• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

As I Lay Dying Reliability of Perception

Free essay example:

Reliability of Perception

In William Faulkner’s novel, As I Lay Dying, tragicomic register entangles the narration provided by both Bundren and non-Bundren narrators. The coexistence of hilarity and calamity forges situational irony that illustrates the Bundren family’s tribulation with wavering perspective.  Whether kindhearted or acrimonious, however, these ironic moments play a prominent role in most of the novel's vignettes. The many non-Bundren narrators who perceive the Bundren escapade to be an uncanny amusement or a crude irreverence underline an ensuing a sense of a humorous realm. Accordingly, reliability in perception can be derived in outsiders who are able to step back from the quicksand of self-absorption that victimizes the Bundren family members and perceive the circumstance with a selfless mind able to laugh at the seemingly cursed fate of the Bundren family.

From a detached perspective held by narrators outside of the Bundren family, it is easy to gaze down upon their trials and travails and indulge in comic perception tainted with blasphemy towards their misfortune.  Indeed, Moseley and Peabody undoubtedly add fuel to this rampant fire of sacrilege. Upon Moseley’s account of the Bundren’s disembarkation in Mottson, his adaptation of their odyssey discloses the very truths the Bundrens themselves repudiate: the family had been lugging around a decaying corpse enclosed in a homemade casket for what “had been dead eight days" to the point that its stench “must have been like a piece of rotten cheese coming into an ant-hill," a lingering odor the family didn’t even pause to consider (Faulkner 488). In other words, either the Bundrens chose to disregard the reek or, since it had been undulating in their shadows since her death, they became accustomed to the stench to the extent that it was no longer recognizable. At this time, Moseley’s perspective as a bystander enables us to stop and smell the roses in order to appreciate or weigh out their value. However, in this case, the roses are metonymically substituted by the putrefying carcass of an elderly woman which we must measure the significance of to the family.  His ability to derive situational irony in the Bundrens’ misfortune allows us to step back from the panicked convolution of the family’s own narrations and examine their hardship with a clear mind.

By employing implicit absurdity perceived by the onlooker in instances of innocent tragedy of the victim, Faulkner situates the reader outside the family in order to provide them with a clear angle. Even without the direction of a bystander, we perceive situational irony in circumstances that are grave and solemn to the Bundrens, as they are unable to feel otherwise. Addie’s death is sobering. It is understandable. However, Faulkner strategically paints the canvas for us before we can even start to imagine independently. Indeed, the family’s thoughtfulness to tend to Addie by “[propping] her on her pillow” to “raise her head so that she can see the coffin Cash is making just outside her window” provokes an emotional appeal (342). Still, we have no emotional attachment to her. She is a corpse to us. We know she is predestined to expire. And soon. Thus, we find it ironic that the family is going out of its way to accommodate her lifeless body to foresee her fate in the ground, inhumanely taunting her with mortality. Further acts of empathy towards Addie are exhibited by the holes Vardaman drills in Addie's coffin “so that his mother can breathe,” a perceptibly compassionate gesture illustrative of a son caring for his ailed mother (376). For Vardaman, the epitome of naivety in the early stages of the novel, these holes are vital to her comfort. Vardaman acts out of pure somberness. Conversely, we know his efforts are futile. A corpse does not breathe, nor does it know the difference between being contented or distressed.  Therefore, we discredit Vardaman’s sincerity because we know it serves no purpose aside from appeasing his downtrodden spirit.

Faulkner utilizes Darl as an insider from the outside, undercover in a sense, as he is a member of the family though his ability to hysterically laugh at his family’s misfortune as he loses grip of sanity dictates his stance as comprehensive outsider. Subsequent to Addie’s burial, Jewel and Dewey Dell ensnare Darl and turn him in to two officers instructed to contain him and transport him to an asylum in Jackson. At the outset, shock and distress overcome Darl in consequence to Cash’s lack of admonition, and we witness Darl’s first true expression of sentiment. Usually Darl’s articulates his narrations with a verbose though detached register. In this instance however, Darl expresses his feelings in an effusive manner by laughing frenziedly. This behavior is not well received by Darl’s family members. From Cash’s perspective, the event provides no form of humor: "I be durn if I could see anything to laugh at" (514). Darl, alternatively, derives plentiful humor in the occurrence. Among the siblings of the Bundren family, Darl is the only member to perceive the absolute preposterousness of their odyssey; Darl is the only member of the family that makes an effort to liberate his mother from the contemptible and insolent dealings along the journey. Consequently, his family deems him insane. Nevertheless, his perception is perhaps the most credible for this very reason as he experiences all of the family’s trials first-hand though he is able to step back, and perceive them as would an outsider.  

