There are many indications within the poetry of Tony Harrison that he considers his work within the context of the canon.

Authors Avatar

Elizabeth Murray 25/10/03                                                              Strategies of Reading Catherine Bates

‘Whether one thinks of the canon as objectionable because formed at random or to serve some interests at the expense of others, or whether one supposes that the contents of canons are providentially chosen, there can be no doubt that we have not found ways of ordering our thoughts about the history of literature and art without recourse to them.’ (Kermode, p.20).

In what ways do you believe Tony Harrison to be affected by the canon. Use analyses of the poem to illustrate your answer.

        There are many indications within the poetry of Tony Harrison that he considers his work within the context of the canon. The repeated referencing of other poets and conscious emulation of the form of other poems (‘v.’ is an adaptation of Gray’s ‘Elegy on a Country Churchyard’ ) suggest that Harrison’s work is heavily influenced by other poets, despite his seemingly original style. The way that he uses his referencing is not straightforward, however; it could be suggested that the more traditional references are ironic, as Harrison contrasts his brash modern style with the more ‘genteel’ feel of the poets in the canon. The continual allusions to the opposition his poetry has faced, and his subsequent under confidence, can have said to have led to a need for the reassurance of the canon: using the models of other poets to validate the worth of his own poetry. Alternatively, Harrison may feel that the only way to express the voice he wishes to project, that of a working class northern man with authority is by using the “enemy’s weapons”, and establishing a scholastic side to his work, in order to be taken seriously by the ‘cultural elite’.

        It has been argued that Harrison uses other people’s words and forms to justify his own work; that his feeling of social inferiority reveals itself as an insecurity in his poetry.Whereas in Gray’s ‘Elegy’ the last stanza is a contemplation upon the life of the poet, filled with a sense of repose, Harrison ends his epic poem ‘v.’ still striving to justify his choice to become a poet. By placing it as a viable occupation alongside other more manual lifestyles, such as the production of “the beef, the beer, the bread”, and anticipating possible reactions: “How poems can grow from (beat you to it!) SHIT”, Harrison tries to protect himself from derision. Critics relate the closing stanzas of “Elegy on a Country Churchyard” to Gray’s fears about his poetic destiny. Damien Grant states “The poet writes conscious of his own possible doom, to be ‘preserved beneath deep permaverse’ like any other victim of evolution”, but he is considering Harrison’s ‘epitaph’. By using a recognised canonical poet such as Gray, Harrison has a model to explore his feelings about his own destiny, investigating his own experiences regarding death: “taking a short cut home through the graves here/ they reassert the glory of their team/ by spraying words on tombstones, pissed on beer”, within a controlled and set form.

Join now!

The way that Harrison himself views the canon determines his reaction, and therefore his poetry. The canon could be construed as an enabling, useful force, giving Harrison ideas and structures to work with, and Harrison himself admits to the influence of classical authors, such as Milton. Altieri notes that “contemporary writers… need to address specific canonical works and engage the same degree of emotional and intellectual energy that canonical works provide”, and Harrison seems to have taken up this mantle, engaging it with his desire to keep poetry relevant to his experience and therefore, to him, alive. Harrison is not ...

This is a preview of the whole essay