• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why are opportunity reduction-based approaches to crime prevention attractive to policy-makers and what are the main problems associated with their theoretical bases and practical implication?

Extracts from this document...


Why are opportunity reduction-based approaches to crime prevention attractive to policy-makers and what are the main problems associated with their theoretical bases and practical implication? First this essay will explain what is meant by opportunity reduction based approaches (ORBA). It will give reasons why these approaches are attractive to policy makers and link this to a broader political context. The theoretical base will be examined in relation to social construction and also pointing out what crimes this approach doesn't address. The practical implication of ORBA are analysed such as the problem of displacement and the inequality this highlights. Then finally the uses, abuses and human rights issues regarding certain aspects of the technology associated with this method of crime prevention. ORBA are part of situational crime prevention which manipulates the environment as a method of trying to prevent crime. Situational research is divided into two measures, (1) increasing the chances of being caught and (2) reducing physical opportunities for crime (Clarke 1980). It is the latter that this essay is primarily concerned with, although the two measures do overlap. For example, installing closed-circuit television (CCTV) will reduce the opportunity for crime and increased the likely hood of being caught. Cohen and Felson (1979) ...read more.


He suggests the reason for this is because it is easier to provide a leaflet with the advice to avoid certain areas, or check the back seats of cars than it is of advising women about 'trustworthy men. Bright (1991) comments that 'while situational crime prevention, theoretically, can reduce the estimated 70% of recorded crime thought to be opportunistic, it is unable to prevent many violent crimes such as some categories of assault, domestic violence, child abuse and racially motivated crime' (quoted in Walklate p316). Of course this also links back to again to why ORBA are attractive to policy makers as it is easier to provide legislation for public areas and also public crime is visible and it makes more political sense to tackle crime which the public can see. This means that opportunity reduction based approaches are theoretically and practically limited to attempting to prevent crime in the public domain. In the practical application of ORBA's there is the issue of displacement to consider. Displacement is based on the concern that if a criminal is prevented from committing a criminal offence in one place, he simply moves on to another. In other words there is a concern that the problem hasn't really gone away. ...read more.


To summarise, this essay explained ORBA as a method of crime prevention which is attractive to policy makers because it was simple and could be targeted at certain public area's, it also put the responsibility of crime prevention onto government agencies but mostly on to the victims who invited criminals by inadequate security. Currie (1991) argues that the market society actually perpetuates crime and Young points to capitalism as the expression of upper class fear. ORBA focus of crime is on the public area, this mean it misses crime in the private sphere. The practical application of ORBA brings the unfinished, and possibly unanswerable, issue of displacement and the inequality that this highlights. Finally the issue of advancing technology brings with it the issues of human rights and abuses for which the debates can't keep up, despite this there are positives to these technologies. In conclusion, I think ORBA are a good idea primarily because they do give people a sense of security which allows people to go about their daily lives in the public domain. Although until these defenses are available to everyone and the debate surrounding them has caught up to the technologies, then they remain the property of those can afford them and are also open to abuse. There is also the worry that crime measures will go too far and then we find ourselves in a Big Brother house scenario with every move we make scrutinized. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree English Legal System section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree English Legal System essays

  1. Insanity, diminished responsibility and automatism.

    Surely these characteristics come better under the heading of an abnormality of the mind45 than provocation, it is indeed an arguable point. The same point can be argued for Smith, would diminished responsibility not be a more suitable alternative defence for the mental impairment that led to his susceptibility to frequent loss of self-control, rather than provocation?

  2. The Irish Government is run by men for men. The victim of Domestic violence ...

    violence in the home was dependent on one of its parents to apply for a barring order (van Dokkum, 2004). Section 8 covers the area of the protection of household chattels. This section prohibits a spouse from disposing of household property during domestic violence proceedings until a determination by the court (Law Society of Ireland, 2001).

  1. Lon Fuller - professor of Jurisprudence at Harvard.

    same duty you owe me today, I may owe you tomorrow in other words, the relationship of duty must in theory and in practice be reversible." [9] Based upon voluntary trade, a common unit of comparison (money), and the changing roles of individuals (as buyers and sellers), the market order

  2. What is the nature versus nurture debate? How is this related to causal explanations ...

    In certain cases this could mean that a person whose appearance matches the stereotype of a criminal may be innocently convicted and therefore labelled a criminal (Bull, R. and McAlpine, S. 1998). In the 1960's British criminologists believed that they had made an important breakthrough in the search for a scientific explanation for criminal behaviour.

  1. Intellectual Property –Copyright.

    c) The release of the home video on Daily Pail's website will probably cause damage to Harry's and Robert's reputation. Robert's brother has obviously been paid by Daily Pail of Angela for the video he almost certainly took without Harry's or Robert's permission.

  2. To what extent can it be argued that 'youth crime' is a social construction?

    The concept of childhood, as we understand it today did not emerge until the late nineteenth century (Valentine, Skelton and Chambers, 1999); similarly 'adolescence' is a historically invented category (3). The emergence of the concept of adolescence, which also began in the nineteenth century, could be attributed to the ability

  1. Historically, property has always been divided into two categories - real property and personal ...

    The new legislations aim was to reduce the number of legal estates in land and abandon outdated rules. An estate in land is the right of any landowner to enjoy the land for a particular period of time. Before the Law of Property Act 1925 there were a number of legal estates in land.

  2. Critical analysis of three main defences of voluntary manslaughter for women defendants who kill ...

    a characteristic of being an impotent man have the effect of not classing a man to be reasonable, as the hypothetical reasonable man would not be an impotent man. Bedder v DPP58 demonstrates this point. The question of reasonableness is left to the jury.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work