• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Seamus Heany - Death of a Naturalistand The Early Purges

Extracts from this document...


Miranda Fisher-Levine 10N Seamus Heany - Death of a Naturalist and The Early Purges The poems of Seamus Heany can be seen to be similar in many ways, in language, style, subject and mood. In this essay I shall compare two of his poems - Death of a Naturalist and The Early Purges. The Early Purges is on the subject of a young boy learning about how kittens are drowned on a "well-run" farm. Dan Taggart appears to be an older boy or man, obviously experienced in these matters, and his attitude to the "scraggy wee shits" is transferred to the Heany towards the end of the poem, when he realises the "pests have to be kept down". This is a new attitude to him - at the beginning of the poem, the sound they made was "frail", their paws were "soft", both potential terms of endearment, but these turn out to be (in his eyes) "false sentiments", and he refers to puppies as "bloody pups". Living on a farm does seem to harden him, but these "false sentiments" would only seem false on a farm, where animals have to die to benefit humans. However, these sentiments are not false because when he feels them, he has not learn the ins and outs of farm life, so they are merely na�ve. The thought that this is a "farm attitude" is confirmed by his reference to the town being a place "where they consider death unnatural". ...read more.


The second stanza provides a marked change in mood - suddenly, nature becomes threatening, and the way the "daddy frog" "croaked" in the first stanza suddenly becomes "a coarse croaking" and "their blunt heads fart". The innocent tadpoles he watched have become "gross-bellied frogs", "angry" creatures that "invaded the flax-dam" and made "obscene threats". The last line is particularly interesting. It says that if he "dipped" his "hand the spawn would clutch it". This is a curious role reversal - earlier in the poem, he took the frogspawn and after he sees the frogs, his thought is that the spawn becomes vengeful, and wants to take him, almost to revenge the stolen spawn of the previous year. The language Heany uses is very effective in this poem - the sounds of "clotted" and "slobber" evoke a very accurate image of frogspawn, and the alliteration - "wait and watch", "strong gauze of sound around the smell", "the flax-dam festered" - adds to the aura of fascination that surrounds the poem. The second stanza begins with the word "Then", correctly implying that there has been a change. The onomatopoeic "slap and plop" of the frogs and their "blunt heads farting" combined with the assonance of "cocked", "sods", "hopped" add a sense of discomfort; the language and style of the second stanza combine to provide an effective and evocative mood of aggression and fear. The title implies that there is a death in the poem, but the boy does not die. ...read more.


position, if only to protect myself from the harsh reality that more animals means buying more food, and that means spending more money. Country life is very different to city life, and I, having experienced both, can appreciate that to a certain extent. The poem is very poignant, and I like Heany's use of language when describing the kittens, and, as I am a cat lover, it inspires quite deep feelings in me. The reference to his early feelings as "false sentiments" does not ring true to me. I think that there is no such thing as a false sentiment, there are merely different sentiments that can develop according to how one is brought up and what one experiences. Death Of A Naturalist does not appeal much to me. The subject seems to be a little asinine, but that is judged only on my personal experience - when I was younger, all of nature fascinated me, especially frogs, and I loved the way they croaked and splatted, so I cannot see how that could intimidate or scare a child. His use of language is effective, though, and I like his description of the flax-dam; it is easy to visualise this hot, aromatic, noisy place where a portion of Heany's childhood took place. It would seem that these two of Heany's poems are similar in many ways. It shows that Heany had a childhood in the country, flooded with nature and tells how it affected his childhood. 1,469 words ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Wordsworth section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related University Degree Wordsworth essays

  1. NATURE, natural, and the group of words derived from them, or allied to them ...

    In the times when mankind were nearer to their natural state, cultivated observers regarded the natural man as a sort of wild animal, distinguished chiefly by being craftier than the other beasts of the field; and all worth of character was deemed the result of a sort of taming; a phrase often applied by the ancient philosophers to.

  2. Is it true that early Greek Philosophers discovered nature?

    This is a Greek conception that was conceived around the time of Thales. Personally I think it is scientific but also deals with the nature aspect that is obvious when we talk about "elements". This can refer to nature, as everything is a "form", whether it be a plant (growing thing)

  1. Coleridge, Samuel Taylor (1772-1834), English poet, critic, and philosopher, who was a leader of ...

    left for a trip to the Continent; Coleridge soon went his own way, spending much of his time in Germany. During this period he lost early sympathy with political radicalism and became interested in German philosophy, especially the 18th-century Idealism of Immanuel Kant and the 17th-century mystical writings of Jakob

  2. What are the differences between the humour in Aristophanes' "The Frogs" and "The Wasps"?

    of the house is extremely visual, the humour purely ocular, in Procleon's desperation to escape he becomes more and more extravagant in his means of eluding his son, at one point he tries to squeeze through the chimney pretending to be "only smoke", a very amusing image, especially with the oversize padding they wore.

  1. Many poets were inspired and influenced by nature but however the two most famous ...

    In the first verse he utilizes sound well as the 'z' and 's' sounds create a buzzing noise as the reader says it, 'bluebottles wove a strong gauze of sound around the smell'. Heany chiefly conveys the sense of innocence effectively in the first verse by the child's use of language 'mammy' and 'daddy'.

  2. Poets Throughout History Have Examined Man's Relationship With Nature. Briefly Discuss How Some ...

    Wordsworth starts the poem by describing the day as 'one of those heavenly days that cannot die', producing a sense of eternal joy. He describes his departure from his 'cottage-threshold' as if he is breaking free of its grasp, his emotions as 'the eagerness of boyish hope', giving an image of innocence.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work