Page
  1. 1
    1
  2. 2
    2
  3. 3
    3
  4. 4
    4

What criticisms might be made of the Roman law of theft?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

-Roman Law Week 4- What criticisms might be made of the Roman law of theft. Theft (furtum) is one of four delicts considered by Justinian, along with robbery (rapina), damage (damnum iniuria datum) and outrage (iniuria); according to Thomas1, a delict consisted in wrongful conduct causing harm, for which the aggrieved party recovered damages. In terms of theft, Gaius fails to provide us with a definition but Justinian describes furtum as "a fraudulent handling [contrectatio] of a thing, of its use or the possession of it, and this is forbidden by natural law.2" It must be noted that Justinian fails to refer to the fact that furtum only applies to res mobiles that are in commercio. In this essay, I will criticize the Roman law of theft in terms of the difference between the legal definition of furtum and the popular conception, in terms of furtum manifestum and non manifestum and in terms of the practical application of the penal remedies against an insolvent thief. I will also criticise the condictio furtiva, the lack of actio furti in cases of furtum between slaves and families, and the fact that rapina is viewed by the Institutes as lying outside of the law of furtum. ...read more.

Middle

However, the penalty for furtum non manifestum remained the same as that which was set out in the Twelve Tables which was for double the value. However, as is stated by Buckland, this meant that for the more serious act of furtum manifestum the civil penalty was only an actium in factum whereas for the lesser act of furtum non manifestum the penalty was an actio in ius19. Thus there would appear to be a contradiction in the seriousness of the act and the seriousness of the penalty. One criticism of the law of theft voiced by Nicholas, is that a "thief in any society will not usually be solvent, or at least not provably solvent20", and the multiple penalties, such as the actio furti and condictio furtiva, in Roman Law were nothing more therefore than illusory because the thief would be unable to pay due to his insolvency. What's more, the penal nature of the remedies meant that the thief would have to pay twofold, threefold, fourfold etc. the value of the stolen res. Another criticism of the law of theft is with regards to the condictio furtiva, - a quasi-contractual reipersecutory action in personam against a thief or his heirs- and the specific formula that it utilises. ...read more.

Conclusion

Finally, I have criticised the view that rapina is outside of the law of theft and the lack of advantage to using the actio vi bonorum. 1 Thomas, Textbook on Roman Law, page 249 2 J.4.1.1 3 Ibetson in Ibetson and Lewis, page 54 4 Nicholas, An introduction to Roman Law, page 212 5 Ibetson in Ibetson and Lewis, page 58 6 Ibid. 7 Thomas, Textbook of Roman Law, page 356 8 Ibetson in Ibetson and Lewis, page 62 9 Ulpian D.47.2.21 10 G. 3.184 11 Ibid. 12 Ibid. 13 Buckland textbook, page 584 14 J.4.1.3 15 Nicholas, An Introduction to Roman Law, page 211 16 Ibid. 17 G.3.184 18 Ibid. 19 Buckland Textbook 20 Nicholas, An Introduction to Roman Law, page 211 21 Thomas, Textbook on Roman Law, page 358 22 Buckland Textbook, page 584 23 G.4.4 24 Ibid. 25 Thomas, Textbook of Roman Law, page 353 26 J.4.1.12 27 Thomas, Textbook of Roman Law, page 353 28 G.3.186 29 Thomas, Textbook on Roman Law, page 354 30 J.4.1.4 31 Nicholas, Introduction Roman Law, page 215 32 Thomas, Textbook on Roman Law, page 360 33 Zuleta, page 207 34 Thomas, Textbook on Roman Law, page 360 35 Ibid. 36 Nicholas, Introduction Roman Law ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Miscellaneous section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Miscellaneous essays

  1. SCHOOL BULLYING & RESTORATIVE JUSTICE: THE LEGAL ISSUES FOR GOVERNMENT SCHOOLS

    59 Lionel Wilson and Max Fulton, 'Risk management: how doctors, hospitals and MDOs can limit the costs of malpractice litigation' (2000) 172 Medical Journal of Australia 77, 77-80, Wilsher v Essex Area Health Authority [1987] 1 QB 730. 60 Butler, above n 7, 246-253.

  2. Restorative Justice and Serious Crime

    1 Mahatma Ghandi in John Broomfield, Other Ways of Knowing (1997) 191. 2 Gerry Johnstone, Restorative Justice: Ideas, Values, Debates (2005) 7-8, 29-32, Mark Griffiths, Working with Serious Violent Crime Using Restorative Justice Conferencing (2004) Jesuit Social Services New Zealand Conference Paper, <http://old.jss.org.au/programmes/documents/FinalversionNewZealandConferencePaper2004.pdf> at 2 April 2009, 3, Tanya Rugge

  1. critically the impact of the SOA 2003 upon the offence of rape, with particular ...

    5 Se]fe, David and Burke, Vincent (200]) Perspectives on Sex, Crime and society, 2nd Edition, Cavendish Publishing, p6. 6 Rook, Peter and Ward, Robert (2004) Sexual Offences, Law and Practice, 3rd Edition, Sweet and Maxwell, p2. 7 [1976] AC 182. 8 Heilbron Committee, Report of the Advisory Group on the Law of Rape, cmnd 6352, 1975 HMSO VIII summary of recommendations, Para I, p36.

  2. law of property

    Thus, it makes it clear that the property is a gift to his wife, and the testator expects the wife to act as family held by taking. In such case precautionary words are expressing a desire. By contrast, in Comisky v.

  1. Company Law and Insolvency

    for managers and directors on the model of the French société en commandite8. However such liability for directors was abolished under Companies Act 2006. By early twentieth century, the shareholder power has manifested itself in several dramatic instances, both in the US and the UK.

  2. Historical Background of the Concept of Rule of Law

    asserted that it is not a true Administrative Law because the supremacy of ordinary Courts prevails.16 2 According to Dicey, where there is discretion there is room for arbitrariness. Thus he failed to distinguish between discretionary power and arbitrary power.

  1. As opposed to a test which focuses on whether a publication is likely to ...

    However the court held the material is obscene under section 1(1) as the bookshop is open to the general public. Radical feminists, such as Mackinnon20 regard the Obscene Publication Act 1959 ineffective for a number of reasons. They proclaim that the law only protects the consumer and not the women participating in the pornographic material.

  2. If the public interest immunity was originally confined to such high affairs of state, ...

    Non-disclosure has been ordered on the grounds that the document falls into a particular class which should not be revealed. The report of the inquiry into the Export of Defence Equipment and Dual-Use Goods to Iraq and Related Prosecutions (the Scott inquiry)

  • Over 180,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.