• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Lord Curzon: the Last of the British Moghuls by Nayana Goradia. Delhi: Oxford University Press 1993.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Sina M. Mossayeb: Book Review Lord Curzon: the Last of the British Moghuls by Nayana Goradia. Delhi: Oxford University Press 1993. Goradia's Lord Curzon: the Last of the British Moghuls is a monograph charged with blemished historiography. Her image of the British monarchy, the formative years of Curzon's life, and finally his role as Viceroy appear in a variety of ways. Cumulatively the book is garbled in a maze of inter-disciplinary surveys. She addresses his childhood and adolescence in psycho-analytical terms and interpretative arguments, while diving into his encounters with homosexual-oriented masters at Eton. Goradia's historical analysis of Lord Curzon as viceroy is hardly detached from any sentiment she may espouse toward his role in India. Her political analysis of Curzon's rule and diplomatic relations does not introduce sufficient proof for any argument. Nevertheless, her narrative style of writing renders the book a fancy read, but fails to hold the integrity of academic literature. Her posed words, filled with value judgments, acquit the book of any unbiased merit. In the first two chapters, Goradia's provision for adequate introductory background of Curzon is surpassed by creating a stereotypical paradigm of British self-exaltation and pomp. ...read more.

Middle

While the gloss of Curzon's association with homosexual-like teachers follows the study of his life, the chapter inherently lacks coherence with the rest of the material presented in the book. Her psycho-analytical survey of his childhood perhaps falls under creative license, but her presentation of Curzon's "sexual" relationship seems altogether out-of-place. Although she manages to include the latter chapter into a Book about Curzon's duration in India, Goradia finally enters the Indian era of Curzon's life, and dives into the various aspects of his involvement as Viceroy. Throughout the book, the author pays tribute to praiseworthy attributes manifested by Curzon in his life. In fact, she often overlooks his eccentric personality and redirects major flaws to external factors such as his parents, his wife, or his admiring teachers. The Viceroy and his wife were welcomed in a lavish British ceremonial reception upon arriving in India. According to Goradia, "Being treated like a ruling sovereign made Curzon almost believe he was one."4 Curzon's self-image lent itself to a superiority complex. Although approaching various princes of India will a message of equality, his tone and speech were often condesending. ...read more.

Conclusion

Once again, she redirects blame to an external agent. She meagerly deals with Curzon's double-standard of praising Muslim unity after the partition and his disregard for the minority prior to the division. In retrospect, although Goradia's Lord Curzon: the Last of the British Moghuls is a fascinating read in terms of a historical novel, it lacks any real coherence and cohesiveness. The monograph of this British noble is spotted with multiple themes, all of which seem incomplete or slanted. Overall she introduces the reader to a personal Curzon, and only touches upon some of the real controversial issues dealing with this politicized figure-considerably the downfall of the British Mughuls. Paradoxically his aim was to create an unprecedented British rule over India, but was left to fulfill his own forgotten words: I sometimes wonder whether 100 years hence we shall still be ruling India. There is slowly growing up a sort of a national feeling. As such it can never be wholly reconciled to an alien government... I believe a succession of two weak and rash viceroys could bring the whole machine toppling down.7 1 Goradia, p. 21 2 Ibid., p. 34 3 Ibid., p 59-60 4 Ibid., p.149 5 Ibid., p.157 6 Ibid., p.210 7 Ibid., p. 218 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Other Jurisdictions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Other Jurisdictions essays

  1. State of tort law in India.

    In Constantine v. Imperial London Hotels Ltd (1944), the famous West Indian cricketer was refused admittance to the defendant's hotel without reasonable cause, but suffered no special damage. Ordinarily damages are equivalent to the harm suffered by the plaintiff. When there has been infringement of the plaintiff's legal right but

  2. International Human Rights Laws - North Korea.

    This team is responsible for collecting the dung from the prison toilet tanks and dumping it into a large dung pool everyday for supply to the farming teams. Sun-ok Lee explains: "Two women wade knee-deep at the bottom of the toilet [and fill a 20-liter bucket] with dung using their bare hands.

  1. Land law. The purpose of this paper is to present an analytical and investigative ...

    One case study regarding issues revolving around contract law is the case between Sondre Locke v Warner Brothers in which Locke sued Warner Brothers for breach of contract and failure to act in good faith. (ii) XYZ Nation Media Group v The State, where five orphans claimed XYZ got them

  2. HIV/AIDS, Women's Human Rights and the Declaration of Commitment on HIV/AIDS: The principal obstacles ...

    social lenses, which means that it is intensified by patriarchal social attitudes that discourage open discussion on the issue. According to the one (and the only) NGO "Women in the Future" running a hotline to collect data about the victims of trafficking, total number of the victims reach 300, 2/3 of whom are women (USAID, 2003).

  1. 'Cyber space' is completely independent from 'Real space'.

    This tripartite immunity came to be a kind of Internet Holy trinity, faith in which was a condition of acceptance into the community. A quick comment on each of the under described statement will indicate why cyberspace is developing in the contrary direction.

  2. Outline the laws and government policies that have shaped and continue to affect Indigenous ...

    O'Shane (2002) observes that '[m]ost indigenous women have not enjoyed the protection of the curial system in identifying their civil, political and human rights as a subject within a nation, or their rights as members of the Australian community'12. The criminal justice system does not take a culturally appropriate, sensitive

  1. There are four elements to a crime, a law, an offender, a target or ...

    Newman (1972) suggests that designing built environments in such a way as to increase defensible space can reduce crime. 6 Defensible Space are zones which, to provide maximum control, are divided into smaller, clearly defined areas. All areas are designated as either public, semi-private or private.

  2. Free essay

    Sir Goronwy Edwards had said that two things in special had made the Welsh ...

    to social changes and to legal ideas."31 The ability for the Welsh jurists to update the law shows the capability and sophistication of the learned Welsh people. Edwards comments on how the jurists advanced the law from the time of Hywel: "They built on foundations which he had laid, and

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work