which stated they were not liable if a load was in excess of that which the car was constructed for.

  1. Contract Law Case Analysis. RTS Flexible Systems Ltd v MolkereiAlois Muller GmbH & ...

    Waller LJ found that the factors which influenced Goff J in British Steel10 as indicating no contract apply with "equal force in the factual matrix of this case"11. This devotion to the formal material of precedent displays a formalist approach and more specifically a textual-formalist approach12.

  2. Terms, Conditions, Innominate terms

    Nevertheless, in cases, like Cehave NV V Bremer Handelsgesellschaft mbH (The Hansa Nord),16 where the buyer agreed to purchase an amount of citrus pulp pellets including a term stating that the cargo should be transported in "good condition", the court held that this will not be a condition.

  1. Williams v. Roffey and Foakes v. Beer

    Further support can be derived from the Principles of European Contract Law (Art 2.101(1) ) and the Unidroit Principles for International Commercial Contracts (Art 3.2) which stress seriously intended agreement as the hallmark of contract 'without any further requirement'. The difficulty with replacing consideration with the requirement of intention to

  2. Implied Terms

    in the business/trade, and was even incorporated in the "Contractors' Plant Association". However, there are cases where the customs are not so clear and therefore the courts are reluctant to impose/incorporate these customs in the contract. Terms implied by Court: Terms implied by court may be divided into two categories.

  1. Contract Problem Question - Exclusion of Liability/ Exclusion clauses

    things but fail to fulfill and thereafter avoid the liability with exclusion clause. In such circumstances, Etienne can claim damages that could have been avoided if Ultraclean returned the laundry within 3 days, because this is what they guaranteed. Above all, it may be argued in a similar manner with

  2. Does the UCTA and UCTTR impede on the freedom of contract.

    S11 sets out the reasonable test that must be strictly followed when applying to each case. ?The term shall have been a fair and reasonable one to be included having regard to the circumstances which were, or ought reasonably to have

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work