• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

legal framework

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Question 1 There are three broad categories by which sovereignty (control or ownership) over territory may be obtained. These categories include conflict, cession and by occupation. Sovereignty over territory by conflict is when a country may decide to take territory by force, attacking the current inhabitants of the land using armies, military equipment, superior technology, etc. If victorious the attacking country will take control of the territory. As witnessed in the times of the Roman Empire when many battles were fought over territory. Sovereignty over territory can be reached by cession. One country willingly declares territory to another government. A common form of sovereignty by cession is a signed treaty between two countries. An example of control by cession is when the United States of America purchased Alaska from Russia. Sovereignty through occupation was common during early settlements. If no permanent residents or population occupy any given land space, new settlers occupying the area can obtain control. The settlement of Australia is an example of sovereignty through occupation. Although it is later to be found that the native Aboriginals of Australia were already the original inhabitants of the land. We still witness conflict with the developments of new weapons and waging warfare for strategic and monetary gain, cession by countries signing treaties for purchases of land, but occupation is not as common in modern times as most land has been discovered and is inhabited. As Australia was declared to be terra nullius (land belonging to no-one/no man's land) ...read more.

Middle

Conclusion: I believe that the Shire of Green Valley has acted partially ultra vires. Question 2 (b) The Area of Law The area of law relevant to this question is the common law rules of statutory interpretation Principles of Law Sometimes, to the common citizen laws passed by parliament or delegated legislation can be difficult to understand. It is the role of the courts to interpret the words used in the statute. The need for words and phrases used in legislation to be interpreted can arise because it is possible for words to have more than one meaning, or the meaning of words may change over time or simply that the language used is difficult to understand. There exists two main categories of approaches or rules that have been devised to assist the courts when interpreting legislation, these are statutory rules and common law (or judge-made) rules. Common law rules of statutory interpretation consist of three principal approaches: * Literal Approach * Golden Rule * Mischief Rule A judge has the right to choose which of the rules he will apply to any given case however; he can only use one rule. If the judge uses the literal approach, the words of the statute are given their ordinary and natural literal meaning. An example of this is IRC v Hinchy [1960] AC 748 a taxpayer, Hinchy, had filed an incorrect tax return. Section 25 of the Income Tax Act 1952 (UK) provided that any person who lodged an incorrect tax return was liable to pay "treble the tax which he ought to pay under this Act". ...read more.

Conclusion

2007 Topic 4 P.14-15) It may be important to note that the long title of the act may give indication of what parliament was trying to achieve when courts approach an interpretation. Apply the Law to the Facts To determine whether the Public Library Facilities Act 2003 (WA) authorises the Green Valley Council to provide videos and DVDs to residents an appropriate common law rule must be applied. In the case of the judge using the literal approach the Green Valley Council will be found to be unauthorised to provide videos and DVD's to residents as videos and DVD's are not mentioned in the categories to be provided. In the case of the judge using the golden rule the Green Valley Council will be found to be authorised to provide videos and DVD's to residents as the court would modify the words to include videos and DVD's in the categories to be provided. In the case of the judge using the mischief rule the Green Valley Council will be found to be authorised to provide videos and DVD's to residents as the court would find the problem trying to be addressed was the availability of access to free material for the people of Green Valley. Finally, in the case of the judge using the ejusdem generis rule the Green Valley Council will be found to be unauthorised to provide videos and DVD's to residents as videos and DVD's would not fall under the category of books of fiction and nonfiction, periodicals, journals and similar material. Conclusion: I believe that the decision in The Shire of Green Valley case will vary depending upon which rule the court applies. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Commercial Law section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Commercial Law essays

  1. the resurgence of transnational commercial law

    ,perhaps not even tomorrow-but created it must be, and comparative law must create it. As LAMBERT put it ... comparative law must resolve the accidental and divisive differences in the laws of peoples at similar stages of cultural and economic development, and reduce the number of divergences in law, attributable

  2. Company Law

    It is now settled that the company should be treated as a party to the contract contained in its own memorandum and articles as in Hickman's case and that the contract may contain rights which are directly enforceable by one member against another as held in Rayfield v Hands although

  1. The Criminal Justice Act 1993 (CJA) and the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 ...

    In addition, due to the complicated transactions used by dealers, the crime is even-more difficult to detect.[16] There were also criticisms that the criminal sanctions were aimed only at individuals. Therefore, there has been suggestion that the civil regime of insider dealing regulation should be introduced as it would have

  2. Union Carbide & Bhopal Case

    that a disgruntled employee was held responsible for the water entrance * The Indian government argued that faulty design or operation was the cause of the accident Consequence * Over 3800 people were reported dead * 11000 people reported with disabilities (though direct causation between the gas release and disabilities are not entirely proved)

  1. Business Law

    Angelina did not sign the contract, it was Brad who did it, but her name was included in the contract. So she still has contract rights of a third party. According to some past reference cases like Mendelsshn v Normal (1969), B.G Transport V Marston Motor (1972)

  2. Corporation Law - Case Study Stately Funeral Homes Ltd

    Thing then calls another meeting, and with the extra shares, he and Gomez are able to push the sale resolution through. Morticia is furious. As part of the deal with Stately, Simple Serenity also buys all shares in F2P. Gomez and Thing sell their shares in F2P for $90,000 each, making a profit of $1 per share.

  1. Corporate law

    In addition, directors act as either "de factor" or "shadow" needs to carry out their duty.5 The reason why the directors are assigned the duty is that they manage entirely administration of the company and own the finally power to discourage insolvent trading.

  2. Exclusionary principles

    The major advantage of strict literal approach is the short turn around time within which a decision can be obtained by the courts in regard to dispute, as the only evidence considered is the final written contract. The downside of this is that injustice may prevail in few cases due

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work