• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4
  5. 5
    5
  6. 6
    6
  7. 7
    7
  8. 8
    8
  9. 9
    9
  10. 10
    10
  11. 11
    11

In his article, Du Plessis does a comparative review of the law of unjustified enrichment in the South African and Scottish jurisdictions and finds that in both these jurisdictions, unjustified enrichment has the following similarities:

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

THE SINE CAUSA REQUIREMENT REVISITED TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. Introduction 4 2. A short historical overview 5 3. Comparative law 5 4. The way forward: South African law 8 5. Conclusion 11 6. Bibliography 12 INTRODUCTION Du Plessis, in his journal article1 (and in reference to Scottish law) poses the question of what the notion of absence of legal ground is supposed to mean, and what its' meaning entails on a general level. He concludes that "The Scottish and South African legal systems are currently faced with important choices about the direction that the future development of their mainly civilian uncodified laws of unjustified enrichment should take. An important question which arises in this context is what meaning they will give to the core requirement that enrichment has to be 'without legal ground'."2 It is this meaning, and the context or substance given to it that forms the essence of this discussion. HISTORICAL OVERVIEW Obtaining guidance from Roman law sources as to exactly what sine causa entails proves however problematic as unjustified enrichment was not recognized in Roman law as a source of obligations. In Roman Dutch law the position changes when Hugo Grotius in his Inleidinge tot de Hollandsche Rechts-geleerdheid3 formulates an obligation from enrichment as arising "when one person without legal title derives a benefit from another's property."4 His writings also reflect the variety of meanings that the word causa bore in Roman law and his reference to the absence of a lawful cause seems to bear a ...read more.

Middle

THE WAY FORWARD: SOUTH AFRICAN LAW Du Plessis, in comparing the requirements of specific enrichment claims is of opinion that the absence of legal ground is relevant when dealing with both but specifies the following two condictiones:14 1) Condictio data non secuta 2) Condictio sine causa specialis. The absence of a legal ground can bear different meanings depending on which condictio is used, but modern South African law has come to recognize that in all claims based on unjustified enrichment, the general requirement of absence of legal ground need to be met. A narrow and broad meaning can be distinguished when determining the meaning of this requirement. The narrow approach is that of a valid title, such as a contract or court order for example which entitles the recipient to keep the enrichment. Although it can generally be said that the presence of such a title excludes enrichment liability, the absence of such a title does not necessarily give rise to enrichment liability. Additional considerations like absence of a mistake could result in a claim being refused even though a title is absent. Du Plessis is critical of this approach in respect of the additional considerations which he describes as a "Trojan horse" which is effectively the English approach of unjust factors hidden under the guise of the civilian sine causa requirement.The absence of a legal ground is used in a broad sense to describe meeting all the certain specific elemental requirements to establish the general sine causa requirement. ...read more.

Conclusion

She argues that the identification of some factual basis that explains why the transfer is sine causa is essential in many circumstances where enrichment by transfer is at issue (especially in the absence of a failed contract). Scott argues that since the Leistungskondiktion cannot, in such instances, point to a contractual failure out of which a failure of the purpose of the transfer can be inferred, the only way that recovery can be explained is by pointing to the specific reason why recovery should be allowed and she therefore indicates her general support for the current form in which the sine causa element is articulated in South Africa; one in which "the absence of legal ground approach relies on a covert unjust factors approach in order to function".19 CONCLUSION Du Plessis concludes that the meaning that the Scottish and South African legal systems will give to the core requirement that enrichment has to be 'without legal ground' are of importance in determining the direction that the future development of unjustified enrichment. He prefers the option indicated in German law, where the concept of "absence of legal title" is given greater substance simply by the identification of certain claims that govern typical situations of enrichment liability and he argues persuasively for our law to shift away from action-based treatment of the sine causa requirement to an approach similar to the German position. This is the preferred approach that will give the sine causa approach the necessary substance needed in modern enrichment law. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Other Jurisdictions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Other Jurisdictions essays

  1. Anticipatory Bail under CRPC. A critical study of the recent amendments and judicial interpretation ...

    Considering all the material facts before it the court rejected the bail petition.31 The ruling of Gurubaksh Singh Sibbia is that the lower Courts should not keep unnecessary restraints of its own and make this extraordinary power completely impossible. But, rather it says that the all the Courts having jurisdiction

  2. Introduction to American Law. 5 questions on the US legal system.

    Therefore becoming a judge is more to have the ability to attract political support. So it is obvious that a judicial candidate has to be a political person too. Whether have been involved in politics on a regular basis or as a legislators or party chairman.

  1. Hong Kong Constitutional Law - in order to combat cross-border crime in an effective ...

    Kong's sovereignty from China which would infringe the spirit of "One Country" under the "One Country, Two Systems" principle.44 It was opined that "lingyu" is defined as the scope of sovereignty of a state, whereas "fayu" in general is referred to a region where a legal system applies and takes

  2. Constitutional Equality in Singapore. The predominant purpose of unequal treatment under the Constitution ...

    Unequal treatment should exist to the extent necessary to preserve the twin pillars of multiculturalism and meritocracy. I declare that I have abided by the SMU?s Code of Academic Integrity. ________________ [1] Constitution of the Republic of Singapore (1999 Reprint)

  1. Unilateral Divorce in Muslim Law

    If he abandons his wife or puts her away in simple caprice, he draws upon himself the divine anger, for the curse of God, said the Prophet, rests on him who repudiates his wife capriciously." Commentators on the Quran have rightly observed and this tally with the laws now administered

  2. Indian Law. The Legality of In Camera Trials

    to those who either could not gain admission to the trial or were simply inclined to attend. 3. When documents have come into existence for the purposes of the trial ? by way of pleadings, for example ? these should presumptively be available for inspection by any member of the public.

  1. Fetal Abuse and American Law

    endangerment? statute can be lawfully applied to the women who consume illegal drugs during their pregnancies.[68] An appeal to the Alabama Supreme Court is currently pending, according to defense attorney Carmen Howell.[69] b. Civil More frequently than the aforementioned criminal prosecutions, civil suits have been brought against mothers who consumed

  2. Employment Law Case. The article relates the prosecution of Vincenzo Todaro, owner and ...

    Mr Todaro had created a new company called ?VCR Pty Ltd? and he transferred the ownership of Venezia to the new firm .In this way the old company VST wasn't able to pay the $78.000 imposed by the WA Industrial Magistrate?s Court WA.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work