• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Fate and freedom in Marvell and Milton.

Extracts from this document...


Fate and freedom in Marvell and Milton The concluding image in Marvell's lyric 'The Definition of Love' starkly depicts the separation intrinsic to the lovers' existence: As lines (so loves) oblique may well Themselves in every angle greet: But ours so truly parallel, Though infinite, can never meet. (25 - 8) The perfection and harmony of their love paradoxically prevent them ever from combining or meeting 'as one'. That is to say, the lovers will never meet to consummate their affections and their union can only remain emotional or intellectual, and certainly not physical. Yet this mixture of 'Despair / Upon Impossibility' (3 - 4) does not in any respect demean the value of the love or lessen its intensity: rather, it is from this that it reaches its perfection by transcending the ordinary. In finding a way to resist Fate's 'tyrannic power' (16) they accomplish a fuller union than they otherwise would: Therefore the love which us doth bind But Fate so enviously debars, Is the conjunction of the mind, And opposition of the stars. (29 - 32) Although Fate has placed them 'as the distant Poles' and any physical union will only be the result of freak planetary accident, they have nonetheless defied her and found solace in pursuing more than 'feeble Hope' (7). ...read more.


The poem shows the conclusion of man being master of his own fate, yet unlike the contended reassurance found for the two lovers in 'The Definition', who by a complex astronomical and intellectual leap find that their separation is an aspect of the perfection of their love, here the human assumption of quasi-divine authority is more unsettling. Moral judgement is worthless against Cromwell, who in his virtual omnipotence makes this redundant: 'Tis madness to resist or blame The force of angry heaven's flame (25 - 6) Throughout, Marvell famously refuses to praise Cromwell unequivocally, or to castigate the dead king, instead presenting an ambivalent response to the final events of the Civil War. Although it is a poem with a clear focus on the leaders and events which were forming England, it is much more personal than, for example, 'The First Anniversary', which has a clear sense of its position as 'public' literature. Given this, it might perhaps seem strange that the Horatian Ode presents a world where retreating into the self appears virtually impossible. Nature, the supreme goddess in the final fragmentary cantos of the Faerie Queene and a frequent force of authority in much Renaissance literature, has lost her power ...read more.


There is a kind of delighted lethargy as the speaker immerses himself in an abundant, Edenic profusion of food, apparently retreating so far into a prelapsarian state that he loses control, 'stumbling on melons'. Yet even here knowledge is derived from an experience of loss. Ridding himself of 'busy companies of men', he loses his social lifestyle and learns instead the value of 'delicious solitude'. Intellectually, he discovers the destructive powers of the mind: Annihilating all that's made To a green thought in a green shade. (47 - 8) Jonathan Crewe argued that 'in the wake of political monarchy the only masculine absolutism may well be the displaced, solitary absolutism of the imaginary garden state' (57). This theory does not take into account the extent to which a return to Eden constitutes a further subjection of one's own power from that experienced on earth; it equally ignores the loss of knowledge that such a return necessarily requires. Postlapsarian Adam and Eve have a new freedom to experience life for themselves, to conduct themselves with far greater liberty than that afforded them in Paradise. Although of course life will not be without its rules of worship and behaviour, Providence is now their guide rather than their master. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Milton section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Milton essays

  1. By means of what textual strategies does Milton seek to 'justify the ways of ...

    The idea of any similarity being found between art and divine creation is given particular relevance by speaking of the creative power as Spirit and Dove, that is, by combining in himself divine power, wisdom, and gentleness; it is because God has these qualities that Milton confidently addressees to him a prayer for help in his 'adventurous Song'.

  2. Is Milton's Satan rightly regarded as a tragic hero?

    He is also fundamentally flawed in believing that it is only force that raises God 'above his equals', although he is their creator, and therefore all-powerful. Lewis describes his attack on his maker as effectively 'sawing off the branch he is sitting on', and it is reasonable to believe that

  1. Jean-Baptiste Molire's Don Juan has all the outward appearances of seventeenth-century French farce - ...

    Sganarelle (his character perhaps interpreted as the conscience that Don Juan never developed), views the consumption of tobacco not only as aristocratic behavior, but more importantly, as a root cause of that social nobility (rather than a manifestation). If Sganarelle confuses cause and effect to achieve a higher status, his

  2. Humanism in Dante and MiltonHumanism had a profound impact on European society during the ...

    Throughout the Inferno, Dante meets a wide range of characters, all with different personalities. Many of these characters are those with whom Dante's was once acquainted. Dante's decision to put his contemporaries in Hell reflects humanism, since he respects both his friends and enemies as individuals.

  1. John Milton's "Doctrine and Discipline of Divorce" argued that the most valid reason for ...

    Second: by the same law, whereby each party, either man or wife, in whatever way, could renounce their marital association at will and thus, in turn lawfully separate." (433) These passages clearly give wives the same rights as men regarding divorce and perhaps by omitting to say that wives do

  2. In order to be able to discover the relevance Milton and Paradise Lost still ...

    savages "most English colonialists on the edge of the civil world lived in fear of becoming." (p.93) this relates to the theme carried out throughout Paradise Lost, where God is continuously warning Adam and Eve not to disobey Him and eat from the forbidden tree.

  1. A Study of Traherne's Metaphysical Poetry

    His poetry demonstrates the limitations of language and the reader shares in his frustration that words can go no further. If we contrast Traherne's poetry with a poem such as Herbert's `Vertue'7 many differences become evident. As with Traherne, Herbert experiences a sense of wonder - `sweet day, so cool, so calm, so bright.'

  2. There are many indications within the poetry of Tony Harrison that he considers his ...

    Harrison is not trying to be one of the classical authors; he is trying to respond to them in a way that is different but not necessarily inferior11. Indeed, Kermode agrees that "the best commentary on any verse is another verse, possibly placed very far away from it".12Harrison accepts that

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work