There are five main legal systems in the world

Authors Avatar

Compare the impact of two legal systems on business practices in terms of law making and dispute resolution.

There are five main legal systems in the world. They are: Civil law legal system, Common law legal system, Customary law system, Muslim law legal system and Mixed systems. Civil law legal system and common law legal system are the most important legal systems in the world, which effect on the all legal systems in the world for a very long time and have been adopt by the most countries. Civil law distinguished form common law is that Civil law is based on written legal codes, a characteristic of the Roman legal system, in which disputes were settled by reference to a written legal code arrived at through legislation, edicts, and the like. However, common law is based on the precedents created by judicial decision over time.

 “Civil law legal system is based on Roman law, especially the corpus Juris Civilis of emperor Justinian, as late developed through the Middle Ages by medieval legal scholars. The most authoritative modern source is Karl Eduard Zacharie.”[1] Civil law legal system is commonly used in continental Europe, which is also used in Quebec (Canada), Louisiana (USA), Japan, China, Latin America, and most former colonies of continental European countries. One of the remarkable traits in civil law legal system is codified law, in order to follow the unified legal system

and to use statute law. Judge in civil law countries pursue the maximum precision of the conclusions to close the basis principles. They make decisions based on the code or a relevant statute, and the judgments are also based upon the same provision. Although administration, legislation and jurisdiction have their individual system, the power and degree of jurisdiction is lower than others in civil law countries. Moreover, the court in civil law countries plays the role of loyal interpreter, which can not make statute laws by cases. Meanwhile, generally the prejudication of case by one court can’t be the sanction to other courts.

 

By contrast, common law legal system is accepted by many countries, which has a history as British territories or colonies, such as England, American, Australia and so on. Common law was developed by custom and pre-existing case law, which include statute law and judge-made law or case law. The statutes or legal principle are made based on the real case in common law legal system. For example, the definition of negligence in England came from the case Per Alderson B., Blyth v Birmingham Waterworks Co.(1856)[2]. By this reason, in common law legal system, judge can make decisions based on the previous case, which under the same or similar situation or under the similar principle. Normally the previous case can affect the result in lawsuit. Furthermore, common law legal system trends to protect human right and personal liberty, which adopt the precise criterion against government at the same time. In addition, the inquisitorial system in common law legal system is adversarial system, which means both plaintiff and defendant should offer evidence and confession to prove their points. At the same time judge as the third-parties to make decision. The legislature in common law legal system are parliament, council, executive, national assembly and some communities. For example, in the united kingdom, the legislation come from the following section:

Join now!

1. acts of the united kingdom parliament;

2. statutory instruments such as orders and regulations, which are made by a Minister or by Queen in Council.

3. Acts of devolved Scottish Parliament and statutory instruments are made by the Scottish Executive.

4. Statutory instruments made by the National assembly for Wales; 5.Decusuibsm directives and regulations of the European Communities.

“Legislation is the cornerstone of the modern legal system.”[3] In civil law countries, legislation is seen as the primary source of law. Because of the

traditional request of civil law are precision and unified, the ...

This is a preview of the whole essay