• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

A Rose Is But A Rose: Parker vs. H.D.

Extracts from this document...


Compare & Contrast English 101 A Rose Is But A Rose: Parker vs. H.D Poetry can transcend time, space and definition, but throughout history one of nature's marvels has been made an important part of many authors' poetic focal points. Roses have traditionally been represented as symbols of love, eternity and life. Yet, despite this fact some authors use the rose to associate different connotations. Hilda Doolittle's, "Sea Rose" and Dorothy Parker's "One Perfect Rose" both concentrate on the rose to emphasize the issue of romanticism through which the rose is marked as a misinterpreted artificial symbol. Hilda Doolittle, known as H.D, was considered as one of the ground breaking founders of the imagist movement. Her style and use of the rose helped convey her ability to attach additional allegorical meaning and interpretation to her poetry. While Parker, an American critic and satirical poet, is remembered as much for her flashy verbal exchanges and malicious wit, her ability to disenchant stories and sketches to reveal her underlying pessimism. The contrasting nature of both poems shows two unique ways to convey the image of a rose. Dorothy Parker's ability to use tone, specific diction and subtle poetic devices transmits a much clearer image than H.D's overuse of adjectives and lack of conceptualization. The use of tone can be considered to be crucial when depicting concrete and vivid imagery. ...read more.


This three quatrain poem in its first stanza has a very euphonious tone: "A single flow'r he sent me, since we met. All tenderly his messenger he chose; Deep-hearted, pure, with scented dew still wet-- One perfect rose" Diction is a pertinent part of tone and the specific word choice of Parker indicates that her initial reaction that she wanted to evoke from her reader was a poem that came across with a soft, euphonious tone that adhered to love via the rose in its most traditional meaning. The tone continues through the second stanza with smooth vowel sounds, while the first stanza emphasized vowel sounds like "eee" the second stanza uses "ooo" sound to transition into a third stanza that is not completely euphonious but disrupted with specific diction like the word "limousine" and devices like enjambment in line nine and ten. "Why is it no one ever sent me yet On perfect limousine, do you suppose?" The use of assonance allows the poem to flow smoothly and until the third stanza where the tone changes as the Parker uses sarcasm and pessimism to mock the rose as a symbol of love. Parker's ability to use multiple dimensions to change tone makes her writing style much more effective than simple use of adjectives that H.D uses in the "Sea Rose." ...read more.


This is especially noticeable in the repeated motifs of "harsh rose, wet rose and spice-rose." H.D. symbolically evokes the dichotomy of a disparate femininity, for example 'wild as opposed to sweet, unlovely as opposed to lovely.' The "Sea Rose" discards conventional femininity to privilege explosive sexuality. To compare and contrast these poets who both use the symbol of the rose is to compare oranges to apples. While H.D uses adjective-fashioned diction to create an image of a rose beaten by the elements at the sea, Dorothy Parker narrated a story throughout her work. Both use imagery to develop justification for why a rose is not just a rose. But Dorothy Parker ability to use simple poetic devices, like end rhyme, enjambment and assonance makes her imagery much easier to visualize for readers. Parker's narrative style is conducive for a reader to easily see rose as a central focal point and visual an object with an insightful story or situation. In contrast, listing descriptive adjectives as H.D did in the "Sea Rose" does not necessarily portray rose as anything but a rose. While both use imagery to develop justification for why a rose is not just a rose, the complexity of human emotion can only be portrayed through narration not description. H.D's inability to tell a story caused the poem to lack meaning in terms of meaning with an image. On the other hand Parker's poem "One Perfect Rose" allows the reader to see that all roses are not traditionally symbolic of love, life and eternity. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Wordsworth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Wordsworth essays

  1. NATURE, natural, and the group of words derived from them, or allied to them ...

    by the same laws of vegetation by which the wild rose and the mountain strawberry bring forth their flowers and fruit. A house stands and holds together by the natural properties, the weight and cohesion of the materials which compose it: a steam engine works by the natural expansive force

  2. "Prometheus Unbound" and Shelley's Prefatory Defense Against Critics

    In this work, he states that: There must be a resemblance...between all the writers of any particular age. They cannot escape from subjection to a common influence which arises out of an infinite combination of circumstances belonging to the time in which they live; though each is in a degree

  1. Nature vs. Science in Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Birthmark"

    As she told Aylmer, the birthmark often increased a man's admiration for her (397). However, after years of marriage to Aylmer, she too learned to hate the wretched mark as much as he did. Georgiana noticed Aylmer's reaction of disgust every time he laid eyes upon her cheek and she "soon learned to shudder at his gaze" (398).

  2. Explore the Relationship Between Literature and Politics In the Work of Romantic Authors.

    Shelley's political views are strongly expressed in a poem that he wrote after he heard news of an event on the outskirts of Manchester. Shelley's reaction to the Peterloo Massacre of 1819, during which at least 11 people were killed and 421 were injured when mounted dragoons attacked unarmed men,

  1. Choose one piece of writing you would like to develop further - Chosen ...

    * He went to prison several times because of the nature of his works. These included 'Abuses, Script and Whipt' (1613) and 'Wither's Motto' (1621). * His later work was less controversial, and best known was probably his 1634/35 book, 'A Collection of Emblems'.

  2. Compare and Contrast The Concept of Nature in the Works of Karl Marx and ...

    conscious thing"q4); Secondly, by .his control over the productive process, through planning, ("man [unlike animals] constructs also in accordance with the laws of beauty" (Schmidt, 80); and thirdly, his self control (man is unique in that "no other animal can suppress his needs", (Mclellan, 521)

  1. Marvell & Herrick's Use of Carpe Diem.

    Continuing into the third section, Marvell's use of metaphors is more extensive and his rhyme becomes more regular again, recalling the earlier subtle and smooth flow of tone. It is also in this section that Marvell agues his solution

  2. Amine Werther's attitudes to nature. Is any development discernible? You may also wish to ...

    "Es schweben die Wolken Abw�rts, die Wolken Neigen sich der sehenden Liebe. Mir! Mir! In eurem Scho�e Aufw�rts! Umfangend umfangen! Aufw�rts an deinen Busen, Alliebender Vater!" 3 In "Auf dem See", we see many similar connections with Werther's attitudes to nature.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work