• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare the ways in which the Miller presents John the Carpenter in 'The Miller's Tale' with the ways in which Miss Fozzard presents Bernard in 'Talking Heads 2.'

Extracts from this document...


Laura Westwood Compare the ways in which the Miller presents John the Carpenter in 'The Miller's Tale' with the ways in which Miss Fozzard presents Bernard in 'Talking Heads 2.' In your answer you should pay particular attention to: * Vocabulary and style * Form * Any other features of language you consider to be important. The presentation of Bernard and John is largely different due to the narrative styles of the authors in the two stories. 'The Miller's Tale' is written in the style of third person intrusive narration, therefore the reader is influenced by the Miller's views and attitudes towards the carpenter. The Miller gives direct input to the presentation of the carpenter by expressing his feelings through comments such as "This sely carpenter goth forth his wey." This encourages the reader to agree with the suggestions the author makes, therefore in this case we believe the carpenter to be silly and na�ve, this is also emphasized by the tone of the narrative voice, being quite diminutive of the carpenter. The Miller is also an omniscient narrator, so he 'knows all' and 'sees all' that is going on in the text. ...read more.


Here, the speech of Nicholas emphasises his dismay and shows his state of mind, amusing the audience at his talk about elves and sprites. Therefore John is portrayed as a feeble, pathetic character. Nicholas has far more direct speech and is obviously the dominant speaker in exchanges between Nicholas and John, who is largely a passive listener. This is seen when Nicholas begins to involve John in his plot. He has many lines of speech whereas John only cries out things such as "Allas, my wyf." Bernard's attitudes come through in the story by the existence of non- verbal actions, which is especially expressed in 'Bernard suddenly throws back his head and yawns.' This seems quite rude of Bernard, and this is intensified by the use of the adverb, 'suddenly' which suggests a purposeful action. As he cannot at this stage talk, his actions are prominent in the presentation of his character. However, when he does begin to regain his power of speech, it is amusing that his first word is, "cow" and this is aimed at his sister. This reinforces with language the conflict we have previously seen by the use of the yawn. ...read more.


The repetition of this phrase effectively instils an image of the carpenter into the reader's mind. We are influenced by this and take the persistent views as fact. It is also emphasized by the contrasting epithet used to describe Nicholas, "hende Nicholas." This further diminishes the status of the carpenter as he is portrayed in a far less favourable light by the Miller, than essentially his 'rival.' The Miller also repeatedly makes reference to the term, "wood" which means 'mad,' an example being "crien 'water' as if he were wood" This essentially becomes the way in which John the carpenter is ridiculed by Alison and Nicholas at the end of the tale. The Miller explains that people in the village "in ronnen for to gauren on this man" they ran to stare at him. Again, Nicholas is held in higher status than John at the end where Nicolas was "anonright heeld with oother" so the people of the town believed a student over John the carpenter. In the same way that the epithet is used by the Miller, the way in which Miss Fozzard refers to Bernard in comparison to other characters, also influences the reader's view of Bernard. Miss Fozzard refers to her brother by first name terms only, which on the surface may seem to indicate a close relationship between the two characters. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Arthur Miller section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Arthur Miller essays

  1. Oleanna, written by David Mamet.

    That he 'liked being with me.' He'd let me write my examination paper over, if I could come back oftener to see him in his office" (2.1811). The "sexually explicit" story she refers to is a comment that John made about the different copulation tendencies of the rich and the poor.

  2. The Significance of a Line From Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman

    How does Arthur Miller show that the past is as alive as the present in Death of a Salesman? 2. How did Miller's decision to have Death of a Salesman take place "in a single setting, in a night or day" affect the impact of the play?

  1. Analyse and evaluate Millers choices of form, structure and language to express meaning

    Also, after his death, we are left with a sense of tragic waste, which follows the death of a hero, because despite being loved by his family, Willy came to value himself more in death than in life. Willy : Funny, y'know?


    This is because of her love for him. Although she is forced to come out with the truth in the end that it is Catherine he wants and not his name "You want somethin' else, Eddie, and you can never have her!"

  1. Caplan is a theatre critic. She argued that "The Crucible" is sexist in its ...

    I disagree with the statement, "Men abused women in the 17th century and Miller is abusing them in the 20th century". I feel Miller is intentionally creating this sexist approach towards women in his play because I think he is attempting to show how uncertain times can lead to erroneous judgement of character.

  2. What do you find interesting about the way Miller presents the character of Abigail ...

    I think Abigail is afraid of the situation that she now finds herself in. What started off as a playful adventure with some friends in a forest has quickly turned into very serious circumstances. We learn of Abigail's dominance amongst the group of girls who were in the forest.

  1. Eddie brings about his own downfall. Discuss this statement with close reference to the ...

    He shows this when he phones the immigration bureau. Catherine assumes when Eddie tells Rodolfo to go, he means her as well. However he grabs her arm and tells her she's "not goin' nowheres". Eddie knows he is beginning to loose Catherine and by telling Rodolfo to leave he's bringing his own downfall.

  2. The Chaucerian Miller: Not the Typical Miller.

    Moreover, the wart on the tip of his nose puts the finishing touches Chaucer needs to convince any reader of the General Prologue that the Miller is an unsophisticated man, who has enjoyed the base aspects of life, and gets pleasure out of the more primitive things, such us his sinful, vulgar tales.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work