To What Extent Is El Médico de su Honra principally a Play about Honour?

Extracts from this essay...

Introduction

To What Extent Is El Médico de su Honra principally a Play about Honour? The Code of Honour was an unwritten set of rules referring to social behaviour, which was the regulator in all social groups. The King, as the head of society, governed the code of honour. Wilson claims that due to the social basis of the code, the thought one had to keep in mind was that it was 'not so much to be, as to be seen to be' that mattered. This is supported by Menéndez Pidal who exclaimed 'Mas aunque la honra se gana con actos propios, depende de actos ajenos, de la estimación y fama que otorgan los demás.' Honour is a principal theme in El Médico de su Honra and to demonstrate this, one need only look at the many examples featured in the play. The first breach of the honour code occurs before the start of the play, when Don Arias visits his wife to be at Leonor's house.

Middle

However, unlike Coquín he does not question his belief that he should obey the code. There is another aspect of honour looked at in El Médico de su Honra. The first is 'del rey abajo ninguno', meaning nobody can take vengeance on him or others in his presence. This is why Enrique and Gutierre are put in prison. They draw swords before the King, which is usually a capital offence. The other aspect is 'soy quien soy', which is a phrase used by people of noble birth in Calderón's plays. Mencía is the first to use this expression as she finds herself in a testing situation. It can mean that the person knows their position in society and intend to live up to it. Gutierre later uses the same phrase; 'Mencía es quien es, / y soy quien soy'. Although one might immediately think that El Médico de su Honra is just a play about honour, there are other aspects of the play to be discussed; love, jealousy and fate.

Conclusion

Many incidents occur that all aid in pushing the play towards its conclusion. The first example is before the start of the play when Gutierre sees Arias leaving the house of his betrothed, Leonor. He breaks off their engagement and marries Mencía. At the beginning of Act 1, Enrique enters the scene as he falls off his horse. This physically fall is a hint at what is to come; the fall from honour of Enrique, by pursuing a married woman. Another clue as to the future of characters is when Pedro hands Enrique his dagger and it cuts the King's hand. The audience, knowing the history of the two half brothers, know that Enrique kills Pedro, but this occurrence also serves to indicate the death of Mencía. In my mind, El Médico de su Honra is principally about honour. Although I have mentioned other themes in this essay, they are all linked in some way to honour. Therefore, honour is present in every situation. Each character thinks of honour at some point because it is extremely easy to lose it, as we have seen from Gutierre, who is dishonoured just by the thought that his wife is being dishonest. Claire Blackburn, St Peter's

The above preview is unformatted text

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • Over 150,000 essays available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Over 180,000 student essays
  • Every subject and level covered
  • Thousands of essays marked by teachers

Related University Degree Much Ado About Nothing

  1. Theme of Love and War.

    (Shaw 1294, act 1). She acts as though she can continue to live in her ideal world forever and believes that she has found a true love in Sergius. As a couple, they put on a show for each other to prove their emotions are real.

  2. Much Ado About Nothing is a play in which language is a key focus.

    that there is a 'merry war' between them, 'They never meet but there's a skirmish of wit between them' (Act ? scene ?, lines 57-58) Shakespeare does this to show that Beatrice's character never likes to be out beaten, in which she always has to win the battle of tongues between herself and Benedick.

  1. Much Ado About Nothing … and love and wit and men and women…

    The possibility of love, and the strength of a woman such as Beatrice, is easily able to sway the seemingly stubborn Benedick far too easily. By the end of the play, it is evident that it is not only what Beatrice and Benedick say, but more importantly the methods and

  2. Look at Act 1 Scene 1 again of 'Much Ado About Nothing' by William ...

    By her saying this she means that no one is listening to Benedick and she means to make Benedick feel embarrassment. Benedick returns with just as hurtful a comment: "What my dear lady disdain! Are you yet living?" The banter continues in the same manner getting more vicious, sadistic and

  1. What are the most effective aspects of Aristophanes' comic technique in :

    Two of the plays Aristophanes parodies, Andromeda and Helen, were only produced at the Dionysia the previous year, 412 BC, so the storylines would be relatively fresh in the audience's minds. The first parody of a play,"Telephus" , in The Poet and the Women is one of the funniest scenes

  2. To what extent is “El médico de su honra” principally a play about honour?

    It is safe to say that Calderón used the former for variety and for purposes of rhyme and rhythm since "honra" is stressed on the first syllable and "honor" on the second. Honour is often embodied, in 'El Médico de su Honra' as social reputation by those involved in it.

  1. Explore Shakespeare's Presentation of Relationships in Messina.

    There is sufficient evidence for this throughout the play. Eg: in Act 2 Scene1 Claudio believes Don John when he tells him of Don Pedro trying to win Hero's heart. He also believes Don John later in the play when he tells him of Hero supposedly sleeping with another man.

  2. Act II, Scene II - Analyse Friel's dramatic presentation in this scene and how ...

    ("she turns away from him..."), it reveals more than Maire's misunderstanding; it is Friel showing the incompatibility of the two cultures, not so much that they don't want to come together, but that there will always exist numerous misunderstandings which are inevitable.

  • Over 180,000 essays
    written by students
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to write
    your own great essays

Marked by a teacher

This essay has been marked by one of our great teachers. You can read the full teachers notes when you download the essay.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review on the essay page.

Peer reviewed

This essay has been reviewed by one of our specialist student essay reviewing squad. Read the full review under the essay preview on this page.