Upon the conclusion of the novel, nonetheless, laughter appears to be the only retort to all preceding misfortunes. After the passing of nine days in which the family flouted multiple perilous obstacles in order to transport Addie's dead body to its ultimate resting place, the memorial service culminates in a spectacle that Faulkner abridges into two lines. The only mention of the burial itself announces the family "got it filled and covered"(513). The alleged climax of the trek lacks expected description due to the focus away from the family's bereavement and misery in laying the familial matriarch to rest, and instead, on the independent personal drive that truly promoted the continuation of the odyssey. Thus, outsiders and Darl alike possess the most reliable perceptions due to their ability to target the focus of the family in terms of morality and sensibility and steering clear of personal detours spoiled by ulterior motives. The final segment specifically- Anse’s introduction of the “new” Mrs. Bundren to his children- exploits humor to accentuate the disgracefulness of the circumstances. Beneath this layer of superficial irony lies a core of aching and disconcerting awareness of what transpired in the monologues amassing to this incongruous finale. Anse’s timely indulgence in another woman tops off the situational irony of the novel, hitherto one way or another such a finish is far from a commemoration of life's conquest over death. Instead, the irony produces a laughter shaded with grief and repentance.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Literary Criticism section.

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related University Degree Linguistics, Classics and related subjects Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related University Degree Literary Criticism essays

  1. How do "Frankenstein" and "Another Country" articulate the experience of the outsider?

    white has been created with bright people on dark streets, and white smiles in the black night. Race and its connotations are very prominent features in Another Country, with Rufus' character being particularly conscious of these. Throughout Rufus' short existence in the novel, Baldwin continuously uses free indirect style to

  2. Sense and sensibility in 'Howard's End' and 'Sense and Sensibility'

    No man could ever have written Jane Austen's novels.' (Hawthorn 38) The patriarchal society that Austen lived in meant that women were expected to obey their fathers and husbands. Middle to upper class women, such as the Dashwood sisters, had very little choices over how to occupy their time.

  1. The Compulsive Mother in D.H. Lawrences Sons and Lovers

    Paul was late one night from going out with Miriam. After asking if he came right home after dropping her off and receiving no answer, Mrs. Morel says, "She most be wonderfully fascinating, that you can't get away from her, but must go trailing eight miles at this time of night," (Lawrence 185).

  2. IN Faulkner's As I lay Dying What Would You Say To The Characters?

    When Addie is dying, all you do is complain about having to pay the doctor, because in your head you really just wanted the money to buy new teeth.

  1. South Park isnt Sesame Street, it is not poison either

    The paid celebrity only pretends to care for the hunger of those people. We learn that actors "are just people who are paid to pretend". In addition to that, this episode talks about sharing, caring and helping others if you are able to.

  2. Puddnhead Wilson as Fabulation

    The opening sentence of the novel is more formal than "Once upon a time" but the actual words-"The scene of this chronicle"-have much the same effect. In true story-telling fashion Mark Twain then starts off with the setting and with an introduction of several of the major characters.

  1. Using Evelyn Waughs, A Handful of Dust and Isabel Allendes Daughters of Fortune, as ...

    h?tred between th? p?rents th?t M?isie h?d to voice: "'he s?id I w?s to tell you? from him?' she f?ithfully reported? 'th?t you're ? n?sty horrid pig!'" (J?mes 11), not only destroys any hope of the family reuniting but is also corrupting Millie's young, innocent mind.

  2. From Hobbit to Hero- Frodo's Quest as an Examplary Monomyth

    He frequently appears in a masculine form, i.e. as a wizard, hermit, teacher or smith. The helper may also function as a guide, who leads the hero through a part of his quest. Another form of helper appears in a feminine form: the ?fairy godmother (...) a familiar feature of European fairy lore? (Campbell 1966: 71)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work