How far do you agree with this judgment on Milton's handling of Satan in ParadiseLost I & II?

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

How far do you agree with this judgment on Milton's handling of Satan in Paradise Lost I & II? Satan in Paradise Lost presents an unusual dichotomy; he is both the personification of cosmic malevolence and a pathetic character. As a theist who is resolved to "justify the ways of God to man", one assumes that Milton would not deliberately show Satan in a wholly sympathetic light. Indeed, Milton warns that humans are particularly attracted to Satan's "guile" and that he is ultimately a deluded fraud. Yet Satan's villainy is caused by his faults and his conflict as the "the Antagonist of Heav'n" contributes to both the plot and God's over-aching scheme. It seems counter-intuitive to suspend the ethical context of a theodicy, however, Satan's exploits could be described as tragically heroic. As Milton engages in other conventions of classical epics such as epic similes and the invocation, one would assume that Paradise Lost has a hero of some kind.

Middle

In these admissions, Milton presents Satan as a complex character of some virtue. Satan's leadership is inspiring as he is able to rouse his initially hopeless army to draw "millions of flaming swords". He is morally admirable in believing that "to be weak is miserable". Yet one must be vigilant against viewing Satan as absolutely heroic. The first two books are from Satan's perspective, therefore his view of God and his resultant situation is somewhat perverted. Unlike tragic figures such as Oedipus, Satan's punishment does not lead to either self-knowledge or catharsis. He bitterly demands why he should "bow and sue for grace/With suppliant knee", re-enforcing his role as the antagonist of the poem. His unwillingness to repent is to his blinding "fixed mind" which proudly refuses to abandon his "high distain". The loyalty he inspires in his troops verges on sinister as they "bend/With awful reverence prone". This, coupled with Milton calling him "great Emperor" and "Sultan", shows Satan to be comparable to Ottoman Emperors whom the English despised as wicked, dehumanised despots.

Conclusion

This charade of democracy and ironic "full consent" is specious and affirms Satan to be deceptive. His reaction to Sin and Death perhaps best characterises his ability to manipulate. He initially casts a "disdainful look" and calls Sin an "execrable shape" until he realises her usefulness. This disgust is masked as he assures her he is "no enemy" and affectionately refers to her as "dear daughter". This "subtle" shift illustrates Satan's Machiavellian nature that is willing to cajole in order to gain. The Miltonic Satan deliberately provokes a moral tension as the reader is inclined to empathise, or indeed sympathise, with him. In his dilemma of being "confounded though immortal", the pathos does give Satan a tragic dimension. Although he may be a sophisticated literary character, Satan should not be entirely vindicated even though he is more recognisable than the abstract protagonist. Perhaps it is the reader's post-lapsarian state which is partly seduced by Satan in Paradise Lost. "In some ways Satan resembles villainous tragic heroes such as Macbeth, but there are many indications that the reader is supposed to regard him as a fraud."

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Milton essays

  1. Discuss the presentation of Hell in Book One of ParadiseLost.

    'A dungeon horrible' suggesting torture, suffering and punishment, which is Milton's intention as he wants you to think of Hell like this, with a pictorial image produced by his use of language.

  2. Paradise Lost Books IX and X "Discuss the development of the characters of Adam ...

    For me, the fruit acts as a kind of truth potion. We start to see the genuine and unmasked versions of the two major characters. The way in which they have acted when together before has been very stereotypical. Now however, we see what they have been yearning to release from within themselves during the start of book nine.

  1. By means of what textual strategies does Milton seek to 'justify the ways of ...

    Who was to blame for the downfall of commonwealth ideals? Had Milton proved inadequate, and been struck blind as a punishment? Had the English people failed their God? Or had God failed his people? Milton set out with one aim, in an effort of epic composition, to 'assert Eternal Providence, /And justify the ways of God to men'.

  2. In order to be able to discover the relevance Milton and Paradise Lost still ...

    Milton, in his epic Paradise Lost deals with the theme of colonialism throughout the poem. As Evans (1996) brings to our attention, "those who journeyed into the new world were portrayed in early literature as being more ambitious, more energetic, and more daring than those who stayed behind."

  1. There are many indications within the poetry of Tony Harrison that he considers his ...

    Harrison is not trying to be one of the classical authors; he is trying to respond to them in a way that is different but not necessarily inferior11. Indeed, Kermode agrees that "the best commentary on any verse is another verse, possibly placed very far away from it".12Harrison accepts that

  2. The Dualistic Genesis of Paradise Lost

    consideration can be taken as a supercilious summit standing out in a major strain of Christian theology, the Pauline tradition (O'Keefe 1982). Then, they are also signs whose analysis may shed light on a stage in the maturity of the Western mind.

  1. 'Paradise Lost' - "Our Flesh is An Eve Within Us"[1]- The Presentation of Eve ...

    Eve, made from a rib of Adam, is traditionally seen as his inferior, "not equal, as their sex not equal seemed" (IV: 296)11 and her servitude justified on the basis that Adam is "for God only, she for God in him" (IV: 299)12.

  2. Paradise Lost - What Do We Learn About Satan's Character from Line 84 To ...

    He makes a virtue out of his unwillingness to 'Repent or change' - the very unwillingness which imprisons him eternally in the hell of himself. Much of what Satan says makes him sound grand and admirable because of the rhetorical force with which it is expressed, however when studied more

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.