• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Medieval writers were much better at starting dreams than finishing them." Consider the problems of ending in medieval dream narratives.

Extracts from this document...


"Medieval writers were much better at starting dreams than finishing them." Consider the problems of ending in medieval dream narratives. In that they deal with bereavement, both Pearl and Chaucer's Book of the Duchess begin, paradoxically, writing about endings. Through dreams, the narrators play out tensions between these so-called "endings" - the death of a beloved (though unnamed) daughter in Pearl and Blanche, Duchess of Lancaster in The Book of the Duchess - and the difficulty that the bereaved suffer in coming to terms with the notion of a 'new' beginning for themselves and for their loved ones, in a separate, divine realm. For Spearing, medieval dream poetry is, by definition, a genre fundamentally concerned with the question of beginnings and endings: "compared with other poems, it makes us more conscious that it has a beginning and an end", which is marked clearly by the falling asleep and the awakening of the narrator. However, at the same time, the dream poetry genre as a whole has far less clear sense of a beginning and an end. Even within the medieval period, Spearing also reminds us that "despite the common assumptions of some critics, dream poetry did not constitute a separate category of love-narratives." Both of the poets seem to display a strong consciousness of writing within a long and continuous literary tradition, for example in the intertextual references to Roman de la Rose (perhaps the most influential medieval dream poem of all) ...read more.


However, each step that he takes in the dream seems to bring him further from the objects of his desire. This sense of distancing and limitation is manifested in the physical symbol of the river itself that separates the dreamer from heaven. The poet plays upon the dual meaning of the word "deuyse" to illustrate the way in which the dreamer's separation works on many different levels: "what separates the dreamer from heaven is not so much space as a different mode of being...it represents an ontological rather than spatial divide." Even when the dreamer is allowed an insight into the heavenly city, this occurs at a distance. Putter comments upon how the descriptions: "is not intended - as it is in its biblical source - to herald man's permanent absorption into the kingdom of God, but to underline his continued exclusion from it" (there is, for example, no mention of the second coming in Pearl). Equally, the maiden demonstrates an emotional distance from her father, speaking in a lofty tone of reprimand rather than affection: "Sir, ye haf your tale mysetente...". It seems that the culmination of this quest to understand and bridge the spatial, emotional and symbolic gap between the two realms - as the dreamer dashes into the water - only serves to emphasise the impossibility of his aim. For many critics, this abrupt end to the dream is often seen as rather "disappointing" (Burrow). ...read more.


that can be traced back to formal classical thought, but also as a mode of thinking that distinguishes us as humans (reminiscent of the Cartesian: "I think therefore I am"). It seems that, even at the end of Pearl, neither the dreamer, nor the reader, can escape these "doubts" about the limitation of human understanding. For Putter: "the dreamer in Pearl always remains an outsider". There is a sense of this exteriority in the symbolic river that forces the dreamer to remain outside of heaven and in the manner in which he cannot enter into a full understanding of the paradoxical transcendental truths of heaven. Even the structure of the poem itself is characterised by a kind of rigid restriction, yet as Borroff writes: "In Pearl we see the poet offering up his craft, creating an expressive power out of the very restrictions imposed upon expression". It seems that in the complex ending of Pearl, the poet pushes boundaries of human understanding by revealing its limitations. At the beginning of the poem, the dreamer faces a personal, emotional crisis of bereavement but also poses fundamental theological and philosophical questions. At the end, when the poem has come full circle, the narrator is forced to confront the futility of his search to possess his pearl (literal and metaphorical), but also with the wider, fundamentally unanswerable nature of the questions that he seeks to answer. The unresolved, circular and opaque (even pearl-like) "problems" of the ending are in fact perhaps the most striking quality of the entire poem. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Wordsworth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Wordsworth essays

  1. Analysis of The Abstract Wild by Jack Turner

    Little is known about these ancient birds because they avoid human contact. Turner is intrigued by their behavior. He observes the white pelicans as enjoying their risky high dive flights. He makes the connection between the peculiar behavior of the white pelican and the nature of wild animals.

  2. "Prometheus Unbound" and Shelley's Prefatory Defense Against Critics

    Olympus and antagonist. He infers that Milton's Satan, in contrast, is vengeful, overly ambitious and blinded by hate. (Wheatley 734) Clearly, Shelley wrote for the masses but with the reviewer in mind. On one hand, he hoped to spark reform, while convincing the socially elite reviewer that the "Champion and

  1. In this sense, we will represent Felicia ...

    Hence, we have to admit that there is a shared culture between men and women throughout the period of romanticism. Wollstonecraft argues that to deny women the opportunities of education and an active role in society is to transform them into domestic slaves.

  2. Compare and Contrast The Concept of Nature in the Works of Karl Marx and ...

    understanding of nature. Human Needs as Nature's Needs On examining the concept of human needs in Marx, it appears that they are often found to be the equivalent of the means of subsistence. In Capital, Marx lists needs specifically as the strength needed to work the next day, for the

  1. Attitudes to London in William Blakes 'London' and William Wordsworths 'Upon Westminster Bridge'.

    The word 'Runs' tells us that the blood is continuous and there is lots of it. It could represent everyone in London's blood, as they are suffering while the royal family is inside the safety and security of the palace walls when it is there responsibility to sort the mess out, as they are the figures of authority.

  2. A Rose Is But A Rose: Parker vs. H.D.

    describe the rose and not any particular human feeling on the topic of love. This brief poem and its carefully picked verse lines strung together with adjective-fashioned diction becomes very simplistic and one dimensional. A great example of H.D's descriptive use comes in stanza one, "Rose, harsh rose, marred and

  1. Amine Werther's attitudes to nature. Is any development discernible? You may also wish to ...

    he prefers children to express themselves naturally rather than be constrained by society; he refers to the early writers Ossian and Homer during his letters which are by definition of the period more natural; he admires Lotte's motherly relationship with her siblings for its naturalness and the way in which

  2. "The experience of the wild exposes and educates." How well is this statement supported ...

    Ovid's experience in Tomis also teaches him morally. On a hunting party, he is able to release the guilt he bore for being "the son who should have died". Ovid remembers how he had become distanced from his father and how this unhappiness had become a burden on his life.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work