• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

How far did the Poor Law Amendment Act mark a turning point in attitudes and state provision towards the poor?

Extracts from this document...


How far did the Poor Law Amendment Act mark a turning point in attitudes and state provision towards the poor? The Poor Law Commission of 1832 marked a significant turning point in attitudes and state provision towards the poor. The Commission gave birth to much greater knowledge of the poor, caused British society to replace their paternalistic attitude with utilitarianism, established the Poor Law Amendment Act and changed dominant class running the poverty. Therefore great reforms occurred as a result of the Poor Law Commission however, the many restrictions and flaws of the commission limit the impact it has as a turning point in attitudes and state provision towards the poor. Before the establishment of the Poor Law Commission in 1832, the poorest members of British society were the responsibility of individual parishes and, as the poor were not the responsibility of the government and the upper-class, knowledge of the unreformed poor law was very limited. ...read more.


Intellectuals such as Malthus and Ricardo began to highlight the flaws of the Old system by raising awareness of serious issues which would arise from the Old Poor Law. However, such views had no great impact on the majority until after the findings of the Commission, when people were more prepared to listen to what intellectuals were saying. In particular Jeremy Bentham's doctrine of 'utilitarianism' was at the center of the shift away from paternalism and the nation now believed his theory of 'the greatest happiness for the greatest majority'. Therefore the Commission of 1832 marked a turning point in the attitudes of British society towards the poor as the nation went from their paternalistic approach to adopting a utilitarianistic attitude and the views of anti-Old Poor Law intellectuals would have much more influence. As the position of intellectuals became of great value, so did their solution to reforming the Old Poor Law. Jeremy Bentham's suggestion of establishing 250 industry houses and the abolition of 'outdoor' relief came into practice under a large Government legislation known as the Poor Law Amendment Act which, was a direct result of the Commission. ...read more.


Although the Poor Law Commission was a marked a major turning point in the way society and the state dealt with the poor, its limitations restricts its impact as a turning point. The investigation only covered 10% of Britain's parishes and the methods the assistant commissioners used to gather evidence, were inefficient and inappropriate. Most importantly however, the commissioners had already come to their conclusions before the investigation was conducted and merely intended to use its findings as a tool to reform the poor laws. In conclusion, despite the fact that Poor Law Commission of 1832 had a predetermined aim and does not live up to modern accuracy, it was a ground-breaking survey for its time. The Commission must be recognised as a massive turning point as, not only did it end a system which had been in the works since 1601 but it changed ownership of poverty, gave government control of issues which had previously been out of their hands, ended traditional society and paternalism and also started the welfare state ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree English Legal System section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree English Legal System essays

  1. 'The Land Registration Act 2002 makes a poor attempt at reforming the law of ...

    He had also maintained the plot as a garden planting bulbs and trimming hedges etc. The Council intended to use the plot as part of a road diversion scheme. In 1975 the Council wrote to him asking why he was exercising rights over the land he replied that he intended

  2. Following the McPherson report and subsequent Race Relations Amendment Act 2000 there is no ...

    However, research proved the 1976 Act had short comings. Some claimed it very ineffective and likened it to "machinery not functioning properly91". It was only unlawful to discriminate in employment education and public services, therefore making it perfectly lawful to discriminate outside them92.

  1. Analyse and evaluate how poor people were treated in British society between 1601 and ...

    It was the responsibility of each parish to accommodate its poor with such mobility amongst paupers their parish of responsibility was often difficult to determine. According to Fraser (2003) a national pattern emerged of mass litigation regarding where responsibility lay for mobile paupers.


    He argue that "... the allowance system encouraged laziness, drunkness and early marriages with their attendant large families" ( Jenkins, 2002, p. 136) He also believed that if the Poor Laws were abolished this would lead to higher wages because without the poor-rates employers would be able to pay better wages.

  1. Juries an essential bulwark against oppression or an inefficient anachronism?

    These factors place the jury in a very strong position to take decisions that are "unjustifiable" in accordance with the law. Juries have, therefore, sometimes delivered perverse decisions. In R v CLIVE PONTING [1985], the defendant was a civil servant, was prosecuted after passing confidential information to a journalist which showed that the government of the time had lied.

  2. Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of the Old Poor Law. Do you agree with ...

    almost intolerable burden on locally raised finances, (as did the Napoleon wars of 1792-1815.) The Napoleonic Wars, bad harvest periods and many suggested systems and solutions to the problem of strain on these Old Poor Laws made it clear that change needed to occur.

  1. How successful was the Victorian poor law?

    It was also meant to relieve the taxpayers from the increasing costs of relief. The extent of an able-bodied pauper's need depended on the whether he was prepared to enter the workhouse. However, the conditions of the workhouse were to be less attractive - less eligible than 'the situation of the independent labourer of the working class.'

  2. How important was the Poor Law in Victorian welfare policy? What other forms of ...

    Children were removed from the workhouses and placed in district/workhouse schools, always segregated from the adult paupers. Some children were sent to lodging homes or were sent out to apprentice. In 1840 movement was made to establish a new grant based system to train children from the ages of thirteen, they could chose to follow apprenticeships for some five years,.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work