• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Manus and Owen: two contrasting fortunes. How do their attitudes and fortunes change?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Rebecca Hong Manus and Owen: two contrasting fortunes. How do their attitudes and fortunes change? The play Translations by Brian Friel opens with Manus, the eldest son of the hedge-school master, helping a "waiflike" Sarah, who suffers from a speech defect, to speak, and he does so with "a kind of zeal". This in itself reveals an aspect of Manus' personality. He is a giving character, putting the needs of others before him. Manus has lived with his father, Hugh O'Donnell, in Baile Beag all his life, and has accepted his role as his father's 'guardian'. He is a nationalist, supporting the Irish while despising anything English. This is shown in his support for Doalty in Act I, where Doalty's trick on the English soldiers is regarded simply by Manus as "a gesture". Hugh's younger son Owen is perhaps more dynamic than Manus. He decided to leave Baile Beag for Dublin at a relatively young age, and was able to set up a number of shops there. At first we are unclear as to where Owen stands in terms of his nationalism. There is an air of ambiguity regarding just how 'Irish' he really is. However, once the play develops Owen proves that he is an Irishman at heart, becoming a nationalist together with Doalty and the Donnelly twins. In both Act I and Act III Manus refers to himself as "lame". He mocks himself using the term "lame son" in an attempt to entertain those around him and make fun of himself, and succeeds, as it is said that "Maire has to laugh at this". ...read more.

Middle

The relationship between Manus and Owen is distant at first. Upon seeing eachother for the first time in six years they greet one another rather formally-"And Manus!" "You're welcome Owen". Owen then turns his back to face the others at the school. Though Owen makes physical contact with each of the school members, there is no contact with Manus, creating a slightly cold atmosphere amongst them. Despite this, Manus is the only one to ask about his arrival, and the only one to care whether Owen has been enlisted as a soldier. When speaking to Manus about this matter Owen is rather patronising and condescending. His use of "quiant" and "archaic" to describe their language supports this further. Owen uses the phrase "you people" to describe the people of Baile Beag, suggesting his detachment from his Irish roots-he no longer identifies with them. Owen also suggests he is in support of anglicizing place names by using the phrase "the King's good English". He thinks that English is a 'good' language, superior to all others. This is supported by his blas´┐Ż attitude towards being called Roland. He says "Owen-Roland-what the hell. It's only a name. It's the same me, isn't it?". This carries great significance, as it shows Owen's attitude regarding the changing of place names, though the fact that he follows this question with the phrase "Well, isn't it?" gives reason for us to believe that he is looking for assurance, that he is unsure of himself. ...read more.

Conclusion

This is strengthened by their decision to leave the place name Tobair Vree as it is, rather than try to find it's English equivalent. This brings Owen and Yolland closer as friends, and is reflected in Yolland's relationship with Manus later on. When Manus reveals he has a new job Yolland is sincerely happy for him, and Manus is also sincere in his reply, as they shake hands "warmly" on his departure. Manus is portrayed throughout the play as a caring character, especially in his treatment of Sarah. He speaks to her with a warmth that no other in the hedge school does-"Those are lovely, Sarah". Manus is very affectionate when dealing with Sarah, and though this behaviour may be an everyday occurrence for him, Sarah has read more into the situation than he has intended. He kisses her on the head and hugs her a few times, and she is full of "embarassment" when he receives the flowers given to him, yet he seems unaware of Sarah's feelings for him. On occasions he simply ignores what she has to say, for example when she actually is able to say her name to Owen she is "elated at her success", and shares this with Manus, who just ignores her. Despite this she is fiercely loyal to Manus, and upon seeing Maire and Yolland together instinctively calls his name. Manus' departure leaves her feeling upset and guilty, and Manus kindly says she is not to blame-"you did no harm at all", yet he addresses her with no warmth or concern, as he has previously done. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Wilfred Owen section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Wilfred Owen essays

  1. Compare and Contrast the Presentations of the Individuals in Conflict with Society in ...

    Even though Bromden is much taller then any of the staff, and therefore could physically overpower them, because of the strict attitude of Ms. Ratched and the Black Boys, they are able to manipulate Bromden into believing he is weak in comparison.

  2. Write a critical appreciation of the passage pages 52-56 paying particular attention to Friels ...

    Manus's demand "What's incorrect about the place-names we have here?'' to Owen in Act one, is reflected in Yolland's subsequent questioning of Owen's answer-"Who's confused? -Are the people confused?" Both realise the true reasoning behind the renaming process: "It's a bloody military operation!''

  1. Compare the presentation of changing and contrasting attitudes throughout the First World War through ...

    Despite the apparent diversity of the poems by placing them together the reader is able to see them as a single article portraying the views and attitudes of soldiers and civilians as the war went on. "When the war came Stephen was relieved.

  2. The poem "Futility" by Wilfred Owen deals with the speaker's desperation after the experience ...

    by his recall of the past, thinking of the "sun" that "always [...] woke" (I,4)his companion. This turning away from the present seems to be a try to escape the situation he is unable to cope with by dreaming away to a happier and -even more important- peaceful past (I,

  1. Three poems by Wilfred Owen.

    He yells out in pain and flounders like a man in fire, as a fish would when out of water. Owen goes on to use the metaphor of 'as under a green sea' to describe this man's death as he drowns in the sea of gas as it settles on the ground like a green mist.

  2. Compare William Makepeace Thackeray's 'The Due of the Dead' and Sir Henry Newbolt's 'Vitai ...

    The use of repetition in the final line of each stanza, 'Play up! play up! and play the game!', strengthens this extended metaphor and acts to reinforce the poet's propagandist thesis, as well as supplementing the idea of continuity that can be inferred from the poem's title.

  1. The management issues that Robert Owen was dealing with at Lanark

    and efficiency, Making the most of limited resources and coping with the changing environment How the wider context affected Robert Owens Management activities and how Owen tried to change that context. Robert Owen was faced with a wider range of problems, which he believed affected the mill.

  2. How does Owen change his affiliations in "Translations"? Discuss his role as translator and ...

    Yet although his job involves going against his people by taking away Irish heritage and ultimately rejecting the Irish language it is clear that as the play progresses he takes on board some of Yolland's views and begins to discover the true importance of naming.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work