• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Shunning the Human Person: A Response to Roland Barthes's The Death of the Author

Free essay example:

Martin Klekner

English and American Studies

Course: English Skills and Cultural Communication

Time: Wednesday, 19.10 – 20.40, P001

Lecturer: Stephan Delbos

Shunning the “Human Person”:  A Response to Roland Barthes's “The Death of the Author”

        There is a difference between offering a valuable opinion and imposing a new “universal truth”. If Roland Barthes in his essay “The Death of the Author” did the former, his text would  probably have more meaning than in its current form. He asks a question “Who is speaking [in a literary work]?” and answers it: “We shall never know, for the good reason that writing is the

destruction of every voice, of every point of origin.“ The implications are obvious and maybe even shocking. Barthes basically declares that the literary author is not important, that the text is the only thing that matters - and he expects the world to tremble. He presents his opinion as a single valid answer and completely ignores the real world reality.

        The essay reminds us that the “author” is an invention of modern times, of the focus on the “human person” and it goes on about this as if it were a bad thing. This is the problem. This topic is clearly a matter of personal opinion and when “human person” is presented with such a clear negative attitude, one can not help but to argue. The whole idea of multi-layered text with infinite number of meanings all originating from the reader is very attractive, but Barthes kills it by shunning the author and presenting his opinions as unarguable. If he just brought this idea, displayed it and let the deep meanings sink into the reader's mind instead of outraging a lot of people by destroying the generally accepted beliefs in the importance of human personality, he would be much better off.

        As one of his examples, Barthes chooses the French poet Mallarmé, who shares his opinions about the “language” being more important than the “author”. “Mallarmé's entire poetics consists in suppressing the author in the interests of writing.” Again, a very unattractive opinion for many. A question lingers in normal person's mind after reading this: “Is the death of the author really worth it then? By suppressing the author, won't he become slave to the text? Won't then the text become a mindless, personality-less game of its own? Is that what we really want?”

        Barthes is placing the language above the writer, he makes it something supernatural, almost flawless, something more than the person behind it. What is one to think when he declares: "Linguistically (...) [subject] I is nothing other than the instance saying I."? Throw away the author, he says. Forget him! Focus on the text. The text, the language! Yet he forgets that the – call him normal, average, sane – reader is not really interested in the text, he does not want to learn more about a group of words or paragraphs. He wants to learn about the individual behind it. He wants to connect with him on an emotional level. What Barthes fails to realize is that language is not a goal, it is a tool to express and connect human beings.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our University Degree Literary Criticism section.

(?)
Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related University Degree Linguistics, Classics and related subjects Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related University Degree Literary Criticism essays

  1. Exploring the power of the human Spirit in the Grapes of Wrath

    Steinbeck goes to great lengths throughout the novel to explore the theme of unity, and the shift from "I" to "We". This is first seen when Tom Joad returns home and becomes a unit with his family again. The emotive description of Ma in chapter 8, "She seemed to know,

  2. Sex, Shame and Guilt: Reflections on Bernhard Schlink's der Vorleser (the Reader) and J

    But even so, guilt always has a judicial dimension. However, once we begin to consider shame, we find ourselves in different territory. To quote Gabriele Taylor again, 'repayment and punishment are appropriate to guilt but not to shame'. (3) Shame is incomparably more diffuse than guilt.

  1. In what ways do ballads express enduring human condition?

    These themes can vary, from love, vanity of wishes to death, grief, resentment and fear; one will notice they all have in common that they are human emotions rather than anything else (i.e. talk of nature or other). They reflect events or ways of life, using their structure as a

  2. Abstract of Michel Foucaults "What is an Author?"

    Due to this fact writing itself kills the author. Foucault now describes the author as a creation of a text or writing. This implicates that the author is not the central subject designated to the text but is placed outside of what Foucault calls a "work" - the author is decentred.

  1. A short commentary on Roland Barthes Mother Courage Blind

    Brecht was a man of great culture, creativity and a sense of humor who influenced many of his time and still does now. What Brecht?s implies in this play is how great powers, in this sense the European powers use war as a profit venture.

  2. Angela Carters collection of stories, The Bloody Chamber, was published in 1979 and provides ...

    It is negative because it takes what is conceived to be outside language and subjectivity?woman?and shows that otherness to be an effect of representation. It is, most importantly, deconstructive because it does not just repeat and parody the opposition between male and female; it also takes the affirmative step of

  1. Is the meaning of a literary text created by the author, the reader or ...

    far above me, or too far below me; that mine was the middle state, or what might be called the upper station of low life, which he had found by long experience was the best state in the world, the most suited to human Happiness, not exposed to the miseries

  2. Perceptions of Death in Tuck Everlasting and Charlotte's Web

    She still shows an attachment to all life as she has not experienced the wonders of life yet; Fern?s life is incomplete. By comparing her life to Wilbur?s, Fern is showing her insecurities and fears regarding death.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work