• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Moral Conscience vs. Church Doctrine

Extracts from this document...


Loresa D. Matarazzo Response Paper, Question #3 Principles of Lit. Study 350:220 July 21, 2004 Moral Conscience vs. Church Doctrine Contemporary readers would likely disagree with Elizabeth Rigby's assertion that Jane Eyre is an "anti-Christian composition;" however, in light of the prevailing religious doctrine of the Evangelical movement and turmoil regarding same during the mid-1800's, one can easily under-stand Ms. Rigby's reasoning for this indictment at the time. There are at least three characters within the novel associated with Christianity; namely-Mr. Brocklehurst, Helen Burns and St. John Rivers, and it is made clear in the text that Jane refuses to pledge herself to the doctrine espoused by any of them. It is not difficult to object to Mr. Brocklehurst's hypocrisy and to find him detestable. With regard to Helen Burns, it is impossible not to develop fond feelings for her, but it is also not possible to ignore Jane's skepticism with regard to Helen's martyr-like religious doctrine. ...read more.


(Chapter IV, p. 26). Brocklehurst's ensuing dialogue with 10-year-old Jane seems more like an inquisition than a conversation, during which he seeks to instill fear: "Children younger than you die daily...It is to be feared the same could not be said of you, were you to be called hence." (Chapter IV, p. 27) In creating such an uncompassionate character, it is clear that Bronte sought to expose the oppressive nature of the Evangelical religion. Bronte also confronted the harsh and hypocritical nature of such a religion as respects the preaching of self-denial and suffering in the name of God. She exposes what she feels to be un-Christian behavior done in the name of Christianity. The cruel, abusive nature of such extremism is shown when Brocklehurst chastises Miss Temple for giving the Lowood students bread and cheese to substitute for the inedible porridge. ...read more.


In this way, Bronte accuses this type of "Christianity" of being hypocritical and of precluding genuine spirituality as well as equality. Throughout Jane Eyre, Bronte concerns herself with how the 19th century popular Evangeli-cal doctrine serves to endorse cruel, unjust behavior (and in the form of St. John Rivers and Helen Burns, how it restricts Jane's freedom). Her direct opposition to these forms of "Christianity" is shown in Jane's rejection of each of their doctrines. Bronte thus binds Jane to none of the Christian doctrines advocated by these characters, but instead leaves her to balance her faith in God with her own moral conscience. Therefore, especially in light of the prevailing low social status of women, this could have easily deemed Jane Eyre to have been shocking and revolutionary as well as anti-Christian to some of its initial readers (likely of a high social class.) ?? ?? ?? ?? 2 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Charlotte Bronte section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Charlotte Bronte essays

  1. How is happiness conveyed in Jane Austen's Emma and Charlotte Bronte's Villette?

    Emma is told through a third-person omniscient narrator, whereas Lucy tells us the story through her own, if somewhat limited perspective. Austen's narrator gives us a wider outlook on the events at Highbury, although the free-indirect style means that the narrator's opinions are sometimes blurred with those of the characters and there is some mimicry of Emma's thoughts and tone.

  2. Free essay

    Jane Eyre, its film and sequels whatever their differences- always return to the ...

    She gets out the loft on more than one occasion, first outside Jane's room when she is heard laughing, then when she sets fire to Rochester's room, and ultimately burning down Thornfield and making Rochester lose his sight and hand.

  1. This essay attempts to examine and analyze the autobiographical links in Kafka's fiction Metamorphosis ...

    Georg's father breaks his son's will to write as Kafka's father attempts to do with his disdain for and indifference towards it. In conclusion, although Kafka desired his writing to be a semantic and psychological mechanism where the author is 'distanced' from the "act of reading or interpretation" <http://www.kafka.org/essays/koopmanWB.htm>, and

  2. How does Charlotte Bronte build up tension? Using chapter 23 to illustrate.

    In the novel, Jane is very conscious that, socially, she is inferior to many of those with whom she associates in spite of being a 'lady'. At that time, money only can determine where anyone can fit on the social ladder.

  1. Jane Eyre- Analysis.

    While Helen's Christianity is not useful for Jane, neither is Jane's attitude of self-defense; she must find and develop her own brand of spirituality. Helen's philosophy of Christian forgiveness is tested as Mr. Brocklehurst unjustly punishes Jane. Though Jane does not fight back, she inwardly seethes and thinks, "I was no Helen Burns."

  2. The function of landscape or the environment in Jane Eyre.

    In fact, Jane only goes back twice in the novel - from Thornfield to Gateshead, to visit Mrs Reed and from Moor House to Thornfield, when she searches for Rochester. Key themes in the novel are closely linked to and represented through environment, and the different settings become quite inseparable from their association with key characters.

  1. In Sons and Lovers how does Lawrence challenge conventional attitudes towards social and sexual ...

    Lawrence includes the unconventional relationship of Clara and Baxter Dawes in the novel to juxtapose with the failed relationships of Mr and Mrs Morel, and Paul and Miriam. The success of this relationship is interesting as it was very unusual for a woman to leave her husband, to live independently and to have an affair with her husband's younger friend.

  2. In the light of these two critical readings, discus the presentation of the unnamed ...

    It is possible to see Rochester as a victim as suggested by Jayachandran, who says that he is a 'worthless son to his father'. He has been shunned and forced into a new way of life, which was commonplace. Rochester had no choice but to acquiesce and commit as now he is married 'for better of for worse'.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work