• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Narni Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Limited. This paper examines the agreement by conduct to extend overdraft limit and whether an implied term not to terminate the account without notice exists.

Extracts from this document...


TABLE OF CONTENT Page Preface 2 Question 1 : Reason behind the litigation 2 Question 2: breach of the implied term by the National Australia Bank 3 Question 3: Raise of an estoppel claim 5 Conclusion 6 REFERENCES 7 Narni Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Limited Preface: This paper examines the agreement by conduct to extend overdraft limit and whether an implied term not to terminate the account without notice exists. The relevant case is Narni Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Limited [1998] VSC 146. The following sections are going to address the three matters based on the reading of the case. 1. Question 1: Reason behind the litigation Before answering this question, it is essential to recall the case that leads to the litigation by Narni Pty Ltd. The appellant's business was a nursing home set up in 1987 and all of the business premises were financed by borrowings from direct loans or indirect responsibilities to its shareholders. The pricipal shareholders and directors were registered nurses, Narni McCarthy and her sister Norma Caringal. Due to the cash flow problems, Mrs McCarthy frequently contacted with Clem Kealy, the manager of the Elwood branch of the Bank for an overdraft. ...read more.


However, the account remained substantially over the approved limit until the May cycle commenced and at the end of the May cycle, the account was $100,000 over this limit. It is noticed that there was no evidence of any specific warning of dishonour after that recorded by the manager on 31 March. Therefore, it was concluded that the Bank continued to permit the company to overdraw the cheques till the date of termination without any warning in writing. The practice of the Bank in 1989 shows that the silence by the Bank meant the cheques were being honoured and this action would be reflected in the periodic bank statements by debiting the overdraft service fees and applicable interests where the account was overdrawn. Moreover, in the document signed by the director of Narni on 6 November 1987 when the account was opened with the Bank, there was the term of the contract that in case of termination, the Bank would give immediate notice in writing. As a matter of law, it was an implied term of the arrangement that the Bank could not terminate or vary it without giving the customer reasonable notice so as to allow time for it to arrange its affairs to comply. ...read more.


The argument used by Narni was that because of the Bak's conduct, Narni was misled that they were able to overdraw cheques in excess of the limit. However, at the time when the Bank ceased to do business with the company, Narni was in surprise as they were not informed clearly about the decision of account termination. The conclusion by the court was that, these states of affairs were clear to both parties and the breach of the arrangement between the Bank and its customer estopps the Bank from denying the cheques repayment on the ground that the balance of the account exceeded the approved overdraft limit of $65,000. Conclusion It was apparent that the National Australia Bank breached the implied term of the arrangement between it and Narni Pty Ltd by dishonouring a numbers of cheques without having given reasonable notice. The conduct led to the failure of Narni's business and the business was forced to be liquidated by the debenture holder. The case was brought by Narni for seeking adequate compensation from the defendant bank. However, it was held by the court that Narni, upon the receipt of the proceeds if the sale of the business, has suffered no further compensable loss, and the action by Narni was in truth seeking double compensation which was unsuccessful thereafter. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Other Jurisdictions section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Other Jurisdictions essays


    Allsop J was concerned by the diplomatic implications of the proceedings regarding the rights Australia claimed off the AAT and therefore asked the Commonwealth Attorney-General to provide submissions on these issues as amicus curiae.42 In response, the Attorney-General highlighted both the international law issues and the consequent political controversy in

  2. This essay focuses on the issues surrounding environmental sustainability and the impact it has ...

    corporation contravenes a civil penalty provision under the Act.36 This is pursuant to whether the CEO knew, or was reckless or negligent as to whether the contravention would occur, and that officer, being in the position to do so, failed to take all reasonable steps to prevent the contravention.37 C

  1. Scandalous trademarks. In Australia there has been an increase in the number of ...

    It was further stated in that case that the examiner or delegate when deciding whether to reject or approve the application; must not remain isolated from the day to day world, frozen in an outmoded set of moral principles, he must equally not presume to set the standard.

  2. Unilateral Divorce in Muslim Law

    The justification for this rule in Hanafi law is that this law looks to the act rather that the intent. Among the Hanafis, the talaq may be oral or in writing[53], so long as the intention is clear, no specific form is necessary.

  1. Australian Corporation Law Case.It is necessary to determine that whether Finance Pty Ltd is ...

    the real purpose of the controller, to avoid an existing legal obligation, as a vehicle for fraud, to assist in a director?s breach of fiduciary duties, to trade with the enemy, to avoid tax,[4] as a mere puppet of its controller and to act as an agent or partner in a corporate group.

  2. Indian Law. The Legality of In Camera Trials

    Does it truly serve its purpose? Take the case of Shiney Ahuja rape case, a 20 year-old maid who worked in Shiney Ahuja?s house accused him of raped her at his Andheri West home June 14, 2009. He was arrested and spent 110 days in police and judicial custody in

  1. Fetal Abuse and American Law

    Once a duty is realized, an additional question remains to be addressed. First, what if the pregnancy was unplanned and is not recognized until after fetal harm has occurred? No duty can be imposed where a reasonable person of like circumstances would not recognize that duty to have existed, so

  2. Employment Case. The main issue raised by this case is whether it is legitimate ...

    The distinction between the two is, in law, fundamental and cannot here be bridged. ________________ This distinction suggests that not only the entire group is treated as an entity from outsiders? perspective, but also every member inside the group should be treated separately.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work