• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The core function of the police should be to maintain order.' Discuss with particular reference to Wilson and Kelling's 'broken windows' thesis. This essay will provide an explanation of the broken windows thesis and link this to the role

Extracts from this document...


'The core function of the police should be to maintain order.' Discuss with particular reference to Wilson and Kelling's 'broken windows' thesis. This essay will provide an explanation of the broken windows thesis and link this to the role of the police in maintaining order. It will highlight that the thesis only recognises street crime as a source of criminal activity and how disorder and order are defined in this context. The issue of how maintaining order produces tension with regard to human rights will be examined and in particular who is often labelled as disorderly and therefore criminal. The issue of reducing crime will also be investigated and the reason why reducing crime is viewed as so important in the first place. Finally the positive effects of the thesis will be examined and it will look at the alternatives to the police maintaining order. When Robert Peel founded the metropolitan police in the early 19th century, the primary function was crime prevention and maintaining order through street patrols. This was to protect the public from the 'menace of mob disorder' (Reith 1938) as Robert Peel did not want to leave the streets 'in the nightly possession of drunken women and vagabonds'. ...read more.


An article in the Daily Star newspaper explains how a man was minding his own business and these 'hoody thugs' attacked him without provocation (Malley 2005), while the daily mirror shares the opinion of the Ex-Metropolitan Police chief who believes 'hoodies' should receive longer prison sentences (McGurran 2005). There is an assumption that disorderly behaviour and therefore criminal elements are easily recognisable and by removing these elements the problem will be eliminated. Kelling and Wilson even recognize the failures in establishing who is criminal. They point out that when people on a housing estate were asked where the dangerous places were they identified where young ones gather and play music, even though this was not an area of crime. This puts the thesis on shaky ground, they claim that if you sort out the disorderly elements this will stop it escalating into further criminal action. However if the people pinpointed as disorderly are not committing or causing criminal acts how does stopping and harassing them prevent further criminal acts, it could surely produce the opposite effect in that they feel oppressed. Instead it is labelling people as disorderly and therefore criminal for what they look like and what they wear. This also illustrates that the thesis is one sided as it looks at the feelings and thoughts of the 'victims' but fails to take account of the feelings of those who are actually labelled as criminal. ...read more.


It also points out that those labelled as 'criminal' are not necessarily criminals. They are more likely to be those who appear different and those highlighted by the media. There also appears to be a never ending cycle of those labelled as criminals and there is a failure to take note of any social influences. In addition the prejudice that results from labelling can have devastating consequences. All of these reasons coupled with the point that the police are unlikely to catch a person in the act means that a police presence in the form of foot patrol is unlikely to have an effect on street crime rates. However it does seem to have a positive effect on those in the community fearful of crime. Although due to police accountability and political pressures this is not seen as important or cost effective. In conclusion, I don't think that the core function of the police should be to maintain order as it has little effect on crime rates and they tend to target those who 'looks' like criminals, also by using foot patrols and concentrating on street crime means other areas of crime would to be overlooked. However I do think that the police role in maintaining community relationships does have merit, as they could be used in an advisory capacity and this way police could continue monitoring crime and fear levels within the community. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree English Legal System section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree English Legal System essays

  1. Critically analyse Police powers on Stop and Search, Arrest and Detention.

    Where ethnic minorities were charged the cases against them were more likely to have been dropped by the Crown Prosecution Service suggesting that the police are too quick to take action against ethnic minority groups. However the research was base on studies which took place between 1994 and 1995 and

  2. Judicial accountability

    conceived to be of divine and, therefore no human being not even the king or monarch could claim to be above the law. In the Vedic days of Hindu India, the monarch alone was the administrator and source of all law.

  1. Law and moral.

    enforcement of morality was a major issue in the "Spanner" case, in which six middle-aged men were prosecuted for a variety of offences arising out of their sado-masochistic practices. All those involved were adults and had fully and freely consented to the acts done to them, and none sustained injuries sufficiently serious to need medical treatment.

  2. Following the McPherson report and subsequent Race Relations Amendment Act 2000 there is no ...

    Sandra Fredman indicates in her journal that we have to give the RRAA 2000 and further legislative initiatives being brought forward by the EU time to prove themselves, which I deem to be correct. John Lea talks about a complete reorganisation of the Metropolitan Police Service and the fact that

  1. Describe the Role of a Modern Police Service

    The traffic units are comparatively the newest of all the units with the police services yet they find themselves in a more demanding position now the use of motor vehicles is an integral part of modern society. The shift in roles and responsibilities, and the introduction of new legislation has

  2. Evaluate the thesis (as per Wade) that the Factortame case represents a technical legal ...

    Clearly the European Communities Act has placed limitations on the legislative supremacy of Parliament, but the extent to which this is a 'revolution' is questionable. Based on the argument of Wade and the Diceyan principle, Parliament would have in fact lost its sovereignty when it legislated regarding Independence acts, as

  1. In order to discuss Alan's criminal liability, it is necessary to look at the ...

    A simple decision to keep property, unaccompanied by any physical act could amount to an appropriation. 'An act done with the authority of the company cannot in general amount to an appropriation' are no longer good law11. Following Gomez 1993, an appropriation can occur even though the owner appears to imply or express consent to the taking12.

  2. Have the police become less accountable in recent years? How can police accountability be ...

    motorized patrol units, with the use of electronic radios, hoping to increase the response to emergency calls and improve public relations with the community. However this movement was counterproductive and failed to bring the police closer to the community. People felt intimidated by their heavy patrolling, and community problems alongside

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work